Traffic stop leads to Franklin County farmworker deportation, Chittenden County Sheriff Deputy called Border Patrol

Posted

BERKSHIRE – A Franklin County farmworker is being deported, following his arrest by Border Patrol agents. 

Genri “Alex” Jimenez, 22, was a passenger in Anthony Cruz-Morales’ vehicle July 19 when Chittenden County Deputy Sgt. Scott Costella pulled the car over. The car did not have a front license plate. 

Costella later requested back up from Border Patrol, and agents subsequently detained Jimenez and began deportation proceedings to Mexico, according to reporting by nonprofit advocacy group Migrant Justice. 

How events unfolded

During the traffic stop July 19, Costella discovered the vehicle operator, Cruz-Morales, had recently purchased the vehicle, but had yet to register or insure it under his name. 

In an internal narrative statement, Costella said he went back and forth using Google Translate to clarify this information with Cruz-Morales.

The routine traffic stop turned into an immigration enforcement action after Costella requested federal Border Patrol agents “R16 James Lariviere” and “R4 Wesley Martin” to come on scene. 

After speaking with the driver and Jimenez, Costella returned to his vehicle and allegedly used his personal cellphone to text federal agents writing “need one of you.” 

In his statement, Costella said he was not aware of how many people were inside the vehicle. Seeing Jimenez and Cruz-Morales on their phones, he requested backup from Border Patrol. 

Two Border Patrol agents arrived 15 minutes later and asked questions to Jimenez and Cruz-Morales. As federal officers handcuffed Jimenez, Costella was there to hold him and lead him away, according to a body camera photo. 

Costella, in his statement, said he saw Jimenez “actively resisting” Border Patrol’s attempt to bring him into custody and ran up to the driver side window to record the activity and only placed his hands on Jimenez in case he were to fall forward while being cuffed. 

Jimenez was held at ICE sites in Vermont, New Hampshire and finally Louisiana before being deported to Mexico, according to Migrant Justice, separating him from a partner and family members who remain in state. 

Jimenez has worked on dairy farms in Franklin County for the past two years.

“It is an injustice that Alex and I have been separated,” Jimenez’s partner said in a press release, wishing to remain anonymous for fear of retaliation. “Border Patrol should have never been there. We should still be together.” 

A wider scene 

Migrant Justice argues the actions taken by Costella violated Vermont’s Fair and Impartial Policing Policy, which prohibits local law enforcement from helping federal authorities in civil immigration cases, unless there is threat to public or officer safety. 

Chittenden County Sheriff Dan Gamelin submitted a complaint to the Vermont Criminal Justice Council’s Professional Regulation Subcommittee July 28, regarding Sgt. Costella’s possible actions. 

In the complaint, Sheriff Gamelin states the Chittenden County office is conducting an internal review to see if the action is consistent with the agency’s Fair and Impartial Policing Policy. Gamelin told the Messenger an official press release from the department is forthcoming. 

It’s not the first time the Chittenden County office has been in hot water. According to Migrant Justice, the office paid $25,000 to Alex Ulloa after a 2019 traffic stop resulted in a deputy calling Border Patrol and subsequent deportation. 

“We have fought hard to create Vermont’s Fair and Impartial Policing Policy and have celebrated its implementation in this state,” Migrant Justice spokesperson Cristian Santos said in a release. “The policy has been clearly violated through the detention and deportation of Alex, a farmworker in our community.”

“This action shows us that where our rights are concerned, there is no difference between the police and ICE,” Santos continued. “We will not allow this to be swept under the rug: we demand justice for Alex and for an end to police collaboration with deportation agencies.”