ST. ALBANS CITY — Movie theaters have almost always seen better days.
In the 1950s, the rise of television gave movie-going audiences a reason to stay home. In the 80s, VHS tapes brought movies to home audiences away from theaters.
Today, the same industry-wide alarm bells are ringing – this time thanks to the Internet – as more and more theaters shut down across the country. Just between 2019 and 2022, the U.S. lost 5% of its movie screens.
But what will happen to the Welden Theatre?
Since its purchase by the City of St. Albans in April 2023, the Welden Theatre has seen some upgrades after recreation department workers tackled a few long-standing issues to refresh the place, but the theater’s future is still largely up-in-the-air as the city seeks out new leadership to manage it.
Vermont’s other movie theaters, however, have found ways to make it work.
Across the state, theaters in towns like St. Albans have discovered varying approaches to ensure they keep butts in seats. From Brattleboro to St. Johnsbury, movie theaters are leaning on their strengths as entertainment centers, communal spaces and avenues for discussion to survive the next expected industry contraction.
The trick?
“Our mantra here is that theaters are no longer the arbiters of content, we are the arbiters of experience,” Jon Potter, executive director of the Latchis Theater in Brattleboro, said. “Now you have to outcompete on experience, content and the natural inclination to stay home.”
People aren’t going to the movies like they used to. Talk to theater managers, and they tend to point to the COVID-19 pandemic and the explosion of content available online and at home as the primary reasons why typical movie-going audiences have dried up.
But they’ll also quickly point out that a movie theater is more than just a big screen.
For many theaters, relying singularly on film screenings as the only source of revenue has become more and more difficult post-pandemic. Vermont’s latest theater closure, for example, the Palace 9 in South Burlington, was the second largest multiplex in the state before former owner Merrill Jarvis III shut its doors, and Regal shuttered 39 of its multiplexes across the U.S. last year.
That has left many theater owners looking to diversification as a way out.
Out east, for example, Stowe Cinema has an attached bar serving drinks and a nearby golf simulator to diversify its offerings, while Waitsfield’s Big Picture does the majority of its business out of its attached cafe, owner Claudia Becker said. As for more art-focused nonprofits, they look to diverse programming outside mainstream offerings to bring in repeat fans.
“One of the things that we really try to nurture here is not only providing a space to watch movies, but to provide a space to connect with people with movies,” Andrea Otto, community liaison with Catamount Arts said.
Founded in 1975 in St. Johnsbury, Catamount Arts offers a full lineup of arts classes and programming, but most of their film lineup consists of independent and international fare. Over time, Otto said they’ve been able to create a strong regional audience that seeks out Catamount Arts’ eclectic offerings, such as live shows like Puccini’s “La Boheme,” which is simulcast to Catamount’s screens by the Metropolitan Opera.
“That has been such an incredible program and opportunity for our arts center, because we have a lot of musicians in our areas, people who love music, people who love opera,” she said. “The cameras are so close to the stage, so you can see these world class singers, sweating and crying, pouring everything into their performance.”
Latchis Arts also hosts the screenings in Brattleboro. Like Catamount Arts, the organization began with a focus on film, although Latchis Arts has expanded on that mission thanks to its 86-year-old theater. The Latchis Memorial Building houses the organization and features both movie screens and a main stage sitting 750, as well as a more expansive area for arts exhibits fronting Brattleboro’s Main Street .
That infrastructure already in place made it simpler to imagine the building as more than a movie theater, Potter said, as the space was already built with arts in mind.
The difficulty, however, has been finding what connects with audiences. During the pandemic, Potter said Latchis Arts found a lot of success in renting out its available space and screens, and the Brattleboro community began to rely on the service to help pull the organization through difficult times.
After doing some customer surveys, Potter said they recognized that people were seeking out the venue to create custom experiences for them and their friends. Some would use the avenue for large-screen gaming, or for children’s birthday parties, or to celebrate a wedding anniversary with a showing of a wedding video. Recognizing the differences in demand helped Latchis re-imagine the rental space for more customizability and recognize what people wanted.
“People still treasure going to the theater, but they wanted to customize their own experience,” he said. “We don’t have all the answers, but that really showed us one of the ways forward.”
Claudia Becker first purchased the Big Picture Theater & Cafe in Waitsfield out of the gate with the understanding that the business would likely need to diversify. Almost 20 years later, Big Picture has become a major hub for the town of roughly 1,900 people.
“It takes time and authentic heart and soul,” Becker said. “Theaters are not a particularly profitable endeavor no matter how you slice it.”
Instead, Big Picture’s success came from its larger communal role, she said. Starting out, Big Picture had to deal with some reputation issues – people were guessing that theaters would be closed soon then, too – but she was able to rally the support after cleaning up the space and responding to what people wanted.
Soon, more programming, like the MountainTop Film series, and repeat cafe customers eventually solidified the business’ role as a “third place” in the town. The term refers to public places outside a person’s home or work where the people feel comfortable interacting.
“I think as we’re losing third spaces more and more because we don’t have the mom ‘n pop stores, or the little cafes … that’s where the new role can be (for theaters),” Becker said.
Getting there took a lot of effort, she said. The theater has always been committed to offering a diverse lineup of both new and international movies, but it took time to find exactly what worked with the different groups in the Waitsfield community to be able to bring them in on a weekly basis.
Sometimes that required some creative guesswork. Becker said they “threw spaghetti at the wall” on more than one occasion to see what stuck, and they eventually found success after discovering the theater's particular voice and niche.
Cinemas especially are served well by either being “cute” or “luxurious,” Becker said.
“If it’s held together by Duct tape, that’s wicked cute,” she said. “Especially in a world where everything has become so homogenized. Most of the businesses in Waitsfield have a real mom and pop feel, that authentic funky-fun down-to-earth Vermont feel. You need anything that makes (a business) stand out.”
That way, the quality of the movie itself isn’t nearly as important, she said, as the movie-going experience becomes the primary focus as well as the primary draw.
As for the Welden’s plans, city organizers have instituted a few additional programs. The city’s Belonging, Equity and Inclusion Committee rolled out a “Movies that Matter” film series, and the theater has hosted free movies on Wednesday nights sporadically.
The next stage of the Welden, however, will largely be up to its next round of leadership (and City Council), recreation director Kelly Viens said. The city released an ad looking for a theater manager in June, and Viens said they’re hoping the new manager will be able to bring some ideas to the table, expand what they’ve already accomplished and hold more special events like they have in the past.
Viens pointed to a Polar Express movie showing event held last Christmas, which drew in roughly 250 people.
“That movie is not new; it was the experience,” she said. “The kids came in their pajamas. We had cookies and golden tickets, and they got to see Santa Claus at the end. … That's what we’re looking to do. We want to expand on that and do some more fun events.”
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here