The future of Fairfax: What Article 4 means for voters

Posted

FAIRFAX – At Town Meeting this year, residents of Fairfax will vote on the future style of the town’s government. 

Article 4 asks if residents want to rescind the town manager position. This question was put on the ballot following a petition last year calling to remove the form of government. 

Although it’s up to a vote, residents and the selectboard must consider what happens if it passes, what the implications are, what duties will be given to the board and what happens next. 

Residents voted to move Fairfax to a town manager form of government back in 2017, after selectboard members said at the time it was becoming too challenging and taxing to take care of everyday responsibilities in the growing town. 

“I was a selectboard member a long time ago and I would caution anyone in our community that [says] we can go back to that,” resident Barbara Murphy told the selectboard in August. “It’s way too much to ask of a volunteer member of our community. There's no way a member board could run our town again. It would be very difficult.” 

The vote was approved 407 to 325. The town first hired Brad Docheff as town manager in 2018, followed by Sarah Hadd in 2021.

In the eight years since, the town has continued to evolve, growing its population and expanding its services. 

Now Fairfax sits at a crossroads with this vote; the town currently employs an interim town manager with Nicholaus Nadeau, but he is only with the town until the end of March to settle the next selectboard. 

What happens after the vote can push the board into finding a replacement manager, starting a new form of governance with an administrator or taking on a host of responsibilities they haven’t carried since 2017. 

Selectboard powers

Earlier this month, the Vermont League of Cities and Towns gave a presentation to the selectboard on the difference between an administrator and manager, as well as the workload the selectboard has with each. 

Under state statute, the selectboard has general supervisory authority for matters in the town and essentially performs all duties not given by law to any particular officials. 

Staff Attorney Carl Andeer said in a town without a manager or administrator, the board serves all three roles in government – executive, legislative and judicial. 

“The selectboard really has a hand in all these things,” he said. “Legislatively, you’re adopting policies and ordinances. For the executive branch you’d be the HR head and supervising all employees and department heads. Judicial branch, you’re on the board of civil authority hearing tax exemptions and vicious dog hearings.” 

Part of the reason why a town moves to administrative heads is because of the large amount of work which comes with managing those three branches. 

The other reasons, Andeer said, come in government efficiency. Vermont utilizes open meeting law which requires the selectboard perform all duties during public meetings – and a majority of the board to agree on an action. 

“You can’t make a decision based on individual members, you have to make it as a group,” Andeer said. “That’s a barrier to efficiency for the town to get action done…in terms of time and how many people are making decisions to get things done.”

When town voters approve the move to a town manager, the executive portion of duties essentially moves into the town manager's hands. 

Instead of managing everyday decisions, Andeer said the selectboard instead becomes like the captain of a ship, while the manager ends up as the navigator. 

“With this form of government, the selectboard has ultimate oversight over the manager, but the board is more like directing a cruise ship, and setting goals and policy for the town,” he said. “The manager is saying ‘these are the goals and policies I’ve been told and I will be the one to implement that. I will be the one turning the wheel as the selectboard has set it.’” 

Town manager vs. administrator 

In order for a town to hire a manager, the registered voters of the town have to approve the position – like Fairfax did previously – during a Town Meeting vote. The administrator, however, can be appointed at any time and can serve on other elected boards. 

Managers are also given stronger job security and cannot be fired at-will like an administrator. Part of that job security comes from the fact that administrators are only given powers based on what the board delegates, unlike the manager who receives powers from state law. 

“The idea is administrative function and this [manager] person is doing a job professionally in letting the selectboard present policy in terms of politics," Andeer said. “I’ve seen elected clerks be administrators or admin assistants do tasks on behalf – but a manager can’t hold an elected position. They have one job. They are there to efficiently administer the obligations of the town.”

Town managers are also hired on as a nonpolitical professional, whereas the administrator position has less hiring restrictions, but therefore is required to do a lot more coordination and preparation with the selectboard than a manager. But the trade-off there is the board’s progress is slower. 

Andeer said he also believes administrators require more work of the selectboard because they have to designate what the administrator’s powers are. 

“If it’s not clear, there’s confusion about where the lines are about administrating employees, for example,” he said. “While in a manager form it’s clear and a delineated position that most people know the manager is the head of departments in the town.” 

In practice of day-to-day operations, however, the manager and administrator forms of governance function similarly. 

No matter what the town’s governance is, the selectboard’s goals will always be to communicate its vision and desires to the person, dictate policy and write job descriptions. The manager or administrator’s goals are to always carry out the board's wishes and follow the town’s policies and ordinances. 

Next steps for the board

Regardless of the vote on Town Meeting Day, the incoming selectboard will ponder a change in leadership and some uncertainty. 

After the vote, residents are able to request a redo within 30 days according to state statute. This halts immediate action from the board. 

“There is time after [the vote] someone could petition to redo the town vote, so I would caution the selectboard would want to wait until consideration of revote has passed,” Andeer said. 

If the board takes up action too soon, it could open the town up to legal challenges. 

While the board waits to move forward with an administrator, they first need to wrap up the manager form of governance and deal with the responsibilities being placed back on to the town’s elected board.

Editor’s Note: This article was updated at 7:23 a.m. Feb. 20. The town manager question is article 4 on the ballot, not 5. 

#sanltop

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here