'The facts aren’t going to appeal to everybody'; Insights into how social media is harming the conversation

Posted

FRANKLIN COUNTY — Al Voegele might be the hardest working 84-year-old in St. Albans.

Go to any public meeting, and he’s sitting in the corner, listening and absorbing – as he’s done for a lifetime.

Voegele started adding to the public conversation around 1977 – in his late 30s – with his face printed in the newspaper alongside an article pointing out the learned behaviors associated with alcohol, and he’s been engaged with some level of government or community service since.

Why? Voegele said he’s seen the consequences of good governance first hand, with actions taken 50 years ago still delivering for those in need.

Now, he has a new worry that the same isn’t being considered in the 21st century.

“I don’t know how to get people to think about the future,” he said.

All work, no play

Nicole Draper runs Swanton’s Department of Recreation from a tiny office and an attached garage. But spend any time talking to her, and it quickly becomes apparent how fiercely proud Draper is of her community.

“We don’t want to just continue to be the redheaded stepchild of Franklin County, or St. Albans,” Draper said. “(Swanton) wants to be a place. We want people to see how proud we are of the community that we’ve grown here and continue to grow.”

Her challenge, however, is convincing other residents to believe the same thing in today’s information ecosystem. While Draper is a fountain of enthusiasm for Swanton and its future, she’s having a hard time getting the message through.

Suzie Kelleher, a newly-elected Village of Swanton trustee, is a partner in the effort. 

After Kelleher won a seat at the table this past Town Meeting, she’s been an active proponent of Swanton, quickly finding her stride as a community organizer. The two women, working together, helped launch Swanton’s summer block party – a response to downtown disruptions around the town’s closed Veterans Memorial Bridge – and now they’re focused on promoting the town within the wider state.

As Draper pointed out, Swanton rarely makes it to the list of Vermont’s headlining recreation spots, but the two women think they have enough material to make their point. Swanton itself sits on a confluence of a lake, a river, a wildlife refuge and rail trail to create a playground for hikers, cyclists and reelers, but locals don’t always recognize what’s in their backyard.

“I’ve lived in Swanton since I was five. I’ve been to the refuge twice,” Kelleher said. “It’s just we have these underutilized resources that I think we’re just trying to figure out a way to market them to everybody. And that’s kind of the thing that we’re running into right now. Marketing costs money.” 

The two women have tried to rally community members to help. While the Swanton Enhancement Project has a dedicated core of volunteers, it’s often the same core people at every meeting, at every committee, at every event.

“We do what we can. We have all these little committees from SEP that are working really hard to make things happen in our town, but it's always the same 15 people,” Kelleher said.

To take it to the next step, they need more people to show up.

Kelleher was elected, in part, on a message of improving local transparency and local trust after the village’s $19 million bond project cratered at the polls. In that effort over the last few months, she’s spent time trying to be more active and being more communicative.

But her viewpoint has evolved as she’s been on the receiving end of social media complaints. As an example, she explained how she relayed some information about a federal mandate to check lead in people’s pipes. 

The comment section erupted in negativity as a result.

“I’m trying to share information as a trustee about something that’s important,” she said. “And I’m getting people who aren’t even reading the information, people making assumptions about the information … and just not engaging in the post in the manner and the spirit that the post was intended.”

“Then people go – I thought you were going to be the trustee that would engage on social media,” Kelleher said. “But I am and I do.”

Draper, who has been working at this issue for the last several years, knows the challenge well.

“Even though I see many local governments trying to portray factual information on social media, it’s getting more of an emotional response than a factual one,” she said. “I mean, there is every different kind of human interacting on a platform that it’s hard to target one group still with that factual information, because the facts aren’t going to appeal to everybody.”

No trust for the weary

At Montgomery’s latest selectboard meeting held Sept. 18, Chair Charlie Hancock faced a contentious audience when town residents brought the board 120 signatures on two articles asking for a re-vote concerning the town’s wastewater project. Citing legal counsel, the selectboard denied the petition, as the rules for referendums can differ on bonds for public utility systems. 

Some Montgomery residents, however, have labeled the total maneuver a “bait-and-switch.” The term applies to a fraudulent sales tactic where the initial offer is recanted to screw over the buyer. 

Hancock said he did not face the same level of anger when the project was first proposed in 2020.

“There’s this tension,” he said. “There’s these financial constraints that people are seeing due to general high inflation and education funding. And those are coming together with – what some folks see – as an outsider’s perspective of what the state thinks towns should do.”

As chair, Hancock has led Montgomery through the initial wastewater bond vote in 2020 and has been an advocate for the project since, but the change in scope – due to increasing prices on everything – scrapped a major part.

The resulting public backlash from the change in scope has kept Hancock stressed more than he’d like. After spending hundreds – if not thousands – of hours on the effort after a majority of Montgomery residents voiced support for it, a vocal group online has cornered the conversation. 

Hancock sits at the center of it, being portrayed as a huckster online, and whatever is added to the conversation is often rolled out as evidence of malicious intentions.

“How we communicate with each other makes it even harder,” he said. “It’s one thing to sit with someone and talk. It's something completely different to go on social media, which is where so much of this is occurring.”

“It’s cliche, but nothing good happens in the comment section,” he added. “It makes it hard. We lose that defining sense of community that really makes these towns special.”

Hancock said he’s seeing similar problems across Vermont as town residents seem to be reacting to the state’s increasing unaffordability, hypercharged by a political conversation that normalizes anger, hyperbole and divisiveness. Apathy is high. Public trust is low.

The result is local development projects – no matter the need – are falling flat out of the gate. Once the crowd gets involved, real worries about increasing prices overtake the rest of the conversation, drowning out the efforts of the already thin line of community players involved in each town.

“The village voted me in to be their voice, right?” Kelleher said, over in Swanton. “So, they have to – at some point – have some kind of trust that I’m going to do the right thing for them, like they’ve entrusted me to do.”

Bigger coffers

Amy Brewer knows what it can take to make change.

She recently won one of her long standing battles in downtown St. Albans by removing tobacco advertising from being displayed across from BFA-St. Albans.

It took her almost two decades to get it done.

The opportunity came during a development review board meeting when the building was turned over to From Scratch, a new business. A few of her close contacts alerted her when the discussion finally came into the public eye after she advocated for the change.

“It’s 15, 20 years of me saying the same things to the same people who are already listening, who trusted me and could then take the message, integrate it into their work and make that suggestion at the right time to not miss that,” she said.

But then again, that’s how everything in government works. There’s a process on every level of government. 

And Brewer knows well that there’s entire industries devoted to stopping that process. Her official day-job is as the coordinator of the Franklin -Grand Isle Tobacco Prevention Coalition. When she isn’t helping groups pick up bags of cigarette butts, her duties include working to inform the statewide conversation around anti-smoking initiatives, including recent state congressional efforts to eliminate flavored tobacco products.

“We use (policy) within the realm of public health to find ways to protect the greatest number of people in a way,” she said. “To do that one person at a time, it would take forever.”

The bill made it to Gov. Phil Scott’s desk, but he vetoed it. In his letter sent to the general assembly explaining the decision, Scott said the law was inconsistent around the state’s actions around alcohol and cannabis use.

“I’ve found people lose faith in government when policies have these types of inconsistencies, because they contradict common sense,” Scott wrote.

When Vermont got close to actually passing the law, Brewer said she saw a spike in ads combatting the no flavor tobacco bill. Like clockwork, organizations who could potentially lose money from fewer smokers showed up to contest the loss of customers.

Brewer said that was the whole point of the bill. 

Research shows that increasing the price of tobacco decreases the number of smokers and increases overall public health. Governments do it all the time with so-called “sin taxes,” including Vermont’s 14% excise tax on cannabis.

“They had ads – on television, social media – everywhere you looked. They had ads that said this was going to harm small businesses. … There’s no evidence of that,” she said. “(Tobacco industry groups) have money to run those ads. … and they did things like put out QR codes, like ads here in the convenience stores.”

The bill was ultimately defeated, and smoking use is up in Franklin County year-over year, Brewer said. Meanwhile, about a third of high school students vape.

“You’re going to give local businesses a boost based on the death and disease and addiction of other people, and the costs that are associated to our society with that decision. And nobody said that out loud,” Brewer said

“The industry has more money, more organizing power, more people and fewer guardrails,” she added. “But if they can encourage people just to question, then it bleeds down (to decision makers).”

Facing the change

As a former town manager and selectboard member, Voegele has seen a lot of interactions between the public and government officials, but he’s worried about the latest discussions and about what the future holds.

Politicians on the national stage take potshots at each other whenever they can. Facts and feelings are all mixed up. Social media encourages brevity and high emotion posts, which are antithesis to slow, fact-based government processes. 

And the problem is coming home to roost. Local government officials are voicing concerns that the quality of the public conversation is deteriorating to the point where any attempt for change – good or bad – is becoming the target of naysayers and nihilists.

Add Vermont’s upcoming demographic into the mix, and the future is even hazier. The number of working-age adults will be outnumbered by (mostly) seniors and children by 2040, and if the negativity propagated by people’s online lives continues, there will likely be fewer and fewer people like Al Voegele – adults working lifelong to envision their communities’ future. 

“At what point do you go all-in on your community?” Kelleher said. “If you’re not all-in on your community, then I guess there’s really not much anybody can do, right?”

“How do you get the whole community to trust you?” Brewer asked.

Meanwhile, there’s no singular solution, or immediate fixes. More likely, it will be messy – just like the government always is.

“The more I talk about it, the more resistance I get about the future. They say, ‘We don’t want change,’” Voegele said. “There’s no way to stop change. The only thing that doesn’t change is change.”

#sanltop

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here