ST. ALBANS — Vermonters have donated over $4 million to the 2024 presidential campaigns. But as Democrats turn their eyes south, will Vermont Republicans find an opportunity to add to their ranks at the State House?
A review of the latest campaign finance numbers reveal how the different political actors have been spending their dollars while Harris and Trump hog the national spotlight.
While 2024 has brought with it a contentious national political season, the number of down ballot races has been uncharacteristically sparse.
Outside of the presidential race, only five races affecting Franklin County voters feature active campaigns. They include two statewide offices – for lieutenant governor and governor – as well as the three legislative races for seats representing St. Albans, Enosburgh and Montgomery.
Here’s a quick review of how spending has played out in each race.
To secure the state’s top executive seat, Gov. Phil Scott is expected to easily win against Democratic challenger Esther Charlestin.
In the 2022 election, Scott ended up with a 47-point spread against then challenger Brenda Siegel, who ran a spirited campaign that spent $167,000 to unseat the popular Republican governor.
In comparison, Scott’s 2024 campaign has spent more this year buying campaign ads than the total amount his total campaign raised two years ago. Charlestin, meanwhile, has raised roughly $40,000.
As for Scott’s message, it’s been pretty clear.
“I need you to support common sense candidates for the legislature who will actually work with me and meet me in the middle,” Scott said during the Oct. 29 WCAX candidate debate.
The four-term governor’s political message has largely blamed the Democrat-controlled state legislature for continued affordability issues in Vermont, making repeated calls to voters to elect legislators willing to work with Scott.
The resulting political disagreement between the executive and legislative branches this year has resulted in Scott’s priority to keep property taxes low – a consistent talking point pushed by Republicans across the state.
While most people expect Scott to run away with the vote, the lieutenant governor’s race will likely be a much closer matchup, if campaign finance is any indicator.
In the race, Lt. Gov. David Zuckerman faces former Democratic legislator John Rodgers after he flipped his party affiliation to Republican, and the two men’s campaigns have faced much closer competition while trying to raise funds.
This September, for example, Rodgers ended up outraising the incumbent candidate, and he’s already spent more than Zuckerman this campaign season, spending tens of thousands alongside Scott with Burlington-based Hen House Media to create political video ads and commercials for the two candidates.
In comparison, Zuckerman and Democratic campaign spending shows a much different tactic as they engage with social media and email marketing firms to help drum up support from their online voter base.
Age likely plays a role when comparing the two approaches. While almost everyone has some presence on the Internet, younger people – who typically lean left – are less engaged in so-called legacy media, such as radio, newspapers and television, than their older brethren. The national election, however, could scramble all those suppositions.
With high turnout expected, Zuckerman will likely benefit from those voters who will vote “D” all the way down the ballot in response to anti-Trump sentiment.
Rodgers, however, could win if he can give fiscally conservative Democrats a good enough reason to split their own tickets. By flipping his own party status, Rodgers helps give those voters permission to make the differentiation between national and local conservatives, while relying on Trump voters to carry him over the line.
The three representative races in Franklin County all have varying degrees of financial backing, but there are definitely some patterns in the financial noise.
The biggest campaigns, by spending, focus on the face-off between Rep. Mike McCarthy and Republican challenger Joe Luneau. Two years ago, McCarthy ended up landing more than 250 votes over Luneau to help cinch his position as St. Albans representative, eventually landing him on the peripheries of House leadership. But Luneau has created real momentum as he outraised and outspent McCarthy this election cycle.
In large media buys, Luneau spent three times the amount McCarthy dedicated to advertising with repeated mailers purchased and sent to property owners and display ads purchased to propagate his message online. In total, Luneau had $24,000 for his campaign, while McCarthy had roughly $11,000, according to secretary of state data.
In comparison, the other two races feature much smaller ad-buys from Republican candidates. Rep. Casey Toof, the Republican candidate who represents St. Albans, hasn’t spent a dollar this election season. Meanwhile, Allen “Penny” Demar’s biggest purchases have been $500 for advertising postcards.
On the revenue side, Toof and Demar have done some fundraising this cycle, although their contributions often come from the state’s larger Republican fundraising network. Listed contributions include those from fellow politicians, political action committees and other large donors seen on other contributor lists.
The two Democratic newcomers running against Toof and Demar, however, have been building up their own war chests in response. Both Zach Scheffler’s – running against Toof – and Heather Moore’s campaigns – facing Demar – have both raised over $6,000 during the 2024 season.
The two Democratic campaigns have spent the funds getting their messages out via postcards and yard signs deployed throughout their districts in order to make a dent in the Republican response.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here