SWANTON — Three candidates are vying for the two seats in the Vermont House representing the towns of Swanton and Sheldon.
Republican incumbents Matthew Walker of Swanton and Thomas Oliver of Sheldon are facing a Democratic challenger in Tamar Bouchard of Swanton.
Carmela Mayette withdrew her campaign for medical reasons.
To help readers get to know the candidates before Election Day, the Messenger asked each the same questions. Answers are edited for length and clarity.
WALKER: I felt the work I did as Chair of the House Transportation Committee the last biennium, it was very gratifying to actually be able to accomplish something and do something I can point at that I was able to help towns across all the State of Vermont.
Primarily, I’m talking about highway funding, highway and bridge projects. Towns hadn’t received an increase in state aid in 16 years, and in the first year of the biennium, I was able to put through an inflation adjuster so at the very least every year moving forward, the amount of aid that goes through the towns, which is divided up by the amount of mileage they have, will increase by an inflation adjuster for highway construction projects. Then this year, we were able to work on another way of going about highway funding and increasing the town aid.
And, as a Republican chair of one of only two Republican chairs out of the 14 committees, to work to accomplish something like that was very satisfying, and that is the largest reason why I want to go back is to continue to work in the area that I’ve been assigned to and find more ways to help the towns.
OLIVER: I want to continue to be a strong voice for Sheldon and Swanton. I have four years of experience serving on the House Judiciary Committee and the Joint Committee on Judicial Retention. My lifelong career in law enforcement, including decades of working directly within the judiciary, gives me a unique, informed perspective backed by practical experience. My education and career background have also provided me with a strong understanding of both criminal and civil law.
BOUCHARD: I am a native Vermonter, I care so much about our state. I’ve been mulling over running for a while, and there’s a lot going on in the world and in our country right now that I am not happy with. Instead of whining and crying, I actually want to see what I can do to help.
I have a master’s of education so I feel I have some qualification to look at the education issue and school funding. When I moved to Swanton in 2021, I immediately got drawn into politics here because people needed help, so I was like “Well, how can I help?” I ran for Justice of the Peace and got in there, then there was an opening at the town’s clerk office and I was there for two years as assistant town clerk. People came in all the time just struggling with the cost of taxes and those things that have increased in price inflation. To be helpful in Montpelier is to figure out how we can reduce costs, whatever we have to do to make things a little bit more affordable in Vermont.
WALKER: We could pick whatever topic you want to focus on in the campaign, but in the legislature, and especially as a minority party member, you are assigned the committee that you’re going to be in, and that is where you’re going to spend your time. I have spent my five years in transportation, the last two as chair, and I put most of my energy into that area.
Certainly, for statewide issues, school reform has to continue to move forward. That’s the biggest issue the state needs, followed by healthcare costs. I’m not an expert in either one, but when you look at the demographics of the state, and you look at the expense for the state, and you look at what’s hurting Vermonters and property taxes and healthcare costs, those are the two largest and need the most work.
OLIVER: My specialty is public safety, but housing, healthcare and education are all equally important and success in each helps reduce criminality. How do I plan on addressing them? I support cutting unnecessary regulations that drive up housing costs, and finding sustainable ways to bring down healthcare costs as well as Vermont’s high property taxes. We must make education spending more efficient while increasing quality. Public safety is also essential, and I will continue to support all first responders and law enforcement. The key is getting legislators to work together toward real solutions that work toward a more efficient and effective government.
BOUCHARD: With education, I want to work on whatever we’re doing to make it more affordable. The can has to stop getting kicked down the road, so that is very important to me. Figuring out what we need to do to contain costs.
I feel like healthcare is a human right and we should think about healthcare as single payers, or Medicare for all, though it’s more of a national question, but we talked about doing this when we did Vermont Healthcare for All. There are so many places where it would reduce our costs if we could figure something like that out.
I’m also a realtor, so housing is very much on my mind. I watched those prices go up, and I benefited a little from that too, but at the same time, I know how hard it is for first-time homebuyers to even enter the market. Even if you have the money, sometimes it’s hard to find the kind of home you want to live in because we have such a housing shortage, and if you’re renting you’re at the mercy of the landlord and however much they want to charge are just adding to our costs and making it really tough especially for young people here in Vermont.
WALKER: Everybody went to school, so everybody’s got an opinion on how schools should be run. How they’re financed, and how they’re handled is not something we’ve all been involved in.
What I really focus on when I’m involved in that conversation is the demographics. I don’t think people truly understand where we’re headed. As an example, I graduated Northfield High School in 1987 and we had 89 graduates and this year Northfield graduated 29 kids. You can’t keep a school alive with 29 kids at the same level of costs. If I asked you to throw a birthday party for everyone who turns 65 this year, you’d have to find a building for 13,650 Vermonters. If I throw a birthday party for everyone turning one, I only need to find a building to hold 5,000 Vermonters. The numbers are not just dropping; they are dropping faster than we’re recognizing, and I think we have to move forward on a level of change, whether or not we’re willing to make the hard decisions anytime soon.
If you talk about a political change, that’s going to take years to agree on, years to implement, by the time you start to see the benefits of it, you’re going to be below 60,000 students. That’s why we have to make changes. The obvious areas are the Montpelier area, the Burlington area, the Rutland area. In Rutland, you’ve got nine school systems within 20 minutes of each other, and all on significantly declining enrollment. I don’t want to close them. I do think we have the resources to keep every elementary school in each local community, but I think you have to look at what if there’s a different structure for middle school, for junior high school and senior high school.
OLIVER: It is too expensive now and families urgently need relief. Vermonters need a better understanding of where their money is going, and we need to focus on measurable results in the classroom. I believe a foundation formula is the best way to start. It is also imperative that communities maintain as much input as possible, but we cannot hand out blank checks that affect other Vermont schools that are spending within their means.
BOUCHARD: I think thoughtful consolidation makes sense. I did like that at one point they landed on it being voluntary, because I know in the greater Burlington area, you have Burlington, South Burlington kind of teamed up to try and share some resources. I mean it started with football a few years ago and has continued to go forward. I know it’s hard when you’re out in the hinterlands and there’s a lot of distance between towns, a lot of different distances between one edge of a county and another. I understand a lot of that, and I also understand wanting to maintain local control. But, we had to move from one room schoolhouses to what we have now. So if we have to make other kinds of changes, let’s think about that, let’s see what will save us money.
WALKER: Property taxes are what I hear the most from. Now locally in Swanton, issues with the electric company are huge, but those weren’t state-created or state-controlled. I feel the pain when they add the property tax increases and they add what is happening then to the electric rates. It’s just really a double whammy. Then you add the price of fuel, again a federal issue, not something you can do anything about here in Swanton. Our people are really struggling. The people here need some level of tax relief on property taxes and they need some help.
We have to have some education finance reform and I will continue the work I’ve been doing in transportation to continue to find ways to help provide relief to towns across Vermont. I’d like to see a continued effort to see business develop that supports the tourism aspect.
OLIVER: Primarily, we hear about affordability. To coin the phrase we have all heard, "Vermont has a spending problem, not a revenue problem." We need to look back historically and see what was working with things like our schools, highways, rent and homes. We became comfortable with all of the Covid-era government funding that is now gone, yet we still have to fund programs that were started with those monies. We also have to be honest about what hasn’t worked, which is a much harder conversation that requires everyone to come to the table in good faith in order to get to real solutions.
My plan is to continue to vet expenditures as I would my own. We have to be responsible to our constituents, just as responsible as we are for our own families. Those fortunate to be elected to serve our neighbors need to remember that it is not the government’s money, it is the people’s and we must always treat it that way.
BOUCHARD: I feel like the biggest issues impacting our district are – it’s definitely housing, though it’s a bit more affordable here, but we still are lacking in housing. We’re definitely lacking in opportunities that make sense and match up to the cost of housing. We could use more employers up here. We could use some type of transportation to get people who are out and about into places where they can work because without a car in the state of Vermont, you’re really in trouble and if you’re not making a lot of money or just starting out and you don’t have access to transportation, you’re going to struggle because there’s not going to be a lot there for you.
I’m a really good listener, and I’m an even better advocate. I had a lot of time in nonprofit work and in serving the community in lots of different ways. I really care about people and I want them to be okay. I’m more solutions oriented than I am judgemental. So if somebody comes to me with whatever, I worked in crisis. There’s nothing you can say to me that’s shocking. I don’t care about the identity politics nonsense, I just care about people and that they’re okay.
WALKER: As chair, and having two years for it, I would want to continue my work in the house transportation committee. Outside of that, because education reform is such a critical area, I think that whether it be on appropriations or ways and means would be the other two committees that I would want to serve on. But, as chair of transportation, I feel I sort of have to continue that work now. I’ve got some experience in it and have an even better understanding of how to move forward.
OLIVER: I have been on the House Judiciary Committee and would like to continue. It is a good fit for me given my unique perspective. That committee usually has a number of lawyers, as well as folks who have no real experience with the legal system. I think having an actual practitioner in the room is helpful while working on policy because it brings in a different perspective.
BOUCHARD: I definitely would like to be on education. I would like to be on housing. I would like to be on economic development because I'm a project manager for the City of Burlington and I also sell houses as a realtor. I have my fingers in a lot of pies, and economic development will help us in a lot of ways, and saving money on education will help us in a lot of ways, and housing helps us more than anything.
WALKER: I was born and raised here and there’s a combination of sort of old school Vermont with the pride of your house and your property and you should have your rights to be able to do what you want to do and then there’s a certain level of, I really like a lot of the direction that Vermont has gone in terms of tourism and expansion. In terms of there’s a lot to do here, whether you’re an outdoor person, hiking, biking, then obviously skiing and winter sports. I want to continue to see that area grow, but I was very much brought with the sort of you should be able to do yours and get along with your neighbors. Like the state motto Freedom and Unity. How do you balance the freedom of each individual and their property?
OLIVER: I would like to see a Vermont where families can grow, have kids and be a place where their kids can afford to stay, feel secure and most importantly, want to live. I believe that is what we need. Vermonters are a tough bunch and can put up with a lot, but we are asking too much of them right now. We owe it to hard working Vermonters to turn the tide on decades of our state becoming less safe and less affordable and watching our kids move away. We can do it if we commit to working together.
BOUCHARD: I want us to get back to the Vermont that was open to progress and new ideas, and coming together as a community to solve problems while supporting each other, instead of all of the oppositional stuff that’s going on or the judgemental stuff going on where if you’re not this exact ideology, then you’re no good. I think we all have to remember we’re people trying to do the best we can and we need to work together to solve our problems.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here