Swanton Village Trustee President race: Q&As with Neal Speer and David Winchester

Posted

SWANTON — Two local races this Town Meeting Day are shaking up representation on the Village of Swanton board of trustees. 

In the first race, two newcomers — Shayne Mott and Suzie Kelleher — are looking to fill the seat previously held by Chris Leach, who retired from the board this past year.

In the second race for village president, longtime incumbent Neal Speer faces a challenge from David Winchester. 

Q&As from both Mott and Kelleher can be found here.

Info on the two village president race candidates can be found below.

Neal Speer

What qualifications/experiences would you bring to the board of trustees?

Outside of a few terms in the early 2010s, Neal Speer has served as the village board’s president since 1999. In his professional career, Speer runs his own construction contracting business.

“I got on the board in ‘99 because our downtown was disintegrating. The old Blouin store was sold. I’d been in the community all my life, I’d done business with people in Swanton and around Swanton so I thought I could help revitalize the downtown because its my hometown, and I wanted to help out.”

“I believe that there’s three things that I’m contributing to the committee. One is humility. I don’t believe leaders in any position can go in with an overactive ego and think they’re going to change the world. You have to listen to the people that put you in the position and try to do what’s best for our community, not what’s best for me or a couple of people. With that humility in mind, you try to build a team. I give credit to past and present board of trustees and the village managers, we’ve built a lot of great teams in the electric, police, fire, streets departments, in administration. …

Third, you got to have trust in why they’ve been there so long. Everyone in our system trusts each other. We trust their judgment and there’s a lot coming up that I can contribute to, because I have the experience in the way our teams work together.”

Why are you interested in running for village board president?

“I see the positive things that are possible and I want to be involved in them because I’ve been involved in a lot of positive things that happened in the past ten years, so that’s why I threw my hat in the ring again.”

“We got the water line, the relicensing of the hydroelectric dam, the downtown revitalization, we’ve got Gordon and Debbie Winters spearheading the downtown revitalization and a lot of positive things going on. And I hope after next Tuesday, whatever happens doesn't upset the good things.” 

​​What do you think the board does well? What would you like to see change, or improve?

“I believe the board is working very well together, and the present board has been together for quite a while. Humility and trust is the key to working together. I believe we have that, and I hope that continues. There’s a lot of positive things that are coming the town’s and village’s way, and I’d like to see the selectboard and board of trustees work more cohesively to be better together.”

What are your top priorities, if elected to the board of trustees?

“My top priority is public safety. … We definitely need to improve or add to our operational space. If the public safety building doesn't go through, we have to do something and we're going to have to work together to improve the lack of space, and whatever happens, I hope that ‘s one of the premier issues for the year to come. … There are a lot of things going on with the Swanton (Village Police Department) that Swanton police are working on. A lot of people don’t realize the volatility around our community that the police have been addressing.”

“When keeping taxes under control, that’s an iffy issue, but everybody is asking for more because it’s costing more to live. We have to work together to find the best solution.”

​​How would you maintain a line of communication between yourself and the people you’re elected to serve?

“Social media is a necessity, sometimes a volatile necessity. We have recently upgraded our communications with the public with a new website. That’s another thing with the town that’s been positive, we combined forces for the swanton town and village website, that's been good as it gets the info out there. The Facebook page, we try to put the truth out, instead of all the other options to view, so I think we’re in better shape with the community with this bond vote. We’ve had 37 open houses. The turnout hasn’t been really great, but we did stir things up, no doubt about it.” 

Do you support expanded policing? Why or why not?

“I would like to be able to support the police expansion. I am in favor of the public safety building, but I do realize that the big concern is that it’s a big price tag. And like we’ve said in the past open houses, it’s a worst case scenario. If the bond passes, I’m hoping we can get grants and funding to really reduce that cost big time, but if the bond doesn't go through, I still support the police department. I think they’re doing a fantastic job, and I don't think that’s an issue with the public.” 

“But we have to do something to keep our communities safe. The majority realizes that and if it’s not with a new public safety building, we have to do something to keep the community safe.” 

David Winchester

What qualifications/experiences would you bring to the board of trustees?

“I grew up here in the village, and I’m very familiar with the inner workings of Swanton village. My mother was a village trustee. It’s a small community but as far as qualifications goes, I try to listen to people and to look at everybody’s different sides.”

In his professional career, Winchester has worked as a design/build contractor specializing in private residential custom construction for the last 25 years.

Why are you interested in running for village board president?

“I’ve been asked for years. But there was so much turmoil over the public building project that I was contacted by several people and decided to run.” 

“Nobody ever challenged anybody, and Chris (Leach) and Neal (Spear) have been on the board for close to three decades, so I think people are grumbling for a different change and different perspective. “

​​What do you think the board does well? What would you like to see change, or improve?

“To work better together (with the Town Selectboard). What one chooses to do affects the other, when it’s the town, everybody gets to say and vote on it and participate in it. But if it’s the village, it’s a weird thing that’s developed over the centuries that excludes the town from equal representation so to speak. ‘Taxation without representation’ – you hear it going around quite a bit, because (the boards) work on their own, not in unison, but the taxpayers all have to deal with the ramifications.” 

What are your top priorities, if elected to the board of trustees?

“Well, a big thing is to figure out what to do with the police department. They need more space. They need the big focus as well as the ramification of the huge tax increases in the state and where they’re going to land.”

​​How would you maintain a line of communication between yourself and the people you’re elected to serve?

“I’m a big advocate for the community social media page. Good or bad, people can talk and information is shared willingly and it seems that’s not a bad thing. It can be, but for the majority as far as transparency and holding people accountable is concerned, I’ve been a heavy advocate for it.”

Winchester also highlighted the difficulties around transparency as it pertains to governance structure. Even people who live in Swanton don’t always recognize the difference between the town and village as one’s decision so closely affects the other, leading to confusion when voters are asked to cast a ballot.

Do you support expanded policing? Why or why not?

“The building as proposed, I don't support it, I think it’s too expensive … It puts village taxpayers at risk if the town chooses not to support the building, especially right now. That’s going to be very detrimental for the taxpayers of the village. The town has said, it doesn’t support (the building), and the conflict is the village doesn't seem to want to listen to that.”

“But fighting crime is one of those things that we can’t keep bickering about. That situation doesn't care about local issues.” 

Winter clarified that he’s not against the idea of police expansion itself, but rather, he argued against the $14.8 million public safety building as presented by the village administration, emphasizing that the village could better use its existing assets to shuffle space and keep overall costs to taxpayers down.

“It’s a lot of common sense about how you can afford to pay for things in the village, and it makes a lot of economic sense,” he said.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here