SWANTON — Neal Speer first stepped up to serve as the Village of Swanton’s board president to re-invigorate Swanton’s downtown.
More than 25 years later, he’s watching those efforts come to fruition.
“There’s so many opportunities out there for our community to get involved in,” Speer said. “All of these projects, you’ve got to invest up front. … And then hope it reaps the benefit.”
Speer narrowly lost the election for village president this past Town Meeting Day after serving in the position since 1998. Looking back, he’s proud of what the village has been able to accomplish during his time as board president, but he has some cautious reservations about the future.
Speer is from Swanton, born and raised. He graduated from Swanton High School and he’s spent much of his life working in Swanton as founder of his own construction company, which he started in 1972.
“The community has supported me for over 50 years,” Speer said. “This would be 52 years that I’ve had my business.”
Speer first became village president in 1998, after winning a floor vote against incumbent Ed Daniel on Town Meeting Day. Speer said he was asked to run, and the role seemed like a good way to give back after spending 25 years doing solid business as a construction contractor.
Daniel, a former schoolteacher, had spent less than two years as president after being appointed. On the Town Meeting Day floor, Speer won the vote against him, 55 to 17.
“I wish to thank you all for all your support at the annual Swanton Village meeting held on March 10, 1998,” Speer wrote in an opinion piece to the Messenger later that month. “I have been a member of this community all of my life and find great comfort in having the support of so many good people in my bid for President of Swanton Village. Our community has many slated improvements developing in the near future and I hope to be a positive force in making them happen.”
Speer said Swanton’s downtown was losing traction in the late ‘90s. Like other downtowns across the nation, fewer and fewer people were shopping downtown as big box retail first exploded on the scene, and he was asked to become village president to help reverse the trend.
He kept coming back, however, because he’s enjoyed working with the village.
“I’ve been a part of the community for all of my life. I love the community, and I feel involved in the improvement of it,” Speer said. “Why I’ve lasted so long is because I’ve had great people to work with.”
Speer never had any election challengers until 2024. He did vacate his seat for two years in 2011 and 2012 to give Ron Kilburn a chance at the job, but Speer came back in 2013 to continue as president.
During his decades on the board, Speer said he’s proud of what the village has been able to accomplish, both in its downtown and throughout its operations.
One of those proudest moments occurred when Speer played a large part in bringing Ace Hardware to downtown Swanton by working closely with business owner Gordon Winters, he said. Thanks to the work, Winters was able to flip an old warehouse in the center of town and transform the former eyesore into a strong business.
“We’ve gotten more and more tax dollars than we could ever have gotten out of that building,” Speer said.
Moving forward, he would like to see similar projects for Swanton’s downtown continue to emerge, especially as town and village organizers try to wrangle more momentum for Swanton’s growth. Either way, he expects it’s going to take a lot of work.
Looking at Swanton’s future, Speer sees a lot of potential. The village’s downtown streetscape is due for a major upgrade over the next few years, with the first stage of construction expected as early as 2025.
Speer has been at the forefront of the effort, often bringing the concerns of downtown business owners to village meetings to help improve Merchant Row’s foot traffic and overall appearance. This past summer, the work came to fruition as multiple new businesses – many owned by women – found a foothold in Swanton’s center.
The momentum, however, could be slowing down.
Last month during Town Meeting Day, Speer ran up against vocal opposition from taxpayers worried about the costs associated with a proposed $19 million project to construct a new public safety building for the village. The resulting 3-to-1 vote against the project made it clear that voters didn’t agree with the effort.
“We knew it was an ambitious project. And we wanted to know what the people thought and we found out what the people thought,” he said. “We weren’t going to move ahead with it without their consensus.”
The Town Meeting Day vote also replaced Speer with current village president David Winchester, who’s still learning the ropes. Earlier this month, the new president painted downtown Swanton in a negative light, and the comment prompted its own wave of public feedback against Winchester. Speer said he tries to be careful with own words for the same reason.
But he also recognizes the dynamic has changed. Looking back, Speer said he tried to emphasize three important aspects about governance when he held the job: teamwork, humility and trust. He’s worried the current political climate, however, is making those concepts harder to live by.
“People want certain things from their community, but they want somebody else to do it,” he said. “And there’s not that many left to do it.”
Like many of Vermont’s rural towns, Swanton is also facing demographic challenges. As people grow older, there are fewer younger Vermonters coming up to replace them due to decades-long changes in rural economies, and the result has created diverging experiences and expectations.
With that said, Speer sees opportunity in Swanton. The Hotel Riviere property won’t be ready for development until the state signs off on brownfield remediation efforts, but Speer said he could see the potential for housing on the site sometime down the line. Swanton could also pursue more public private partnerships, Speer said, like the one made with Winters, and there’s opportunity to expand on the village’s current assets, like Marble Mill Park.
“You have to invest grants, tax dollars, invest in something to see the results later,” he said. “If you don’t invest in it, everything’s going to decay.”
Or Swanton residents could move a major project forward, like community members did with the old train depot in the late 90s to save it for the Swanton Historical Society’s use, instead of letting the lack of $300,000 determine the building’s fate.
“Swanton could go anywhere,” he added. “I just hope they take a positive path to improve, come together and make the decisions that are good for all of us.”
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here