Swanton considers policing future at joint village/town discussion; Expenditures predicted to double

Posted

SWANTON — Due to some early budget estimations, the future of policing in Swanton could cause some “sticker shock” to town residents.

Swanton Village’s Board of Trustees and the Town of Swanton Selectboard met this past Monday to begin discussions about a potential partnership to expand coverage of the Swanton Village Police Department.

Under the proposed income statement, the department’s total expected expenditures would more than double from $1.5 million to $3.1 million year-over-year. 

Revenues would be collected by a 41.5 cents per $100 valuation tax rate on all properties in both the town and village – a tax base of over $7.1 million – to collect the funds.

In real terms, a property worth $350,000 would pay $1,452.59 in annual taxes to cover the police department.

“All of the residents of Swanton, town and village, have to think of this as an investment and wonder if it’s going to be worth the investment.,” Village Board President Neal Speer said.

Expanding coverage

Swanton town residents paid $326,000 this fiscal year for 56 hours of police coverage per week from the Swanton Villager Police Department

The expansion of the Swanton Village Police Department would increase that cost substantially, pushing the total paid via the town’s tax base to closer to $2.3 million. In return though, town residents would receive similar 24/7 police coverage as village residents.

Despite the initial sticker shock, Swanton town and village officials largely expressed a positive response to the police expansion. 

Elected officials, especially, said they’ve all heard from community members about the need for more police services as law enforcement tackles what they’ve called a growing drug problem in the area. 

“We’re not immune from it being a small community,” Swanton Police Chief Matt Sullivan said. “Quite honestly, I was shocked – when I came up here almost two years ago now – at the level of drug activity in Swanton itself and how bad it was.”

Out of the $3.1 million in proposed police expenses tallied by the village, roughly $457,000 would cover the first annual bond payment for a new public safety building to be built by the village. 

Sheets said the building is a necessary part of expanding police services. As the village’s 50-year-old municipal building is running out of room, constructing additional space for the police and fire departments would allow the three departments remaining in the municipal building to find more room. The current space the police department occupies also lacks many of the modifications more modern police stations use – such as holding cells or a sally port. 

Despite the limitations, Swanton police have been taking a more active approach to Swanton’s drug issue, and officers have been able to push out some of the drug activity in the area. A new building and regional policing approach, however, should bolster those efforts, Sheets said.

“We have an opportunity to move ahead of the rest of the communities in the state with a state-of-the-art police department that serves all of us,” Speer said. “It’s going to be expensive, but everything is going to be expensive.”

Supporting police

A lack of policing in rural Vermont has been a recurring issue in Vermont since at least 1974. While the Vermont State Police and county sheriff’s offices have helped, neither policing model has stopped calls from rural residents looking for faster response times over the years.

Regionalization of municipal police departments has long been offered as a potential solution, but the cost and complexity has stymied largely municipal efforts.

One of the most successful partnerships, for example, between Greensboro and Hardwick fell apart back in 2021 when policing costs began to balloon in the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic. They had first joined up in 1980.

Both Swanton Village and St. Albans City officials, however, have argued that expanding their departments should drive down those costs due to economies of scale. The two municipalities are both pursuing police expansions based on inter-municipal agreements to share costs with their associated towns.

Sheets said Swanton Village has also seen some interest from residents in Enosburgh, Sheldon and Highgate. Spreading costs over their grand lists in theory would help defray costs.

Sheets said partnering municipalities would also have input into Swanton’s police department to keep costs down, just as St. Albans has done with its joint police board. The six-person committee – responsible for creating the police budget in St. Albans – has three representatives from each municipality.

If Swanton town and village partner to operate a single Swanton Police Department, the governing board would have a similar structure for town representatives to be heard around budget issues, Sheets said.

No decisions, however, were made Monday night, although selectboard members all largely agreed the expansion was needed to tackle drugs and resolve their larger impacts to the community.

“I really think the benefit of the culture that it can create overall is priceless,” selectboard member Nicole Draper said. 

At the end of the night, selectboard chair Earl Fournier brought up the topic of a local options tax to help the town cover some of its bills. To be shared between the village, town and state, the additional sales tax would bring in over $200,000 annually, if the village and town agreed to move forward.

Fournier said he wanted to bring the topic up to jumpstart the conversation on the additional revenue stream.

“We need to consider it because all these things we’re proposing to do are legitimate things that need to be done,” Fournier said. “We have the police department but there are certainly other ones.”

The Swanton Town Selectboard is also in the middle of the development process for a new recreation facility, with a vote to approve the new building expected in 2025.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here