St. Albans Town Selectboard pauses to rework Declaration of Inclusion; Statewide effort signs up 150+ towns

Posted

ST. ALBANS TOWN – The Town of St. Albans Selectboard is considering a rewrite of the Declaration of Inclusion after revisiting the topic this past Monday, Aug. 19.

Roughly 154 out of Vermont’s 237 towns have adopted a version of the Declaration of Inclusion since the statement was initially proposed in 2020 by a group of grassroots volunteers, but St. Albans Town has had reservations about moving forward with adopting the document as its own.

Back in August 2023, Town Manager Sean Adkins brought it to selectboard members, but the board denied approval citing potential political and legal repercussions.

Roughly one year later, many of those arguments were revisited as Adkins brought the topic before the selectboard again after it had been tabled one year ago.

“I think a town needs to take it and make it their own,” selectboard vice-chair Jeff Sanders said after he voiced concerns.

Considering the declaration

Since its initial introduction in 2020, the Declaration of Inclusion has taken on additional layers of meaning as the conversations around diversity, equity and inclusion initiatives have evolved and been labeled with a hodgepodge of unintended political messages.

The document itself, however, features three relatively simple statements laying out a town’s ideals. The first is as follows:

“The Town of ______________ condemns racism and welcomes all persons, regardless of race, color, religion, national origin, sex, sexual orientation, gender identity and expression, age, disability, or socioeconomic status, and wants everyone to feel safe and welcome in our community.”

Town Manager Sean Adkins said adopting the statement would help show St. Albans Town acts in solidarity with the rest of Vermont.

Sanders, however, had a few issues with the document. After hearing a motion and second to consider the declaration as presented, Sanders read a prepared statement laying out his points to why the selectboard should consider scrapping the resolution.

His points primarily revolved around concerns about extra – currently undefined – legal obligations attached to the declaration. And since there are already laws in place to tackle discrimination, Sanders argued the declaration largely served as a political statement that would function as a wedge between those that agree with DEI efforts and those that don’t.

On the other hand, if the town did want to make a statement about being welcoming, Sanders said he would support the drafting of a document outside of the boilerplate provided by the organization initially behind the declaration. 

“I don’t think we should do it for them at all. It’s something we should do for our towns,” Sanders said.

Taking a step back

Sanders' protests eventually pushed the remaining selectboard members to consider how to draft the town’s own version of the declaration as they largely agreed with the intended meaning. Selectboard member Brendan Deso suggested the chair, vice-chair and town manager work together to create something that would be amenable to the larger board.

He also pointed out some of the prior steps the town had taken around diversity, equity and inclusion initiatives. Roughly three years ago, community members had asked the town to move forward with the creation of a diversity, equity and inclusion board, but the effort largely stalled after the selectboard took its own steps to better implement diversity initiatives into its own operations.

Moving forward, Deso said he wanted to see what other specific actions the town could take to further improve services and be more accessible to residents in the same vein.

As for the declaration, Deso warned caution about scrapping the idea of the resolution altogether. With so many towns in Vermont already on board with the statement, not signing the document can signal as much intent as signing the document.

Sanders, however, figured there was likely a way to continue to show that St. Albans Town is welcoming while residents can maintain local control about what happens. As an example, Sanders asked the board if the declaration’s equity initiatives would extend to housing? If so, he said the town would have a diminished argument to make against construction if someone proposed a multi-unit development in the bay area. 

After the discussion, selectboard chair Jonathan Giroux agreed to give the selectboard members more time to craft a declaration closer to what they’d like to see. The topic is expected to be in front of the selectboard again sometime within the next few months.

“I don’t have a problem with having a statement,” Sanders said. “I just think it needs to be our statement.” 

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here