St. Albans City Council reorganizes; City-wide reappraisal kicks off

Posted

ST. ALBANS — St. Albans City Council held its post-Town Meeting Day reorganizational meeting this Monday, swearing in two new alderpersons, as well as incumbent mayor, Tim Smith.

The annual meeting gives new city council members their first chance to take their seats at the board. Both Erik Johnson and Chad Boudreau were sworn-in jointly. 

Johnson, who won the seat for Ward 5, replaced former council member Bob Farrar, who dropped from the race due to a potential conflict of interest with his role as Franklin County Probate Judge.

Farrar, in the audience Monday night, thanked city council members and city officials for their help during his time on board. Farrar joined in 2021.

“I think the council accomplished a lot. We had some spirited discussion in the executive session and public session,” Farrar said. “I just wanted to say thank you for the opportunity to serve and I’ll keep in touch with what the council is doing.” 

As for the open Ward 6 seat, councilors agreed to appoint Boudreau to the position after he had offered his name as a write-in candidate. While Boudreau received less than the 30-vote cut-off required to take the seat, council voted unanimously to appoint him to the board.

Chad Spooner had served as the Ward 6 alderperson for 15 years, as well as multiple terms as council president, before stepping down this year. No candidates, however, filed the petitions required to be on the ballot for the Town Meeting Day vote.

Council also agreed to appoint Ward 1 Alderperson Tim Hawkins as City Council’s new president, recommended by Ward 4 councilor Trudy Cioffi.

“Being that it’s a one-year appointment, I will accept the nomination,” Hawkins said.

City reappraisal team preps for busy year

The St. Albans City grand list – used to determine all property taxes – hasn’t been updated for at least a decade, but the city’s reappraisal team expects that to change by 2025.

The City of St. Albans hired Tyler Technologies – a Texas-based assessment group with a team in Montpelier – to complete the work over the next year. On Monday, city officials invited representatives from the company to discuss what residents can expect to see during the reappraisal process.

The discussion also came with plenty of questions for Tyler Technologies residential reviewers on the impacts any changes will have on individual property owners, as property taxes will most likely have to be readjusted following the reappraisal.

“If anyone's concerned about your property value being treated fairly amongst all the others … the best thing you can do as a property owner is respond to any mailings or any other communications you get from the city and our consultants,” city planning director Chip Sawyer said. “Make sure that we have the most accurate data about the state of your property and materials so that we can make sure everyone is valued fairly in the grand list.”

The adjustment should also impact education property tax rates, as the new grand list assessment would reset the common level of appraisal, or CLA. The state funding mechanism – put in place to adequately weigh changes to property levels on a state scale – is expected to inflate education property tax rates for city residents in 2024. 

Reappraisal process

During the presentation, the team with Tyler Technologies laid out their general approach to explain how they plan to assess the hundreds of parcels that make up the city’s grand list. 

While the discussion went down a few tangents, the general outline of the group’s work requires that they pull in as much data on the city’s housing stock from as many sources as possible. Once the data is collected, the Tyler Technologies team will then be able to weigh each property against recent sales prices in St. Albans City to spit out a much more accurate estimate on what a house is actually worth.

To gather the data, assessors are also trying to inspect as many homes as possible in St. Albans City. As residential reviewer Andrew Mahoney explained, each property will be inspected from the public right-of-way over multiple visits, and the Tyler Technologies team will be reaching out to property owners to be able to get inside for a closer inspection. 

Senior project supervisor John Vickery said info and data mailers are expected to go out to residents soon.

To get a good idea of the quality of homes, a typical re-assessment will often be able to inspect 30% to 40% of house interiors throughout a municipality, Mahoney said, and the goal is to get in as many houses as possible in order to have the best data set.

House-by-house inspections, however, aren’t the only tactic in the Tyler Technologies Team’s toolbelt. The data is also informed by a quantitative understanding of what kind of houses are available throughout Vermont, as well as how well such properties sell on the open market, to inform the final valuation determination. Even data points like lister’s photos and GIS data can play a part in exploring the condition of each property.

During the explanation, councilors Tim Hawkins and Trudy Cioffi had the most questions for the assessing team to try to get a better understanding of the process.

Hawkins, for example, asked about how Tyler Technologies is taking Vermont’s rapid growth into account during the assessment process. 

“What’s happened in the last 48 months is not typical of what would normally happen in the City of St. Albans. So I think that your valuation is going to be heavily-skewed … in favor of a more expensive property value, if you’re basing it just on that criteria,” Hawkins said.

A number of U.S. cities did see the price of single family homes fall over the last year, with Memphis, Tenn., seeing the largest drop in valuation by percentage at 17%. The phenomenon, however, did not materialize in Northwest Vermont, where the median sale price of a single-family home rose by nearly 7% while the number of sales dropped, according to data collected by Coldwell Banker Hickok & Boardman.

The 2023 market report published by the group estimates Northwest Vermont will continue to see increases in housing prices due to even less new homes entering the market in 2024 over last year. Compared to 2020, 750 fewer houses in the region were sold in 2023.

The city’s reappraisal is also expected to use the most current dataset on housing values, which should help buffer any rapid changes in market value seen in the first two years of the pandemic.

“Most of the sales data we’ll be able to use is post-covid and really reflects the current market,” Sawyer said.

Councilors also had questions on how neighboring properties would be taken into consideration when the reappraisal team looks at properties. 

“I get this a lot,” Vickery said. “I don’t make adjustments if the neighbor has a sloppy yard, because you’ll have spot adjustments all over the place. … If it’s a contaminated site, well, that might be a different story.”

By the end of the discussion, Hawkins requested that the representatives from Tyler Technologies return to help answer any subsequent questions about the process, especially as the reappraisal kicks off and community members start asking councilors for info.

“I’d like to see you guys again as things go on. We’re the ones who are going to be asked all these questions when those things start going out,” Hawkins said. “I’m going to see a lot of people all the time saying, ‘do I let these guys in, Tim? What if I don’t? What is this going to do?’ And I want to make sure I know what’s going on.”

Mahoney recommended that Hawkins check out a website, expected to be released by Tyler Technologies at a future date, to help clarify how the reappraisal process works, as well as review printed materials to be passed out as reappraisers come by.

The plan is for each property owner to get a mailer – as well as a knock at the door – to try to catch a property owner while at home, get a tour and confirm any data available, Mahoney said.

 

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here