SAPD gets sign-off on $5.3M budget

Posted

ST. ALBANS CITY — The St. Albans Joint Police Board green-lit next year’s police budget at its Dec. 11 meeting —  setting up a year-over-year 8% increase in base wages for officers, if approved by voters.

St. Albans City Manager Dominic Cloud said the proposed budget reflects new realities for police officers facing a higher demand for their services, and that St. Albans’ joint approach to policing has helped spread out the costs.

“It illustrates the importance of the city and town police contract and how we’re able to compete — with Milton, South Burlington, Colchester and Essex —  because the city and town are together,” Cloud said. “If we weren’t linked, we couldn’t compete, and now we can.” 

Under the proposed budget, Cloud said city voters would be providing the same revenue as they had in 2023 for a major expansion of policing services thanks to the joint policing contract. 

For town voters, the cost of law enforcement services will have almost doubled since the two municipalities signed the document back in January of 2023.

Policing by the numbers

Year-over-year, fiscal year 2026’s police budget proposes a roughly $600,000 increase to bring the department’s total expenditures to $5.3 million. The 12.1% increase, compared to last year’s budget, is almost entirely located within the wage and benefit lines for employees. 

Cloud said the city's police union negotiated an 8% increase in base wage in order to match current market rates, with an additional 2% step increase provided for performance. 

After a busy summer, the increase reflects the high demand for law enforcement, Cloud said, especially when there’s an ongoing workforce shortage across Vermont. Franklin County’s latest unemployment rate, for example, was set at a historic low of 1.8% for October.

“At a union negotiating table, when your profession made the cover of TIME magazine, when 350 people filled a town hall meeting and demanded a strong robust police department, they’re holding a good hand,” Cloud said. 

Meanwhile, police unions across the state have jumped on the moment to emphasize the lack of support they feel from city administrations post-George Floyd protests, with many Chittenden County departments pushing for higher pay increases than St. Albans to counter progressive political perceptions.

The Burlington Police Officer’s Association, for example, sent a letter to the Burlington City Council this past October highlighting how the department is having a difficult time attracting qualified applicants from Vermont due to the city’s in-state perception.

“People who live in the area understand and recognize the lack of support from the city leadership and community, whereas out-of-state applicants do not grasp this as well as someone who has lived in the area for a portion of their adult lives,” the letter sent to Burlington’s City Council reads.

No matter the cause, tax increases are still expected across the board from governments in Vermont, with level-funding a near impossibility. The big question this Town Meeting Day, however, is which groups will find public support for their rate increases.

The increase in last year’s education tax rate, for example, largely spurred a second-look at schools, education professionals and the state politicians who support them.

Tactical needs

While the police budget is largely set, city and town residents won’t know the impact to their own property taxes until the remaining departmental budgets are set. 

Local officials on the joint police board, however, largely signaled their support for the increases.

“We need a safe community. The people who are risking their lives to keep us safe. I think I can swallow that increase because of the safety aspect of the job,” City Councilor Trudy Cioffi said.

St. Albans Police Chief Maurice Lamothe said his department has a much better reputation than Burlington at the Vermont Police Academy. The positive reception and treatment has also helped retain officers within the department. 

But when bigger police departments in Vermont are able to increase their pay rates, Cloud said the city has to adjust accordingly to maintain staffing levels in response.

“It’s those guys that are driving the market and other communities making those same increases trying to lure our officers away,” he said. “It’s basic supply and demand. Demand is off the charts, and supply is shrinking.”

During December’s meeting, joint board officials also talked through what officers need to adequately tackle an expected summer swell in criminality. While warm weather is correlated with more instances of crime, this past summer surprised city officials with a huge influx of calls from the public, influenced by a spate of property theft crimes often related to drug use and/or homelessness.

Cloud said the latest budget reflects the city’s attempt at meeting the issue with additional dollars being spent on staff, equipment and capital purchases. 

“My position is it's an emerging need, and we can fund it now that we know about it,” he said. 

Town officials, however, pushed for more funding toward those areas.  Selectboard member Jack Brigham, for example, asked the city about additional spending on tactical gear to ensure officers stay safe during dangerous building entries.

Lamothe had explained earlier the city had been upgrading some of its equipment, especially as the police will likely have more interaction with drug dealers due to SAPD’s re-instituted street crimes unit. 

The city had initially nixed the program after the town switched police services, signing a new contract with the Franklin County Sheriff’s Department back in 2020 to save money.

“We never defunded the police,” Cloud said. “But we did get rid of the street crimes unit.”

City officials are now betting town residents will be more comfortable covering those increased costs. In response, Town Manager Sean Adkins said the town has worked to keep other municipal spends as level-funded as possible to best absorb the policing costs.

“We’re all up to speed and we’re all pretty much in agreement about what we want to do while also being fiscally responsible with our own budget,” Adkins said. “Within a climate of education increases, we’ve really got to be responsible with it.” 

Dispatching services

While the police department received much of the focus, the joint police board also agreed to the city’s dispatch budget during its December meeting.

Similarly, most of the year-over-year increase for dispatch is concentrated in the wage and benefit line items for the department, equaling a roughly $110,000 increase spread out across staff. In total, the department is asking for $1.6 million, or $130,000 more than last year’s budget.

Cloud said dispatchers also got an 8% wage increase year-over-year, as St. Albans continues to expand its dispatching capabilities. To bring in additional revenues, the city is looking to create economies of scale with regional dispatch to keep property taxes as low as possible. 

At this point, Cloud said dispatcher pay rates needed the extra boost in order for St. Albans to stay competitive and keep a full staff.

“We are part of the largest municipal dispatch center in the state and our employees take more calls than anybody else,” he said. 

In total, the dispatch department employs 11 full-time employees. On the police side, there are 16 patrol officers, with an additional 10 employees filling out the remaining specialist and administrative roles within the police department.

“The most important thing to the city is we’re responding to that groundswell, competing with communities twice our size with twice our taxbase and not asking anything more out of the city tax base than we did in fiscal 2023,” Cloud said. ”And that’s the power of us working together.“

#sanltop

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here