Richford, Enosburgh refuse to create new school board

Posted

RICHFORD – Voters from Enosburgh and Richford voted Tuesday night to stall an organizational meeting for a state-ordered consolidation of their respective town’s school districts, putting a hold on transitional activity until a decision is issued on an ongoing lawsuit against Act 46.

According to supervisory union staff, it was unclear what the legal consequences of the vote will be.

Tuesday’s meeting, held at the Richford Jr./Sr. High School, was supposed to be the first in a months-long process to transition the Enosburgh and Richford school districts to a consolidated district. Under Act 46, the state’s controversial school consolidation law, that unified district is required to be operational on July 1, 2019.

When voting, residents said they feared a mixed message would come from following through on the transition process while explicitly fighting that transition in court. “To go forward with organizing and creating this new structure implies that you agree with it,” said one resident. “Yet at the same time, you’re involved in a lawsuit that says you don’t.”

The Richford School Board is a party in an ongoing lawsuit challenging Act 46 as unconstitutional. The Enosburg Falls Town School District, meanwhile, is not.

Where this leaves both forming districts, as well as the consolidated district, ahead of that July deadline is uncertain.

According to Enosburg school board member Rick Bartholomew, the understanding of the forming districts’ school boards is that they currently have no authority to warn individual school budgets.

“We don’t have authority to do the budget work, and I want to make that clear,” Bartholomew said. “We don’t have authority to do anything.”

A memo circulated by the Agency of Education advises that an organizational meeting, during which a transitional board would be appointed, be held mid-February in order to permit the transitional board to draft a budget for the unified district and possibly revisit its default Articles of Agreement ahead of becoming operational in July.

According to that memo, the forming districts – in this case Richford and Enosburgh – don’t need to warn individual budgets in lieu of a unified budget, explaining:

“Under current law, the Forming Districts cease all operations on July 1, 2019 and remain in existence for no more than six months afterwards for the sole purpose of completing any business the New Union District [sic] is legally not able to perform. Current law remains in effect unless and until a Court [sic] orders otherwise or the Legislature amends or repeals current law.”

Without an order from the court or any action from the legislature, the districts are required by state law to have a merged district be operational come July.

Meanwhile, a resident from Montgomery attending Tuesday’s meeting said Montgomery had warned an individual budget for Town Meeting Day.

The vote to close Tuesday’s meeting came ahead of any other decisions on the meeting’s agenda, including the appointment of a transitional board. With no transitional board in place, the Enosburgh – Richford district is unable to draft a budget for the unified district.

According to Bartholomew and Franklin Northeast Supervisory Union (FNESU) superintendent Lynn Cota, this decision comes amid ongoing contract negotiations for the supervisory union’s teaching staff. Without a hint as to what operating budget will be in place on July 1, 2019, those negotiations could be at risk, they said.

FNESU is currently negotiating each of its teaching contracts for every school in the supervisory union.

Generally, negotiations conclude mid-April, Bartholomew said.

Because voters in the merging Enosburgh – Richford district have voted to hold off on an organizational meeting until a decision is issued on ongoing litigation related to Act 46, it’s highly unlikely a budget vote will be warned ahead of the middle of April.

It’s currently unknown as to when Judge Robert A. Mello, the Act 46 lawsuit’s presiding judge, will issue a decision on any of three lawsuits challenging Act 46 in court.

Mello is currently reviewing a request for an injunction to stop merger activity while those suits are argued in court. A hearing on the issue was held Friday.

Historically, if voters haven’t passed a budget by the start of a district’s fiscal year, the school district, by state law, is required to operate with a reduced version of the previous fiscal year’s budget.

Offhand, Bartholomew estimated that cut to be somewhere around 13 percent of the district’s operating budget, translating to more than $1 million for the Enosburg Falls Town School District.

“You’re looking at all sports programs, teachers,” Bartholomew said. “That’s a lot of positions.”

The Vermont House of Representatives recently passed a bill, H.39, that would delay some mergers mandated under Act 46. That legislation, should it pass the state senate and be signed into law by Gov. Phil Scott, wouldn’t delay the Enosburgh – Richford merger, as the two districts had previously voted on a bilateral merger plan in the past.

That bill is currently waiting review by the Senate Committee on Education.

The vote to delay last night’s meeting was overwhelming, with more than a two-thirds supermajority voting in favor.

Among the dissenting votes were those who expressed fears about possibly losing “highly-qualified teachers” without having an expected budget in place to negotiate teacher contracts with.

Click here to subscribe.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here