Q&A: Dickinson faces challenge from McCarthy for Franklin-2 House seat

Posted

ST. ALBANS TOWN — For the first time in almost a decade, Rep. Eileen Dickinson (R-St. Albans Town) has a challenger for her seat in the Vermont Statehouse.

Pam McCarthy, a Democrat and longtime social services professional, said she is running to stand up for working families and be a “new voice” for St. Albans Town.

“I’m well-known for being a good collaborator and somebody who’s very responsive,” she said. “I think those are qualities that people are desirous of right now.”

McCarthy’s past job titles include the executive director of the Family Center of Northwestern Vermont, the field director for the VT Agency of Human Services in Franklin and Grand Isle counties and president/CEO of the Vermont Family Network. She was also the co-owner of Cosmic Bakery and Cafe in downtown St. Albans for five years.

In the last year, McCarthy has been active as co-leader of Franklin County Women for Democracy, a fast-growing group advocating for civic participation and political accountability.

Dickinson’s first foray into elected office was through St. Albans school boards, and she was elected to the House of Representatives in 2009. Since then, she has served on four different committees and currently sits on House Appropriations, where she weighs-in on any bill requiring funding. She is also the legislative trustee to the Vermont State Colleges board.

“I see Vermont at a tipping point,” Dickinson said. “Our institutions, in a variety of ways, are overbuilt. They have smaller populations to deal with, increasing costs and overregulation. I'm willing to work with everyone to find a practical solution for constituents.”

Dickinson and McCarthy are vying for the one seat representing the Franklin-2 House district. Ahead of the election on Nov. 3, the Messenger asked the candidates the same set of questions to get their take on some of the challenges facing Vermont. Here’s what they had to say.

Q: How can the state support small, rural hospitals like Northwestern Medical Center?

Dickinson: Most of our hospitals are drowning in red ink. They're just not able to cover the cost of their care. We've had many years of regulation, and I'm not sure if we're able to really figure out how to solve this problem.

The Green Mountain Care Board is trying to solve it with the reference-based Medicare pricing, but community hospitals don't think that's going to be enough to cover their costs. We’ve expanded Medicaid over the years, but haven’t increased the reimbursements. That’s something the state needs to do, but the cost shift of that goes into commercial insurance, and that’s part of our issue of high health insurance costs.

McCarthy: We really need to make sure local healthcare is available to people, and that it continues to be of high quality. Both personally and professionally, I've experienced NMC and have really been impressed with what they’re able to do locally. The fact that people don't have to travel a long way to have a number of supports and services is really important.

I'm hopeful … that in the next session, we'll be able to collaborate more between the administration and the legislature to do all that we can to sustain small rural hospitals like ours — and Federally-Qualified Health Centers — and look at how larger organizations like the UVM Health Network can reduce their own costs.

Q: Is universally-accessible primary care possible in Vermont?

Dickinson: My husband has probably gone through four or five different primary care doctors since Dr. Zsoldos retired. My primary care doctor retired in May. Trying to find someone who will take you is hard.

One of the problems is, medical school graduates have anywhere between $250,000 and $450,000 worth of debt. What insurance pays is lower for primary care than it is for specialists. In a lot of other states, the state medical school only accepts in-state students. I don’t think that’s the case at UVM. If you have that debt, and you can’t figure out where you’re going to live or how you’re going to have kids, you are going to choose somewhere else.

McCarthy: I’m responsible for my almost 92-year-old uncle’s care … often it is very difficult to find specific and timely medical care for him.

The system itself is difficult to navigate partly because of insurance and partly because of availability or distance to travel. We have to take all of those things into account when we think about making sure rural communities have access to preventative primary care.

We need to bring more practitioners here, and that ties back to housing and payments.

It’s common sense when you think about it, that if you're doing more things at the front end to keep people healthy, you'll have fewer issues with disease and critical kinds of care down the line because you've done things at the front end to keep people well.

Q: What should the state be doing to support older Vermonters?

Dickinson: We have “Community Rating” — Gov. Howard Dean did this back in the ‘90s — and that means everybody pays the same amount regardless of their health situation. We lost a lot of health insurance companies, about 12 or 13, during that period of time … because they didn’t want to do it. That’s something we did to help elderly people who are ill, but it makes policies really expensive for younger people, healthy people.

McCarthy: I think we need to listen to them, first and foremost, about what they want in terms of care options, housing options, accessibility options, all of that. We have a large swath of our population now who are aging, and oftentimes feel kind of invisible and unheard.

Our communities need to be fully-inclusive of older people and younger people, so people don't feel isolated. Social isolation for elders is a really big thing, and we certainly have some resources here in Franklin County, but they're not comprehensive and not as well-resourced as we would like them to be. I'm thinking most-recently about [Town of St. Albans] deciding they couldn't afford to give funding to the senior center at the level they had previously.

Q: What is your vision for housing, specifically in St. Albans Town?

Dickinson: I think we need to really look at Act 250, and we really need to go and sit down and figure out a way to streamline our permitting process so it doesn't take two years to just build a simple house or a simple project.

We've done a lot with the Vermont Housing Conservation Board to take advantage of the federal low income tax credits that are out there, and we've built those. But a family of four can't really live in those, because they're small one and two bedroom units. They're really designed for a different population, and so the working Vermonter, the missing middle just isn't being built anymore.

We have a problem with supply and demand. We have a lot more demand than we have supply, but our permitting has made it prohibitive for a builder to build anything.

McCarthy: I think there are certainly buildings that could be refurbished, repurposed, especially in St. Albans Bay.

We need affordable housing, but also sustainable housing. Housing that is “green” and has renewable energy, which will make living there less expensive.

We should be thinking about how we create a better environment for folks who are landlords and those who want to add an accessory-dwelling-unit to their property. When I’m out knocking on doors, I’m hearing how difficult it is for landlords, particularly when they have tenants who aren't able to keep up with their rent or the maintenance of property.

Developers also need to include neighbors in the conversation. When there is buy-in from the community, a shared vision, it’s much easier to move big change forward.

Q: Have you ever considered leaving Vermont?

Dickinson: As a young couple, we made a point of coming to Vermont to a rural dental practice. We set down roots. We’ve been here 53 years, and we are very happy. We got involved in the community. My husband served on the board of the hospital. I got involved in the school board.

We met wonderful people. My husband, my son and my son-in-law all serve on the ski patrol at Jay Peak. Our grandchildren are now doing sports in the local schools. It’s been a very positive experience.

McCarthy: Jack and I moved here from Delaware with our family in 1995. We had thought we'd be in Delaware forever, but things changed with his job, and he got this interview at MVU. We came here for the interview, and we absolutely fell in love with the place.

I've lived all over the place; I was an Air Force Brat, and I lived all over Europe. I've been to a lot of places in my lifetime. But we got here, and we put down roots, and our kids thrived, and we feel so fortunate.

There are certainly challenges, but it's a place we want to work on bringing out the best in. I am not a politician. I am a public servant, and I think having the opportunity to bring that to the legislature would really benefit my community and my state.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here