ST. ALBANS — Voters have a choice to make this fall in who will represent Franklin-8. Incumbent Rep. Jack Brigham (R) faces a challenge from Democrat Zach Scheffler.
The district includes the south side of St. Albans Town and the portion of St. Albans City west of Route 7 and south of Lake Street.
Appointed to the legislature earlier this year by Gov. Phil Scott, this November will be Brigham’s first real test at the polls. A longtime dairy farmer, he is the current chair of the Town of St. Albans Selectboard.
“I got my feet wet and decided I’d like to try it for two years,” Brigham said. “We need to figure out how to get a little more balance down there. It’s all one-sided at the moment.”
Scheffler, a city resident, tech worker and skilled community organizer, said he is running to be a more approachable state representative focused on actionable solutions. In 2024, he ran unsuccessfully against Brigham’s predecessor, Casey Toof.
“I see a need for a legislator who communicates, works hard, and most importantly, listens to their constituents,” he said. “We don’t have that right now, and it compelled me to run again this year.”
Ahead of the election, the Messenger asked Brigham and Scheffler the same set of questions to get their take on some of the challenges facing Vermont. Here’s what they had to say.
Brigham: I was in it, milking cows for 40 odd years, and I'm still in it today at a more diversified operation, maple and beef. What can we do to support our farmers? Well, the sad part is $6 diesel. That's not going to help lower the price of milk. There is also way more regulation on farms than there is on anything else. Those are the things that we need to ease up on so that we can make a living off our land.
We have more strict water quality regulations on farms than there is on municipalities. They have discharge permits for sewage overflows, but farms get none of that. There has got to be no discharge of any type at all. That’s expensive [for a farmer] to remedy.
There are a lot of younger folks who are getting into the production of food — vegetables, farmstands —and are helping to utilize some of the land of former dairy farms. It’s very capital intensive to get into farming today, and we should be helping to support those who want to give a go.
Scheffler: What you're seeing with DFA and a lot of these other agricultural companies, it's the county's heritage, right? Really near and dear to our hearts, and you're seeing big out-of-state monopolies gobble more and more of these farms up.
But at the same time, I think of the Choiniere Farm — Matt and Guy are resourceful, working with state ag and trying out a lot of new things. They're diversifying.
There's so much to do. I think part of it is state efforts to build more homes so more people can afford to stay and work on a farm, or live in their community and continue to do what they love to do.
I think the state needs to invest in programs that connect farmers to real food needs in the area. I was just up at the Sheldon Interfaith Food Shelf, and they and the Vermont Food Bank are working with the state so farmers can make local sales and help local people. I think Vermont has a real chance to connect its local food needs, given rising grocery prices right now and the cost of logistics to move food from one state to another. I think if the state can facilitate that and give farmers the options and the expertise and the help to diversify, like the Choineres have, that all contributes to that goal of resilience.
Brigham: I have four children, all grown. Two of them left the state after college and have finally come back, because this is their home, but there's not a lot of [job] opportunity here. They’ve done well enough [out-of-state] that they can come back and afford a home.
When I got married in 1982, I lived in a mobile home here on the farm. It cost $18,000, and my mortgage was 200-and-something-dollars a month. The housing that's built in the town today is half a million dollars. No young person can afford that.
It is a lot cheaper now to rehab some of our older buildings than it is to build from the ground up. The state complex in Waterbury, let’s get that fixed up and let people live there.
Scheffler: We simply need to build more homes. Vermont and New England have underbuilt for decades, and we're seeing the results of that. The housing shortage is my top priority. It's number one for a really, really personal reason, and that's in the last year, I think more of my friends than ever have either moved out of the county or moved out of state, and they did that because they couldn't lower their housing costs. Their rents were too expensive. They couldn't find alternatives, or they had a growing family, wanted to buy a house, and just couldn't find anything that fit with their life. A lot of my friends in their 30s are having kids, and you're adding childcare to that cost.
I think more Vermonters deserve the freedom to stay here if they choose. A lack of housing prevents working families from staying here to fill these jobs we need. My dad works in manufacturing and in hiring, and he can't hire enough people to meet their needs because there just simply isn't the housing to support them.
Building more homes is going to require a lot of different homes for different people at all income levels and at all stages of life. We've got to simplify state zoning rules and streamline the local process to do things like accelerate starter home construction. We have these growth zones in certain parts of Vermont, and St. Albans Town and St. Albans City are ones of those, and we need to lean into that.
Brigham: I served on the school board here in town for a number of years. Insurance is a biggie. We're also kind of a social service as well as a school.
[As to how to lower costs,]I don't have that answer. I think there's a lot of duplication, and I think there's a lot of waste, but the big problem is how do you take the smaller schools and get the kids the same quality education that some of the more wealthy towns can give their kids. There's quite a discrepancy in teachers' salaries from say schools in the Northeast Kingdom, where I have relatives teaching, and down here in the St. Albans area.
Scheffler: I've never met a superintendent who wasn't interested in operational efficiencies. [Legislators] describe school mergers as something they hope would bring that, but these consolidations have been tried before. I'm a little concerned that mergers and consolidations are being touted as a one-step solution to lowering the cost of education in Vermont.
I think we need to look at healthcare. There was a bill, S.190, this past session that was going to empower the state healthcare regulator to lower the cost of healthcare for educators and school districts that would have lowered the premiums those school districts were paying for their employees. When you look at school budgets and you see how much of the school budget is entirely dedicated to paying for healthcare for employees, you say we need to do something about that. S. 190 was going to do that, and one of the biggest reasons I'm running is because my opponent voted against S.190.
We need to lower the cost of healthcare for our school districts. That's going to lower the school budgets. It's going to stabilize your property taxes.
Brigham: I wasn’t raised with computers. I still struggle with my cell phone. I do think we have to be careful. There is a good side — it’s (AI) helping cure disease, things like that — but when you look at AI and the dangers of it, that’s scary.
Back in the day when everything was paper, you didn’t have news flashes about data breaches. That could be the ruination of the world as we know it. I do think we need it, but there needs to be some strict rules put on it.
Scheffler: A lot of our technology these days relies on data centers. Vermont passed a really strong data protection bill last session. Another bill, (which the governor vetoed) would have protected communities from all the things we hear about data centers — environmental concerns, driving up local electricity rates. Beyond the initial construction jobs, these centers don't create much in the way of long-lasting jobs for local people. These buildings are empty most of the time.
I thought that bill — S. 727 — was good, and the governor's administration had testified to Congress that we need to pass more of these protections for communities, and I was really disappointed that my opponent voted against S. 727.
Should I have the chance to vote for a similar bill again, I would absolutely vote for tech protections against AI and a lot of the disruption that is going on right now.
Brigham: I would like to stay on the agriculture committee. There are four of us there who are actually involved with agriculture. There are four others who are nice folks, but have no background in agriculture. That makes it very difficult.
I’m big into keeping agriculture alive in the state, because when it’s gone, you don’t have Vermont. That’s a big draw here, the open land and the woods.
Scheffler: I would like to serve on the Joint Information Technology Oversight Committee. Given my Vermont tech background, it would just be a really exciting place to do some really good work.
One thing I would be really interested in doing on that committee is overseeing state IT projects and keeping the state government to task for how it implements its technology systems.
Right now, the state government is looking at a $70 million overhaul of its IT system. It touches every department, every aspect of state government. It's running into cost overruns and delays. The people who are implementing the project say it might not even work. If I was on the Joint Information Technology Oversight Committee, I would be able to keep a close eye on that project and others to make sure Vermonters are getting a government worth paying for.
Brigham: I have my phone number pretty much out there. You can look it up on the town website, the legislative website. I always prefer a phone call because I like to talk direct.
Scheffler: I’m a Vermont tech worker. I've worked in customer service as part of that. I'm highly communicative and technically adept. I have the capacity to communicate in all channels.
I've been making social media videos to communicate with people about my campaign plans. In my volunteer work and in my day job, I have to manage and communicate with hundreds of people almost non-stop. Whether it's reaching out over the phone or via email or leaving a comment on a video or seeing me at a local coffee shop or a community event, I am constantly accessible, and I enjoy being accessible.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here