FRANKLIN COUNTY — Exact change is getting harder to come by.
This past June, the U.S. Mint stopped putting more pennies into circulation in an attempt to save $56 million in production costs.
Americans are left holding the coins. Now what do we do with them?
At Rail City Market, it’s not uncommon for someone to dump all their change into the till to empty their pockets, business owner Ashley Cleare said. Many people don’t want the hassle.
And pennies — still legal tender worth exactly 1/100th of a dollar — are the worst offenders. Take a penny or leave a penny? How about someone take the whole 200 billion of them? Pennies aren’t worth much in today’s economy.
But people still have plenty of thoughts they’re sharing, Cleare said. It’s a common topic of conversation at the register these days as people reckon what to do with pennies now that they’re no longer being made.
Businesses, however, are still required to take them as a form of payment.
Under federal law, pennies haven’t necessarily lost their value, but it’s unlikely the United States will put them back into production after the U.S. Treasury, under Scott Bessent, made the decision this past year to stop ordering more due to high production costs.
This is not a new problem for the U.S. Mint. The cost of making a penny jumped past its legal value in 2006, but the U.S. Congress has been sheepish about pulling it out of production completely, choosing instead to try to find ways to keep costs down.
As a result, today’s pennies are not made completely of copper, as their luster implies. Instead, the coin is 97.5% zinc and 2.5% copper, due to its plating.
Artazn, the Tennessee company which makes most pennies, lays out the process on its website. Bars of zinc are melted and pressed between rollers to create sheets of the metal, which then get stamped by another machine to create 22,000 coins per minute.
Then the pennies get rims and are coated with copper, ready to be shipped to the two big U.S. Mint facilities in Denver or Philadelphia to receive Lincoln’s profile.
Unsurprisingly, Artazn is one of the few groups which lobbied to keep the penny, arguing the process should be made cheaper instead of nixing the coin completely. They also point to the nickel — a coin that’s actually made of copper and tin as the real problem. The five-cent piece costs over 14 cents to make.
So how have businesses been adapting to no more pennies? Some have had few problems, especially as customers have been keen to offload them, while other businesses have been taking steps to ensure they have them in hand.
Back in November, for example, Market 32 and Price Chopper held a “Double Exchange Day” to pull in more pennies, resulting in the accumulation of nearly 20 million coins for the grocery store chain to beef up their supplies.
“At this time, our stores have a good supply of pennies and will continue to provide exact change to our customers,” Market 32’s director of community relations, Pam Cerrone, said in an email. “If we reach a point where rounding becomes necessary, we will communicate this to our customers in advance.”
The company ended up paying people back in gift cards worth double the penny price, giving out $395,000 in the process.
The penny situation for Hannaford Supermarkets is similar. They’ve got enough for the moment, although they’re “kindly encouraging our customers to use exact change whenever possible at our stores,” said Caitlin Cortelyou, a company spokesperson, in an email.
“Our teams are closely monitoring the situation and will make adjustments as needed, in line with all federal, state and local guidance,” she added.
For smaller, more local businesses, the situation is a little more hodgepodge. At ReMarket, owner Lise-Anne Cooledge said she isn't having any problems at the moment, although she has noticed she’s not getting as many from bank requests as she had prior to the penny’s end of production.
Meanwhile, Chad Heath, an employee at Stone’s Auto, posted on Facebook this past week asking for customers to bring some pennies in because they “just barely ran out.” The response was strong, he said, and the business quickly filled up its coffers.
Some stores, too, have already made the leap to round purchases up or down depending on the last cent. Regular customers of Stewart’s Shops have likely already noticed.
Instead, the biggest difficulty for many businesses has been not knowing exactly what to do about the penny, Cooledge said. When the federal government made the move, it didn’t release a FAQ about it until six months later, and details remained sparse even with the info.
Additionally, Vermont’s state legislators tried to get a law in place that would have determined how businesses should round up or down, although the momentum for the bill seems to have petered out since.
“It would be nice to have some guidance,” Cooledge said. “Then the customers would know what to do.”
If the penny is on its way out, is there any point in saving them? Despite the idiom, the answer seems to be “Not really.”
As Cleare put it — “They’re not rare, and they’re not going to be rare in my lifetime.”
Changeover in coinage, in fact, are pretty regular occurrences in history, although it usually only happens every few decades. Australia, for example, stopped making its own pennies in 1992, and Canada ceased production in 2012. Both countries cited high costs as the reasons.
But then, you don’t have to point to other countries for retired coinage examples. Looking at American history, the U.S. Mint had half-pennies, 2-cent coins and 3-cent coins up until 1873, when Congress introduced additional regulation to how the U.S. Mint functioned.
Some of those old coins can be worth something, especially if they’re made of copper and silver and in good condition.
It’s doubtful, however, to expect today’s penny to appreciate over time. The Messenger reached out to a few local coin collectors to get their opinions, but they all declined to go on record about their thoughts.
The general summary, however, was that pennies will likely be worth exactly how much the federal government thinks they’re worth. At this time, that’s .01 dollars. In comparison, a high quality half-penny from the 19th century might get someone $50 to $100 from a buyer.
So what should Americans do with pennies? Keep using them and keep losing them.
Taking a lesson from history, the coins will probably be scattered about the United States for another few decades, hidden under couch cushions and stuck in cup holders, steadily losing their value thanks to inflation.
And likely someday, the nickel might join them.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here