ST. ALBANS — Vermont’s hospitals need some help.
Green Mountain Care Board (GMCB) officials came to St. Albans last week to deliver that message and highlight the financial issues facing Franklin County’s Northwestern Medical Center.
If revenue and cost trends continue, GMCB officials made it clear that the local hospital could be operating in the red for the foreseeable future until changes are made statewide.
“This is not our process, but we are an active and willing participant in the process,” NMC CEO Peter Wright said. “NMC has been the leading edge of healthcare reform going back over a decade when the all-payer model first came out. We will be at the leading edge of the next generation of healthcare reform.”
“For years, we at the care board have heard that healthcare in Vermont is unaffordable. This has been said in Vermont for a decade, if not two or three,” GMCB chair Owen Foster said Wednesday at the start of the community meeting held in St. Albans City Hall. “ Employers and families are facing skyrocketing insurance premiums, and patients are grappling with rising insurance premiums, rising out-of-pocket costs for X-rays, office visits, procedures and drugs.
And in a nation with some of the worst healthcare costs in the world, Vermont is one of the states with the most expensive health care,” he added.
Now, the GMCB is hoping to tackle that problem by taking a close look at how the state’s hospitals deliver their services.
Wednesday night’s meeting was one of several scheduled this summer throughout the state to explain what the GMCB – tasked with exploring healthcare solutions via Act 167 in 2022 – has been doing over the last few years.
Officials also explained potential solutions and identified what communities would need to do if Vermont wants to keep its hospitals in the wake of its ongoing demographic shift.
“No other state is looking at the demographic and expense growth trends and trying to envision a delivery system that can both meet community needs and withstand headwinds financially that are coming its way. No other state is seeking such comprehensive and innovative solutions,” Foster said. “So this is a time of opportunity and choice.”
To make it happen though, state officials said they’re going to need a large-scale approach with plenty of help.
“I want to emphasize that this is not just a dialogue for today,” human services secretary Jenney Samuelson said. “But it’s the beginning of an ongoing conversation. We must continue to work together as a community to address the challenges ahead of us.”
As GMCB officials explained, Vermont’s healthcare industry has “a short runway” to tackle major problems around its lagging revenues, increasing costs and poor outcomes.
Before the COVID-19 pandemic even began, healthcare costs had been rising dramatically year-over-year with little political will to tackle the issue on a federal scale. But then the pandemic made everything worse.
Years later though, hospitals are still operating by the skin of their teeth.
“We thought it was covid. We thought it was inflation. We thought it would go back down. It hasn’t, and we do not see signs of that pervading and that makes this moment to make decisions to ensure our affordability really important,” Foster said.
The board’s reasons behind the high costs revolve primarily around growing difficulties involving staffing and patient needs.
Due to Vermont’s low unemployment rate and housing shortage, hospitals are having harder times trying to recruit and keep healthcare staff, which has caused financial strains. Meanwhile, more and more people using the hospitals are dealing with unmet social needs, forcing the hospital to provide treatment for issues they’re not best-suited to handle when someone shows up at the hospital looking for help.
Add Franklin County’s demographic problems into the mix, and NMC faces real headwinds trying to make the revenues come out on top. An analysis of the demographic trends estimates that there will be 26% less working age people in NMC’s coverage area by 2040.
This past year, nine out of 14 of Vermont’s hospitals – including NMC – had negative operating margins, and GMCB estimates that if revenues and costs continue at their current rate, NMC will be operating 14% below margin by 2028.
To change the trend, the GMCB identified a number of solutions meant to help tackle different aspects of the problem.
One of the biggest would be expanding on the healthcare services currently available. A consistent difficulty for NMC has been a lack of primary care providers in the region to help people identify health problems and avoid the emergency room.
“A key point here, you’d really like to have preventative care and primary care in the community. That at the top is the root of the issue. When you don’t have those or they are limited, then care is squeezed into the more expensive areas,” industry consultant Bruce Hamory said.
Other proposed fixes would help the hospital system use resources more effectively and efficiently. They include increasing the number of shared support services across hospitals, utilizing professional emergency medical services and creating a statewide bed inventory.
NMC is also considering ways to better deliver services by expanding on rural outreach programs, instituting telehealth, having more hours for their primary care service and creating a regional service line able to provide access to specialists.
Hamory said Vermont communities and the healthcare industry would need to design such a system carefully, but it would bring healthcare closer to people who need those services.
“We want a future healthcare system in Vermont that focuses on earlier identification and treatment of illness and patients being able to obtain care at the most appropriate level, in their home, in their community or close by.”
While the board offered some solutions, fixing the larger problems with Vermont’s healthcare system will likely require multiple large-scale fixes, Hamory explained, as the problems are system wide. Housing is a good example.
“We’ve heard stories from a number of hospitals where they have recruited a doctor, or a nurse, or a lab tech. They’ve come to work. They leave after three months of living in a hotel,” Hamory said.
In that vein, the state could be helpful in attacking some of these issues, and the GMCB expects to eventually report back to the legislature with their findings in tow to help energize the work.
Additional statewide efforts like improving transportation, enlarging the workforce, reducing administrative work and creating new pathways for appropriate levels of care would also all have some impact to push back on the issues hamstringing the hospitals.
“This is not something that the hospital can do alone, that the agency of Human Services can do alone, or that the Green Mountain Care Board can do alone. It’s something that we need to do collaboratively, together with this community and with communities across Vermont,“ Samuelson said.
Wright said there’s a question of “quality versus quantity” at play when talking about cost and health outcomes. When people seek out treatment, there’s often such a strong focus on quantity that can ignore the true costs of providing medical treatment.
“I have watched time after time after time, people – and even my other mother – say ‘throw the kitchen sink in. I don’t care what you have to do. If you have to get the Blue Angels here, fly the Blue Angels.’ But how much does it cost the rest of society? …” Wright said.
“We have to look at what are the things that can actually provide an intervention that will make a meaningful difference versus the things that matter,” he added.
Wright also explained some of the efforts that NMC is currently undertaking to try to tackle its revenue problems, like the Medical Respite Bed Program, CAIRES ACH, group purchasing and cross-organization collaboration.
“We’re being very creative and breaking down the walls, and now we’ve created a network within our community. So we’re connecting with primary care health partners. We’re connecting with home health. We’re connecting with NOTCH (Northern Tier Center for Health). We’re connecting with NCSS (Northwestern Counseling & Support Services), and we’re trying to figure out how we can save them money as well,” Wright said.
A complete list of community engagement meetings being held by the GMCB can be found at https://gmcboard.vermont.gov/Act-167-Community-Meetings#Past
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here