ST. ALBANS – Two crowds gathered on the lawn of the Northwestern Medical Center (NMC) Friday afternoon, separated by a physical road leading to the hospital and by their view on whether or not the nurses of NMC should form a union.
For one side, clad in red and joined by Vermont Attorney General T. J. Donovan and Lt. Gov. David Zuckerman, the answer was a resounding yes, as the union would give nurses a collective voice as they discussed staffing problems with NMC’s administration.
On the other side, another group of nurses declared they would oppose unionizing, saying that they already felt they could voice their concerns with the NMC administration and that a union would only “provide another bridge” to cross when speaking with hospital leadership.
A campaign calling for union elections among NMC’s nursing staff had reportedly been at work for several months now, predating a strike from the nurse’s union at the University of Vermont (UVM) Medical Center, according to NMC nurse Kasey Thompson-Lowell.
The campaign was formally announced late last month, with nurses accusing the hospital’s leadership of largely overlooking the nurses’ suggestions related to hospital staffing and conditions, as well as some requests for tools and equipment. The nurses also said that the hospital would adjust to complaints from nurses, but that those changes were never permanent.
According to the nurses, NMC has struggled attracting and maintaining staffing numbers for its nurses, meaning that its current staff of 180 nurses have had to pick up the pace with unfavorable scheduling and nurse-patient ratios
Through a union, they suggested, nurses could collectively argue for some of the needs in their respective units as well as argue to maintain some of the policy changes previously sought be nurses.
While their late September announcement saw pro-union nurses suggest there wasn’t any animosity between nurses and hospital leadership, the pro-union nurses who gathered on Friday were more critical of some of the relationships within the hospital.
“We are here today to stand in support of our colleagues, who have been bullied, and berated by our administration simply because they are actively working to improve working conditions at our community hospital,” said NMC nurse Debbie Choquette. “We have a right to organize our union without fear or intimidation.”
She cited two examples where nurses that were more vocally supportive of unionizing were pulled away from work to discuss some of their activities. Choquette said that, in both occasions, particular grievances hadn’t been raised with the nurses, but instead they were held in meetings that focused more on general complaints.
“One of our nurses who had been very vocal about getting resources that we need was pulled away from patient care unexpectedly by our CEO for what ended up being 45 minutes,” Choquette said. “During this meeting, our CEO repeatedly questioned the nurse’s attitude and finally suggested that she might consider a new position.”
Another, Choquette said, had been called into a meeting with a hospital official for “doing too much communication about her union while at work.”
Both Zuckerman and Donovan spoke out in support of the union’s upcoming elections.
“I’m happy to stand in solidarity for the nurses who are not only advocating for themselves but for the patients of Franklin County,” Donovan said. “I believe in the right to organize. I believe in collective bargaining, to be able to sit down at a table with the other side and work out the differences.
“As somebody who is a brother to two nurses, who’s a son-in-law to a nurse and who is a grandson of a nurse, I’m with nurses!” Donovan continued.
“You’re really the frontline of the medical community on a daily basis,” Zuckerman said. “And what today is about is having… that day-to-day knowledge, that’s with patients every single day, having a voice in the process and making sure that you’re respected in terms of all that you give patients in the hospital and what it takes from your own family lives.”
Another nurse, Samantha McCarthy, said that some of the scheduling issues cut into their hours at work, something that, according to McCarthy, she couldn’t afford.
Across the lawn, a group of nurses opposed to unionizing gathered to criticize what they saw as an invitation to a third-party that would only muddle the nurses’ relationship with the hospital’s leadership, which, according to those nurses, was pretty strong.
“Many of us sought to understand why our colleagues thought a union was the only answer,” said nurse Daren Villemaire. “After engaging with several of those in favor of forming a union, those of us who believed differently… decided an alternative voice needed to be presented.”
Those opposed to the creation of a union admitted that some of their counterparts’ grievances were true – namely that NMC was facing a nursing shortage and a higher patient volume, which in turn created unfavorable staffing ratios for nurses and led to scheduling problems.
Still, according to the NMC nurses opposed to a union, a union wouldn’t be the solution.
“Those of us who have addressed difficult issues with administration in the past and have seen real changes understand that we do have a voice,” Villemaire said. “Our opinions do matter [and] for those of you who do not feel you have a voice, we urge you to speak louder… to those who can make a difference, rather than a third-party representative who represents a collective voice who compromises your own individual voice from being heard in a meaningful way.”
NMC’s reported staffing difficulties are not unique to the St. Albans hospital. According to the American Association of Colleges of Nursing, an increased need for nursing as the Baby Boomer population ages has been compounded by declining enrollments and a loss of faculty at nursing schools, leading to workforce shortages in hospitals nationwide.
A similar issue led the UVM Medical Center’s nurses’ union to issue a 48-hour strike earlier this summer.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here