FAIRFAX/GEORGIA — The Franklin-1 House district has two empty seats for voters in Georgia and Fairfax to fill this November election. And there are four candidates — two Democrats and two Republicans —looking to step up in Montpelier.
Those on the ballot include Caroline Bright (D-Georgia), Julie Filiberti (D-Fairfax), Keith Billado (R-Fairfax) and Bob Stebbins(R-Georgia). The four individuals are all relative newcomers to serving in elected office.
The legislative district is currently served by Rep. Carolyn Branagan (R-Georgia) and Rep. Ashley Bartley (R-Fairfax). Branagan plans to retire from the legislature after being a representative for over a decade, and Bartley is running for state senate.
To cover the race, the Messenger asked the same questions to all four candidates to get a better idea of their legislative intent and experiences. Their verbal answers have been slightly edited for brevity and clarity.
Filiberti: “I think good people need to step up and try to solve these problems. A lot of bipartisan legislation happened last year, so I know the legislature can work together on a lot of issues.
“Unfortunately, there were a lot of vetos and certain legislators changed their votes, and it felt like gridlock in a lot of things. But when good people are out there doing hard work, listening to their constituents and not listening to corporate lobbyists and working for Vermonters, the problems can be solved. I want to be one of those people.”
Billado: “I wanted to do something to try to lower costs, especially for housing and property taxes. They’re going up every year, including double-digit-percentage increases on a year-to-year basis. I had issues with the funding of the schools budgets this year, when they took $100 million out of the general fund to pay down property taxes. Under normal circumstances, you shouldn't have to do that. The cost of housing, the cost of healthcare, they’re all increasing at double digits with inflation faster than the national average.”
To emphasize his point, Billado explained that his oldest daughter and fiance secured financing to buy a house, but they haven’t been able to find anything within their price range.
“I also want to try to dial back some of the vitriolic rhetoric between the two sides. I’m a centrist more than anything. There’s got to be a consensus or a middle ground that we can all come to.”
Bright: “I decided to run because, frankly, we need a legislature that reflects people's lived experiences, and there is an incredibly small number of representatives in our legislature right now who are under the age of 60. I am the youngest person in my entire race by almost 30 years, and that's pretty typical across the board. We need people who are living the hard parts of life right now to engage in the process, not people who were raising kids 30 years ago, but people who have kids right now.
“If we're passing legislation about funding early childhood education, it might be helpful to have perspective from parents who have children in early childhood right now. So that's kind of a micro example of this broader thing that's we need to have a wide variety of representatives, and I would bring a different perspective and different voice to the table than we typically see.
“Serving in elective office is the best way to help the most people at one time, and it also gives you a platform and a voice to help people with issues that might not be something that we're going to address with a bill.”
Stebbins: “Carolyn Branagan announced she was retiring from the House and I didn’t see anybody rushing to fill the void. After a couple of conversations with her, she wanted someone good for Georgia and Fairfax. I wasn’t sure about any other candidates, but after a few long conversations with her, I have a lot of experience in public safety and as a veteran of the Marine Corps and if I get elected, I could bring something to the table in Montpellier.
“Something that is frustrating is the property tax situation in Vermont has gotten out of control. If I can do anything as a freshman legislator is to be on the team that reins it in a little bit. It’s a good use of my time. I think that’s the bipartisan issue. Democrats, Republicans and Progressives all have to work together if we can come up with any revenue streams.”
Filiberti: “I’ve lived in Vermont for almost 30 years. We moved here and raised our family. We moved when kids were very young, 2 and 4, to give them a good life in Vermont. And immediately once we got here, I stepped into the community.”
Some of Filiberti’s group associations include being a girl scout troop leader, the PTA president and a Four Winds program coordinator when she worked as a paraeducator for 18 years. She retired in 2021, and currently serves as a justice of the peace, a Vermont master naturalist and a board member with Friends of the Missisquoi Wildlife Refuge.
“Other than that, I don’t have any particular experience outside of being a Vermonter — being one of those working families trying to raise kids and struggling to make ends meet in Vermont.”
Billado: Billado is a self-employed gunsmith in Fairfax as the owner of Firearms Repair. He’s been in business for the last 17 years. Prior to that work, Billado said he was head gunsmith in charge of research and development for a larger company, so he also has some supervisory experience.
“I know how to deal with people. Being a father of our adopted children, not everyone will see eye-to-eye on everything.”
Bright: “I think I've had a lot of experiences in the realm of politics. I do have a degree in political science. In college, I completed internships with Senator Leahy's office, with the office of then Speaker of House Shap Smith. When I was Miss Vermont, my platform was about getting women to run for public office. Go figure. Here we are.”
Bright explained a childhood experience when she went with her grandmother to Montpelier and had the chance to watch the political proceedings surrounded by other legislators. After learning more about the process, she said she recognized that Vermont is a place where you can work with your neighbors to “actually get things done” unlike what’s seen in national politics.
“...but arguably, the things that best qualify me for this role are not the traditional political things, but the perspective that I bring as a mom of young kids, as a small business owner, as someone who was born and raised in Vermont and has also left and come back. Someone who is dealing with these issues of rising property taxes while wanting to balance quality education. It's that lived experience that I think is the best qualifier.”
Stebbins: “I’m a lifelong Vermonter. … I feel like it’s given me a good appreciation of the struggles and values of rural Vermont as well as the more-urbanized Vermont. I worked in Chittenden County for 30 years going up every rank. … I’ve done every job that you can do with the Sheriff’s Department in Chittenden County.”
“I got a bachelors from Castleton for English and served on the school newspaper, and I think my military background qualifies. I had a chance to travel to some other states and countries while in the marines. The combo of experience – not an expert on any one topic – has given me a broad ability to listen and just learn. I think as a freshman rep, those are two of your most important attributes to take to Montpelier – the ability to listen to people and to learn new things.”
Stebbins also explained how serving in the military and later in law enforcement gave him a broad range of experiences around problem-solving.
“You have to think quickly on your feet and figure things out. There’s a place for that in Montpelier as a place for deliberative thought. You need to know how to pivot on the issue. And I’m good at knowing when you have the time to have five to six days to decide, compared to five or six minutes or seconds. That’s a skill that most veteran police officers have developed over the years through trial and error.”
Filiberti: “My ideal Vermont is more like to what I moved to. I felt it was affordable. It was a great place to raise kids. People took pride in their communities. They still do, but it’s getting tougher and I think a lot of people are giving up. My kids have moved out of the state and can’t afford to return. (My vision for Vermont) is a vibrant Vermont that people can afford to live in and where people take care of each other, take care of the land and the environment and are happy.”
Billado: “My ideal Vermont would be where there’s plenty of work and industry and jobs for our children so our children don’t have to move out of the state in large numbers now to find employment.
“Vermont is primarily rural with some large companies, but we don’t have a lot of major industries. It takes a bit to get in, and we’re not welcoming to all businesses. Some businesses don’t want to come here … What I’d like to see is everybody being able to live. One of the problems that the state is running into right now is there are fewer and fewer childcare options for parents to bring their children to and a lot of that has to do with regulations. … In order to run a daycare center, you have to have a college degree. To me the average mother doesn’t have a college degree but she can take care of her children.”
“We have to find a solution to the problems that the hospital is facing with the State of Vermont. I just saw today that UVM Medical Center let go employees (199). They shouldn’t have to do that. We have to find a solution to the problem. There are solutions out there that can be worked at.“
Bright: “My ideal Vermont would be a place where families can afford to live here, where families can afford to pay for childcare, where childcare workers can afford to work in childcare. It would be a place where every single student in Vermont receives the incredibly high quality education that best suits them and their needs. It's a Vermont where people can just decide to live here and be embraced by the communities that they opt into, and I think a lot of these things are already true in some places, but they're not true across the board everywhere.
“And I think they should be true for every family, every child, every person who wants to come here. I am proud to be a fourth-generation Vermonter, raising my kids in the same family home my family's lived in for five generations, and I also think that we need to enthusiastically embrace people who choose Vermont. It's not just about, oh well, has your family been here since Ethan Allen stormed the gates of Ticonderoga? It should be about who chooses this place.”
Stebbins: “My ideal Vermont is a fiscally-sound Vermont so (people) aren't leaving as quickly as they are. I’d love to see Vermont start gaining population, but not so quickly that it can’t absorb it. And I’d like to see a net-gain of population instead of a net loss. I’m thinking we can do that here without sacrificing the environmental gains. … I remember when Dean Davis was Republican governor, he was a big supporter of the environmental laws that were lacking in Vermont.
“I support those (environmental regulations) but not if they’re at the expense of small business and large business. The regulatory process is very onerous.
“Let’s identify the problem, and let’s see if we can come up with a compromise that everyone could live with, to get people to come back to Vermont and not leave in the first place.
“I think in general terms, we lose a lot of Vermonters to Florida, North Carolina and Tennessee, and we do seem to be losing people faster than gaining them, and I think the key to a strong tax base to get them here is a fair tax on property.
“‘A rising tide floats all boats,’ and that’s what we need to do to get back to that – more people paying a smaller amount of tax. When you add everything together, we could have a robust economy here and we can dig ourselves out of our deficits that we find ourselves in. I think it can be done.”
Filiberti: Filiberti identified healthcare, housing – to help decrease homelessness – and education as top issues.
“Education needs to be tackled. We need to be making kids our priority in Vermont and their education needs to be top-notch. That costs money, but it’s unaffordable for Vermonters right now. Something has to be worked out to be able to fund what our kids need to go forth in the world, and not impact seniors and families. What we’re doing is not working. Something else needs to be figured out.
”I would love to be able to work towards universal primary healthcare. I think that is a big focus. I believe that healthcare is part of the root of some of the affordability problems in Vermont. There is a big push to get the legislature to address it. I think it’s doable. That’s one of my big pushes to make sure that Vermont can provide primary care. Vaccinations and mental health are huge as well. Any preventative care should be free of charge for people to make it easily accessible. In the long run, it’s going to cost us less money than we're all paying now.”
Billado: “The top issue for the people I talk to is the economy. The cost of property taxes alone are killer for a lot of people. Income-sensitivity is involved in some of the equations for the property taxes but we have to come up with a better solution.”
“The high cost of goods and services, the fact that there’s a lack of housing and lack of housing being built, is a major problem. When our children can’t afford to buy a house, to live in the state that they want to live in. A lot of people still love the state.“
Bright: “The number one issue that I hear about all the time: taxes, taxes, taxes, taxes, and our taxes are driven by the cost of education, and the way education is driven by the cost of healthcare and the cost of insurance and how that relates to healthcare. So, the biggest issue that I'm hearing from people is the financial crunch, and figuring out how we, at the state level, can make things more affordable.
“Whether it's housing, whether it's opening a business, whether it's how do we make this achievable and affordable for Vermonters, and that's why I think we need to take a look at very closely how the cost of healthcare impacts the cost of education. Other than that, one of my pet issues is comprehensive cell phone coverage. I have been talking about comprehensive cell phone coverage in Georgia and Franklin County since 2012, and the fact that I still need to talk about it because I can't get a signal at my house.”
Stebbins: “One thing I definitely hear from voters is the issue of the property tax and its connection with school funding and school choice. There’s got to be a way to have good schools without substantial cuts and not be overreliant on the property tax. That would be my most important issue.”
“You can see that there’s no real center in the town of Fairfax and Georgia anymore. These small businesses will crop up and in a year or less, they’re out of business. If we’re doing something incorrectly in Vermont to support small businesses, it’s about what we can do better to attract small business owners and keep them here. If someone comes in and hires six employees, I would love to see them go up to 20, but I don’t see that happening.
“I’d love to see another store somewhere that was also thriving, but it would be nice – not to increase competition – but we have enough room to have two general stores. When ABC went out of business, you don’t have anywhere to get a sandwich.”
“I’d like to see if there’s an answer or if it’s the free-market economy. Some of it is that, and you have to accept that fact, but I’d like to see what can be done.”
Filiberti: “I believe that consolidation is not the answer. It’s not proven to provide cost savings. I truly believe that Vermont is a rural state and each town’s vibrancy usually centers around its schools. By eliminating schools and sending kids into other towns, Vermont is going to lose its ‘Vermontness’ and its small-town communities.”
“If you look at Franklin West, (which includes Georgia, Fairfax and Fletcher) we already share resources, and that is definitely the way to do it but the simple education piece needs to remain in the communities. … Instead of sharing the kids with the resources, bring the resources to the kids.”
Billado: “We have a declining student enrollment population in the State of Vermont. They’re declining. Back when Act 60 was instituted (in 1997), before that there was some school districts that were less wealthy than others, and they may have suffered a bit in the equation, but it’s worse because we’re talking about shutting some of these schools down by consolidating and driving children across to other school districts, which affects rural areas”
“Vermont pays close to two times the national average per student and we’re ranked lower in Alabama as far as test scores. Somewhere in there, somebody has dropped the ball. … We have to get to the bottom of it and find out why (schools) are so expensive.”
Bright: “I think one of the biggest drivers of the cost of education is healthcare, and we have to make sure that we are providing our teachers with the healthcare that they deserve. But we should be providing every Vermonter with access to healthcare coverage that they deserve and that they need to be healthy. “
“So, universal primary care is something I'm very interested in. I don't think it's the pie in the sky idealistic wild idea that it was 10 years ago or 15 years ago. I think it's becoming something that is a much more practical, affordable solution, and that's becoming clearer and clearer every single time our tax bills go up for our property taxes. “
“I think one of the fundamental problems (in education) that we have is the funding mechanism. It was a funding mechanism that was invented decades ago and made sense and was a good idea then. We need to reevaluate how it's functioning in the world we live in now.”
“The reality is that in Georgia, our test scores are improving every year. There might be a national narrative about test scores…. But you're not going to be able to measure how good a fish is at climbing a tree. Different people have different strengths and abilities. Testing is one way of doing it. But ultimately, the best ways that we can determine our success as an educational system is more complicated than just test scores.
“Overall, education in Vermont is exceptionally good compared to the rest of the country. The entire country is struggling in terms of education. We have to understand the reality that this still is a post-COVID world. We feel like everything has gone back to normal, but the reality is that our sixth graders today were first graders and kindergarteners when COVID was happening, and that will have a permanent impact on their educational experience. It just will.
We need to be addressing that. Now, the overall educational system is a more complicated answer. I am vehemently opposed to forced school consolidation. I think it's wrong on every level. Forced school consolidation is never going to be the right fit for any community.”
Stebbins: “My weakest link is the educational component. I haven’t really studied it, but I think you can find a balance between school consolidation and still allowing communities to have a local school. The governor has plans that not everybody agrees with, but what really is important is nobody wants to see the quality of education diminish. But our per capita spending per pupil and sometimes our results aren’t showing up on standardized achievement tests. I think there’s probably a lot of room for improvement. There's a lot of potential that we have and maybe we’re not realizing that potential. I’d love to see what people say on both sides, to see if there is a consolidation situation where we can save some money for the taxpayers and keep quality while not having to have a ridiculous distance (for students) to drive.”
Filiberti: “I’ve always felt since I lived here that Fairfax is a bedroom community. Most people commute somewhere else to work. We don’t have the businesses that we used to other than Runamok Maple. We had Milton Bradley, but there’s not much industry in Vermont. There’s not a lot of business in Vermont to alleviate the taxes on the citizens, so I think that some development would benefit us in that way.
“When it comes to housing, we have grown what-feels-like exponentially since moving here. Housing is still a problem but what I’d like to see is the development of small housing.
“You have these three- or four-bedroom houses, like one that we moved into. Our kids are now grown. … And the house is too big for us. We would love to be able to move to something smaller and open up for the bigger houses for growing families”
“We have people like us who don’t want to leave their community but there’s now no place for them to go. So if we were to build co-op developments to be with neighbors and be in a smaller house and still remain in their communities. And it’s a smaller footprint for them, which would open up larger houses for families. I would like to see that development and don’t want to see more three- or four-bedroom houses that are priced out of range for growing families.’
Billado: “I’d like to see more rational development. There are places in Franklin county and even in Fairfax where some industries peacefully coexist with housing in a suburban-type setup,
“There are ways to build more moderately-priced housing with more square-footage.”
Billado identified “Not-in-my-backyard” attitudes as one of the bigger reasons behind delays in new projects, which increases the cost to build, but he pushed back against the idea that housing has to cost as much as it does, identifying a Habitat for Humanity project in Rutland and the an ongoing state initiative to use standardized panels for housing construction as potential steps in the right direction.
“If (new families) can start out and fit into something that fits their means. That’s how it's always been in the history of the country.”
Bright: “I certainly want our tax base to improve. Yeah, I mean, I think that that's really important everywhere. Our tax base needs to increase in order to keep up with the realities of the financial situation of the world in general, and also in order to make sure that our communities are sustainable. Just relying on the same taxpayers who own this particular house to be the entire tax base is not sustainable. We do need to have a diversified tax base. We need to have businesses. … In Georgia, there are so many things I would like to see. In Georgia. I would love for us to have a true community center. I would love for us to connect the different resources in our town geographically. I would love to have a coffee shop.”
As for Fairfax, Bright noted that the town was quickly growing, and she’s been learning more about the various needs of the town and residence.
“The other piece of this is there are no perfect answers. I know we want there to be a perfect silver bullet that is the correct answer, so that no one can tear apart any part of it. But that's not the case. You're not going to have a perfect answer.”
Stebbins: “I’d like to see more development because it’s the key to growing our population, as long as we do it sensibly as stewards of the environment. I think you can do it both. It doesn't have to be exclusive. If you fly across Vermont, you can see thousands and thousands of acres of farmland and forests. Some of them are currently being used and some are not. At 6,000 feet, there seems to be some room to have some sensible development and preserve some open areas – to do both.”
“In general, I support more development. In general, I support more growth in Vermont, as I think it’s stagnated for too many years.”
Filiberti: “I don’t have particular ideas, but I’m a listener. What I intend to do is listen to everyone's viewpoint about what things are happening. … I’m not coming forth with my own agenda, but I want to be able to hear ideas and figure out the best path forward.”
Billado: “This last legislative session, the total property tax intake was $1.8 billion. That’s what they took in. That’s a lot of money while using the $100 million from the general fund, which means they don’t have that money available to fix roads, to help towns install septic systems or to help them upkeep. A lot of these sewage systems in these towns are aging and have aged quite a bit. … Taking that 100 million to pay down property taxes. They shouldn’t have to do that. They’re not putting the money into the roads and bridges.”
Bright: “Honestly, I don't know. I haven't gotten a chance to be a legislator yet. I haven't gotten a chance to participate in the budget process yet. I haven't gotten a chance to do any of those things. So, the fair answer is I don't know, and anybody who represents Georgia and Fairfax also probably doesn't know because we would all be first-time legislators. My hope is that again, it comes back to having diverse perspectives. And one of the pieces of this puzzle is that yes, there is a majority party, and having connections and being involved in that party helps give you a better, stronger seat at the table for these communities. So that's a mechanism that's going to be important in these conversations. .. It's about listening to everyone in our district, not just the loudest voices who might yell the most on Facebook. But it's about truly understanding who is in our district, and then taking those perspectives to Montpelier and considering them. That, fundamentally, is the challenge of being a legislator.“
Stebbins: “I think that’s the tricky question. We would all love to have brand new bridges and brand new roads, and we don’t have a $50 million budget in Vermont. I think we need to move deliberately, carefully and slowly. The revenue that we bring in we need to be more creative with. I want us to have good bridges, good roads, good infrastructure whether that’s municipal sewer or water, or the lake,we need to move carefully and deliberately or we’ll tax people right out of existence.”
“It’s a moderate balance to understand the priorities and problems, and the real trick is coming up with solutions that people can live with.”
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here