HINESBURG — It was a hot day, but a cool breeze helped as it moved through David Zuckerman’s Full Moon Farm in Hinesburg.
He bought the place roughly 20 years ago as he grew his career — first as a legislator then Vermont’s lieutenant governor. And in politics, he said, sometimes you have to wait.
“Sometimes, you introduce a policy with a plan to get it done in a couple of years and it goes great. Other times, like some things I worked on, whether it was cannabis reform, which took 20 years and five different major shifts in policy… and then the federal government took it out,” he said.
He expects tackling Vermont’s current problems — like housing, environmental issues and affordability — will also take some time. But then again, not everyone will be getting the benefit of land-ownership and a cool breeze.
Zuckerman’s primary opponent Thomas Renner, a Winooski city councilor and deputy mayor vying for a state-level position for the first time, is arguing that Vermont’s experienced lieutenant governor isn’t stepping aside for new voices after spending close to 30 years in politics.
At 52, however, Zuckerman said he’s not that old, and instead, he has the experience and ability to lead on major issues when Vermont is most in need.
“I think there's a clear difference in which of the two of us, in this particular race, has the knowledge, experience, connections, skillset to step into that in a fairly seamless manner without a potential disruption for everyday Vermonters' lives,” he said. “And that's pretty serious responsibility.”
Zuckerman said there’s some truth in the idea that the lieutenant governor’s position is largely ceremonial, but that despite a lack of direct policy-making power, he also sees a big part of the role’s importance residing in the seatholder’s ability to uphold democratic ideals by connecting with people and renewing faith in government.
He’s received endorsements from a number of climate and labor advocacy groups, eight Vermont senators, including Senate President Pro Tempore Phil Baruth (D/P-Chittenden-Central), 36 Vermont House representatives, Burlington Mayor Emma Mulvaney-Stanak and other political figures, according to his website.
Although Vermont’s net population growth rate is generally minimal post-pandemic — due to the aging population as well as young people moving out — Zuckerman mentioned a lot of high earners have migrated to Vermont from the nearby Washington D.C., Baltimore, Philadelphia, New York City and Boston “megalopolis.”
He said the way Vermont handled the COVID-19 pandemic is attracting migration, as well as its vast outdoor space boasting a safe space to socialize in the event of another shut-down.
Other migration drivers he’s witnessed from conversations while running his stand at farmers markets, are political-climate-driven moves — for example, gay couples from Florida who moved here for Vermont’s legislation.
The problem is, a lot of those folks had the ability to sell their previous properties for a much higher price than what someone used to be able to buy something for in Vermont.
“So now we have this supply and demand problem, where 10,000 people leave Boston or New York and it's like an eyelash fell off there, nobody there notices,” Zuckerman said. “But 10,000 people move to Vermont, and it's like, there's nowhere left to live.”
“And on top of that, you got the investment buyers, buying properties and turning them into Airbnbs,” he added. “And you’ve got a huge second home market — 50,000 homes, or 17% of our homes — are second homes. There's no supply that can be at all in proportion to the demand to have a normal pricing scheme.”
The reasons are complicated, Zuckerman said. The cost of materials and labor post-pandemic have skyrocketed. Even if regulations are relaxed and housing development is better prioritized, Vermont’s carpenters, electricians and plumbers would still struggle to keep up with the inherent demand, further pushing housing prices way out of reach for your average resident.
So — what does that mean for younger Vermonters’ futures? What are government officials doing in an effort to solve this dilemma?
“There’s no magic answer,” Zuckerman said.
Still, he feels some of the legislative permitting changes to build up denser town and village centers have helped substantially. Like Renner, Zuckerman is not in favor of permitting more rural areas, such as the region surrounding his farm in Hinesburg, for dense development.
“We also need food and I think we need to re-localize food more than we have historically,” he said. “But if you do it proportionally to the town, pushing the envelope a little bit, you could actually build up quite a bit of housing.”
Another effort the legislature tried to do was to impose a 3% marginal income tax surcharge on earners of over half a million dollars per year, to subsidize housing and fund other programs aimed at addressing cascading effects of income inequality. Zuckerman pointed out senate economic development chair Rep. Kesha Ram Hinsdale, who endorsed Renner in this race, impeded the policy.
Though it ultimately failed to pass, and though many lawmakers argue that raising taxes on the wealthy will drive higher-earners out altogether, a VTDigger article from this past legislative session cited research indicating such millionaire tax flight concerns are vastly overstated.
“Nothing’s going to happen overnight,” Zuckerman said of addressing the housing shortage and affordability conundrum. “That’s the problem.”
He is in favor though of higher levels of future investment into government partnerships with nonprofits like Champlain Housing Trust, so they can do more expansive work to better keep up with the demand for affordable units of housing.
He does not believe a neoliberal free market for housing will simply “work itself out.”
Zuckerman himself is a landlord at two different properties in Burlington, though he said he rents his units at well below market rate. Although from a legislative standpoint, he’s supported different forms of rent control over time, and supported just-cause evictions in Burlington.
He said he’d love to see future legislation raising property taxes for owners of second homes and Airbnbs that are commonly vacant, either to open up the market to others, subsidize property taxes for lower-earners or to fund building of more affordable housing and rental units.
Zuckerman also views the climate issue as going hand-in-hand with the housing and development one.
As an avid environmentalist and Sen. Bernie Sanders enthusiast, having majored in environmental studies at UVM and hiked the Appalachian Trail, Zuckerman said he’s been fighting on the environmental and climate front for decades.
Although Vermont has perhaps made some more progress than other states, he said it is still intensely feeling the ramifications of a changing climate — as witnessed in the catastrophic flooding events witnessed both this and last July, which deeply impacted homes throughout Vermont as well as the livelihoods of many farmers he knows personally.
In addition, he is concerned about the burden of rising property taxes on Vermonters, and wants to explore how eliminating redundancies in the state government’s budget could make for a tighter, more efficient system resulting in both more savings and better outcomes.
Though he said when he brought the idea to Republican Gov. Phil Scott in 2017, they had just one 30-minute meeting, after which he said Scott never wanted to follow up.
One of Zuckerman’s approaches to the role of lieutenant governor over the years, as a public citizen and as an activist, has been to get informational newsletters out to people without the bandwidth to be active in government so they can draw their own conclusions and contact their legislators on a number of issues.
“As lieutenant governor, I probably have a slightly undue scale of influence compared to some in the past, because I have such a big email list around the state,” Zuckerman said. “I can really utilize that.”
He ran and lost for the governor’s seat to Scott the year COVID-19 hit, and said the way Scott managed the pandemic and the federal dollars that came to Vermont during that term solidified Scott as a hero in the eyes of many Vermonters, rendering the odds of beating him now less realistic, Zuckerman said — despite some of Scott’s less popular vetoes this past session.
“Some other states have more options,” Zuckerman said. “Here, we have two senators, one congressional seat and one governor's seat, so I felt like running [for lieutenant governor] again because I can still do a lot of good for these issues.”
His opponent, Renner — who is a 34-year-old gay, Black man from a working-class background, in contrast to Zuckerman’s upbringing in Brookline, Ma. — asked Zuckerman in a recent debate when he will step aside to make way for younger, more diverse voices.
In this case, the incumbent feels his experience makes him the more qualified candidate.
“He said, you know, ‘When will you get out of the way’ — and interestingly enough, I already have,” Zuckerman said. “A lot of people thought I should have run for Congress two years ago…
“I have good skill sets, I have the capacity,” he added. “But I knew with Vermont having never sent a woman, that as long as there was a woman who had the skill sets and the experience to do it — and there were plenty — I should not get in the way of that.”
Zuckerman said Rep. Becca Balint, who he believed had solid experience in addition to good stances on issues he cares about, deserved that seat. Indeed, Vermonters at the time proved to largely feel the same. She was elected to the House position in 2022.
In this race though, Zuckerman feels his depth and range of understanding on complex, specific issues, and his track record of success in putting forth difficult or controversial ideas and seeing them through to completion to the benefit of Vermonters, outweighs that of the competition.
“Whether it's marriage equality, cannabis reform, raising the minimum wage, medical aid in dying, Lyme disease, expanding agricultural opportunities for more diverse farms… having a track record of starting something and seeing it through is very valuable,” he said.
Zuckerman argues he’s in a position to more seamlessly step into the governor’s shoes in the event that anything might happen to Scott — one of the least-often utilized functions of lieutenant governor, yet one of its most critical responsibilities.
He also pointed out there’s no shortage of fresh ideas and fresh blood in the Vermont Senate already, which is the way the lieutenant governor has the most interaction with the legislature. Half of Vermont’s state senators currently are in that fresh-voices boat.
“And some voices don't want the changes that young people want,” Zuckerman said. “Being someone who is younger than that average, but old enough to be able to talk to and listen to old folks and explain why these changes need to happen, I would argue I'm probably in a better position to navigate those two worlds.”
Outside of his technical responsibilities as lieutenant governor, Zuckerman recently did a banned books tour across Vermont, reading aloud to kids from books that have been banned in libraries across the country and speaking out against those who try to limit the availability of LBTQ+ texts in school libraries, or who push back on allowing trained librarians to do their jobs.
And through conversations Zuckerman had with kids and parents of differing viewpoints on that tour, he described the result as akin to “planting a seed” — as in both farming and politics, it takes time to see fruits born from the labor that goes on behind the scenes.
He said he looks forward to planning additional opportunities to connect the people with their government moving forward — if elected for another term.
“I'm not Bernie by any means,” he said. “But I'm a whole lot closer to him at changing the system and fighting corporate money in politics than just about anybody else.”
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here