Legislators talk housing, education overall affordability in Enosburg; second ‘We the People’ town hall

Posted

ENOSBURG FALLS — About 45 people filed into the Enosburg Opera House Tuesday to hear from local legislators on how Vermont’s issues can be addressed when they head back to Montpelier in January. 

The event was the second “We the People” town hall held by the Franklin County Women for Democracy. The first town hall in October was held in St. Albans with no legislators showing up. 

This time around, however, state Rep. Penny Demar (R-Enosburgh), as well as Franklin County’s Sens. Randy Brock (R-St. Albans) and Robert Norris (R-Sheldon), fielded questions from residents as they sat on the opera house stage. 

“Their presence gives us a chance to engage directly with them, to ask questions and hear updates from the people representing us at the state level,” moderator Sarah Jo Willey Marcotte explained. 

Most of the public questions centered on the big issues that have been floating around Vermont’s ears for the past year; housing, education, healthcare and overall affordability. 

Housing

The first question of the night concerned Vermont’s housing and the ways the legislature could work to make it more affordable. 

Brock, who sits on the Senate Committee on Economic Development, Housing and General Affairs, said he will be looking at how to best increase the housing stock in the state. 

“Not just in Enosburgh, but throughout Vermont, there’s a tremendous shortage of housing, and as a result people, particularly of modest income, have great difficulty in obtaining housing,” Brock said. 

Though the legislature has done much on the issue in recent years, he said, including the passage of the CHIP bill this year, there’s still a lot more that could be done to build houses quicker by effectively eliminating the hurdles. 

Investment in housing from the Community Housing and Infrastructure Program, or CHIP, as well as the Tax Increment Financing (TIF) program used in St. Albans, are great examples of what municipalities were able to accomplish through the legislature’s efforts, Brock said, but the time needed to complete a project is still an issue. 

“It takes too long to do things in Vermont,” he said. “One of the things that we need is a regulatory environment that is more user-friendly, that’s faster, that's more responsive, that has less complication to do things.” 

Using the TIF concept again and again will increase tax revenue coming from the properties, Brock added. The hope is that with CHIP passed during the last session smaller municipalities will be able to take advantage of the program. 

In Enosburg, while Demar was driving around the village, he said he saw how many apartments were empty, as many owners said they don’t want to rent the buildings in fear of getting their properties wrecked by a bad renter. Instead, those empty apartments could be places for houses, he added. 

On the other side of the coin in Montgomery, Demar said there’s an influx of short-term rentals which are changing the housing supply in town.

“If I’m a homeowner, I’m going to go where the money is. I’ve invested a lot of money into a home or second home. Airbnb is money,” he said. “Those are homes or apartments that are being taken away from my housing market.” 

As the housing conversation evolved, legislators also took a few questions regarding homelessness in Franklin County and across the state. 

For Brock, the population of unhoused people is a concern, but a “significant” part of that goes back to substance abuse. 

“... that’s a specific category that we need to deal with separately than the person who was simply down on their luck and who is an honest, hard-working person, who has lost a job and doesn’t have the funds to pay for housing,” he said. 

For those people, Brock said the state has a number of programs that provide opportunity to get back on their feet. The people falling through the gaps, however, are those in need of long-term treatment. 

And although the state needs more of those programs, the big problem, Brock said, is money. 

“So the question is, where do we get the money to do those things?” he said. “That’s where TIF programs and similar kinds of programs that ultimately become self-funding [come in].” 

Education 

With the push from the governor to consolidate, and with the education task force report now available, the public also asked legislators for the next steps in the process and what it means for local schools. 

During the last session, the people of Vermont said they had enough of the price of education, Demar said, and Act 73 was born out of that. The legislature had strong numbers of support for the bill and the message was sent, he added. 

“The governor came up with something, and it was panic immediately and it was thrown out before it was even really looked at,” Demar said. “I felt bad that a lot of this didn’t go that route and work on it. We didn’t do nothing, and now we’re back to square one.” 

For the foundation formula component of the bill, Demar said he doubts schools in Chittenden County are willing to go for it, and with a majority of voters coming from the county he thinks it's going to stop in the legislature. 

Also looking at the number of supervisory unions and districts, Vermont has too many, he said. 

The taskforce recommended voluntary mergers with cooperative services for bigger needs like special education and transportation instead of creating new district boundaries. Because of that decision, Demar said the legislators are back to stage one. 

But the legislature has been there before, Brock chimed in. 

“There are lots of dilemmas in education, but one of the major dilemmas is we have a very labor-intensive educational system in which the ratio of pupils to adults is shocking,” he said. 

With the numbers Vermont has, Brock said they should be expecting better results, but that’s slipping through the cracks as well, so the issue also becomes one of accountability. 

“When you start talking about accountability in education, all the fingers point in every direction except for themselves,” he said. 

With the increases in the cost of education, property taxes and the set back from the redistricting task force, Demar and Brock said something needs to be done and questions need to be asked. 

As for Norris, he said after Act 73 passed both chambers of the legislature he thought there would be some direction on what to do next and how to improve funding. But that didn’t happen, and kept the state at status quo, he said. 

“I don’t know what the answer is, but we can’t continue down that door,” Norris said.

Affordability 

During discussions around spending, some of the public in attendance wanted to know if legislators were considering a different way of acquiring funding, whether through taxing the ultra rich of Vermont, or through income tax. 

Brock, who also sits on the senate’s financing committee, said the problem with taxing the super wealthy of the state is really that there just isn’t enough of them around to make a difference. Not only is there not enough of them, Brock continued, but the state has a progressive tax system with people on the higher end of the scale already paying more. 

The trouble is those with wealth can also move away, he said. Once the price is too high, Vermont will lack some of the income it needs. 

“We want more wealthy people in Vermont because they give us lots of money at a much higher percentage than people who are moderate income,” he said. “That’s the dilemma.” 

As for switching property tax to income tax or some sort of mixture, Demar said he’s not in favor of the move. 

“I’ve got tons of friends, tons of relatives, tons of neighbors and that’s probably the most unfairest tax,” he said. “You get somebody to plow your driveway or mow your lawn, you pay them cash. That’s income. Are they going to show that?” 

There’s also just no way the state can raise enough money through the income tax system. Instead, the most fair tax is a sales tax, he added. 

Norris, who sponsored a bill to exempt statewide taxes on social security, said that’s a way to put a pep back into the economy’s step. Those on social security would pour the money they would have been taxed back into local mom and pop shops, he said. 

“I think by putting more money back into the economy it’ll keep people here,” he said. “It may bring people from outside the state into Vermont, and we’ll have more money going into the economy. I think it's a good thing to at least look at.” 

In the last session, the legislature exempted tax on military retirement income for the same reason, in order to attract people leaving the military and bring their families and critical skills to the state, Norris said, 

The end result is it fills the businesses who are short to hire people, increases the tax base and puts kids into the schools. Attracting people was also some of the goals in programs meant to get people who want to remote work but live in Vermont, Brock added. 

Healthcare

The bow which wraps all the problems together is healthcare, as many of those who asked questions pointed out. 

On the healthcare front, Brock said the legislature over the years has expanded healthcare and made prices more transparent, but the range of prices you can find at hospitals throughout the state is dramatic. 

The other side of healthcare comes in prescription costs, and Brock said they need to ask more questions and make it more obvious to the public to find those cheaper prices, potentially through artificial intelligence and accessibility. 

For Demar, the healthcare front is a mess, as he sits on the healthcare committee in the house. 

“This will be my fourth session, and I get very disgusted,” he said. “This is what I hear in my committee; ‘they did this, they did that, we got to do this,’ I finally got sick of it.” 

To him, the legislature was grasping at straws over the last session to find a solution before handing off more authority to the Green Mountain Care Board. Now, heading into the new year, Demar said he’s discouraged. The committee, he said, sits and talks and debates but then scraps it and goes for something new. 

Although he’s now going into four years in the legislature, Demar said he’s not sure how to continue. 

“I haven’t been there long enough for that. No seriously, that’s it,” he said. 

Norris said he’s concerned about the cost and the impact it’s having on Vermonts, but his concern is how much “free healthcare” is going out. But on the horizon, Norris said, is reference-based pricing in which health insurance sets payments for services as a percentage of medicare. 

Another problem in the health space is the gap in insurance providers. With only two in the state and the small and elderly population of Vermont, he said he didn’t see another one coming sometime soon. 

“I’m looking forward to this reference based pricing … that’s a step in the right direction,” Norris said. “We didn’t reach this problem overnight, so we’re not going to fix it overnight so it’s going to take a while and we’ll all suffer from it.” 

Heading back into the legislator, Brock said it’s time for Vermont to look to realism and prioritization. Instead of creating the “first in a nation” Vermont way, maybe the legislature can take a page from neighboring states to find solutions for many of the issues facing residents. 

“We have a very difficult time looking backward at things that didn’t work to figure out how to avoid doing them again,” he said.

housing, education, healthcare, franklin county

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here