MONTPELIER –– Education reform will be center stage in the legislature this session after Gov. Phil Scott spent his annual address to legislators insisting they finish what they started.
Never deviating from the subject, Scott directed lawmakers Wednesday to finish the work of implementing Act 73, last year’s education transformation bill. The law establishes a process for consolidating Vermont’s school districts and implementing a statewide tax rate.
“This session we have the opportunity and the obligation to continue this transformation in order to build the best public education system in the nation at a cost taxpayers can afford,” he said.
Since the COVID-19 pandemic, school costs have risen with inflation and increased student needs. Scott pointed out education spending in Vermont has gone from $1.6 billion at the beginning of his governorship in 2017 to $2.5 billion set to be paid this year.
Cuts to local school budgets haven’t brought the kind of economic relief taxpayers are looking for, causing the Scott administration to advocate for sweeping change.
Key to that plan, in Scott’s view, is the consolidating of school districts, especially those with few students.
“Just look at the size difference. Some schools have well over a thousand students, others have less than fifty,” he said. “And because our funding formula doesn’t actually provide equity, many schools are underfunded, even though on average we have among the highest per-pupil spending in the country.”
But this past fall, the School Redistricting Task Force chose not to recommend new district maps to the legislature, and Scott voiced his displeasure. Creating fewer districts with larger student populations in each, he said, would provide property tax relief, more resources for teachers and a sustainable education system built for the future.
“Without this governance change, we won’t give kids the better education Act 73 was designed to provide,” he said. “And from my perspective, the recent failure to produce maps was a political strategy to preserve the old system.”
After conducting its own research and taking testimony from school boards and residents throughout the summer, the task force ultimately said it found little evidence redistricting would produce cost savings.
Meanwhile, Vermonters could see a nearly 12% average property tax hike this year, according to projections from the Vermont Tax Department. Scott said he would again ask for a band-aid by buying down the property tax while lawmakers address the root of the issue.
Beyond the emphasis on education reform, there was not much else legislators could glean from the speech about priorities for the new year. He did not address healthcare, which many school officials argue has played a major role in growing school budgets, or funding for upgrading the state’s aging school buildings.
Scott did, however, set an ultimatum: if lawmakers do not make the meaningful changes to the education system that his administration would like to see, he will not sign other key pieces of legislation they pass.
“Instead of this slow, torturous and unmanaged process, let’s move forward with Act 73 so we can manage change thoughtfully, strategically and with students’ best interests at the forefront,” he said.
In a joint statement following Scott’s 35-minute address, Republican minority leaders for the House and Senate said the speech set “a clear and courageous path forward.”
“This is not about politics; it’s about the future of Vermont,” Sen. Scott Beck and Rep. Pattie McCoy stated .
While Senate President Pro Tempore Phil Baruth (D/P-Burlington) said he would have preferred a private communication without the threat, he said Scott’s speech was the most focused he’d heard in his 15 years in the Senate.
“This is the most narrowly focused State of the State I’ve ever seen, in that it wasn’t just one topic, education, it was one bill beginning to end,” he told reporters at the statehouse Wednesday.
The hyper-focus on Act 73 and staying the course is something Baruth said he agrees with. As education costs continue to balloon, he said the state not only needs short-term cost containment in place, but the long-term change to the foundation formula and the other elements called for in Act 73.
Buying down the tax increase year after year is money that could be spent solving other issues in Vermont, he said.
“The money we use comes directly from the general fund, so it is literally coming out of what we should be spending on hospitals, mental health, the homeless people who are losing their healthcare because of federal cuts etcetera,” Baruth said. “We can’t because we’re trying to shield people from those leaps and bounds of growth in the education space.”
While the legislature builds out education reform, Baruth is pitching a bill intended for short-term relief.
In the bill he said he planned to introduce Thursday, school districts would be forced to limit budget increases in fiscal years 2028 and 2029. Districts are too far along in this year’s budget process for the legislature to intervene.
But Scott needs to take his talk on the road and out of the legislature to drum up support around the state, Baruth said.
“Last year, the governor was not campaigning for these ideas outside the building, and I’d like to see more of that,” he said. “I would love to see Phil Scott outside the building making the same case he made today in the Northeast Kingdom, in Bennington, all around the state.”
Still, in the statehouse Scott said lawmakers can’t bow to the pressure, water down change or stop the transition. A static system will never be perfect and education reform will never be done, but Scott said there is an obligation to constantly be working toward better.
“All we have to do is keep our word and push forward into the headwinds that true progress has always encountered, to strengthen Vermont for future generations and change the fate of this brave little state for the better,” he said.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here