ST. ALBANS CITY — St. Albans City Council approved its public nuisance property ordinance this past Monday, Dec. 9, equipping the city with additional legal tools to go after absentee landlords.
“I see this as a way to help landlords get the wrong tenants out of their buildings and help their neighbors,” Ward 4 councilor Trudy Cioffi said.
The new ordinance – introduced in November – would create an additional legal category for rundown properties impacting a neighborhood’s quality of life, which would prompt city-led oversight on the property.
Depending on the landlord’s response, the city could fine the landlord $800 per day for non-compliance, or declare the property uninhabitable, depending on the situation.
The St. Albans City Council has been taking a closer look at absentee landlords and delinquent properties after getting hammered with increased concerns around crime this summer.
The warmer months had brought with them an increased trend of highly-publicized criminality concentrated around retail theft, car robberies and drug use, and in response, city officials spent much of the summer addressing those concerns.
The newest landlord ordinance is the latest evolution in the hope to cut down on next year’s issues, but this time, the city is taking a look at landlords who may be adding to the problem. As City Manager Dominic Cloud explained, under current statute, the city has had difficulty effecting change with a limited number of landlords not doing their due diligence when renting to tenants, leading to a pattern of negligence for the city’s already limited housing stock.
“The normal problems that are occurring in the City of St. Albans aren’t coming from single family residents who have owners that are occupying the property. They’re coming from landlords who are not present or who are not responsible,” Council President Tim Hawkins said.
Instead, Hawkins said these landlords are making due by collecting a few thousand dollars from their renters each month without providing much in return, while hurting the rest of the neighborhood. By calling their actions into question, the city would have additional legal means to stop such behaviors by giving the city more enforcement options, bringing them in front of the board to order that repairs be done on a property, or face a fine.
Hawkins provided some of the legal input on the ordinance, as he works closely with property owners, employed as an attorney in his private career since around 2000.
After the city introduced the new landlord ordinance in November, Hawkins said he has had a few conversations with landlords about their concerns with the proposed law, repeating that the intention is for the city to go after landlords who aren’t keeping up properties.
“This is for the person who’s been doing it dozens of times, and there’s nothing we can do about it,” Hawkins emphasized.
The ordinance itself lays out a process for St. Albans City Council to get more involved with a delinquent property if the city identifies it as a trouble spot. For a typical landlord, Cloud explained, the city would reach out to a property owner letting them know there’s some concern that a property is going the way of a public nuisance after three criminal actions are cited at the location within a 90-day window.
A civil violation of the city’s property enforcement rules and regulations could also lead to a property being categorized as a public nuisance.
During this process, the city is hoping the first reach out with a landlord should resolve any major issue. A landlord, for example, may not know there’s been problems at a property, so the first discussion should help prevent anything from spiraling too far, Cloud said.
If the problem continues, however, the city would have additional options to enforce their rules, bringing in the landlord in order to hold a quasi-judicial hearing and giving council final say – outside of appeals – in defining what could be done to ensure a landlord takes the necessary steps to keep up the property.
That could lead to eviction proceedings – if city council deems it’s necessary – to remove someone from a property.
“(The public) wants the place cleaned up, and this is the tool that gives us the ability to do that,” Cioffi said. “What this does is it encourages the landlord to work with us to solve the problem.”
While the introduction of the new ordinance back in November arrived without much public comment, the second hearing held Monday drew a few more concerns, largely around unintended impacts of the local law.
The current legal language sets up a way to identify public nuisance properties using police contacts as the metric, and a few public comments revolved around how domestic violence – or stalking – victims could end up being affected if the law is misused by City Council.
The city, however, has created a carve-out for that scenario for domestic violence victims, although it’s not an expansive definition.
In such particular cases, City Councilors out that any back-and-forth discussions between the city and complainants would be able to identify such privacy issues before it would ever reach the point where there’s any sort of public airing of differences.
“That would never get through this board. That would never get to this level,” Hawkins said.
After roughly an hour of conversation, Hawkins motioned to pass the ordinance, with Cioffi seconding. The ordinance was passed unanimously.
“This isn’t going to be perfect from the get go. This is something that we will learn from and need to tweak as we go along,” St. Albans City Mayor Tim Smith said. “But for us to get something out there to begin with, we need a starting point.”
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here