ENOSBURG FALLS –– Village trustees are weighing the costs of repairing or replacing a hydroelectric power unit. The prices vary drastically.
“The small hydro is down currently at the Kendall unit,” Village Manager John Dasaro said. “We pulled it out to assess it, and we’re trying to make a decision on the next move, whether we go new, or a couple options to repair. Whichever way we repair it is a significant cost difference.”
The Kendall Plant is one of two hydroelectric generating plants the village uses to produce power for its customers in the region.
At the trustees’ Aug. 25 meeting, Dasaro presented trustees with three plans: replace, repair and work with what they’ve got.
Purchasing a new unit would cost $800,000, while restoring the unit to its pre-failure condition would be $100,000. Doing a minimal repair with fixed blades to get the unit back into the facility quickly would cost $20,000.
A minimal repair, however, would put extra stress on the hydro unit and gates and create limitations on when the unit can run, depending more on the Missisquoi River’s flow levels.
“The issue with that is it would then depend on the gates of the flow, and our gates aren’t designed to adjust the flow,” Dasaro said. “Basically, they would just be open or shut depending on water levels and ice and so forth. They’re not designed to navigate the flow of water, and it’s more labor intensive.”
Crews would have to monitor the dam on a nearly 24-hour basis to accommodate for the river’s level and adjust the gates accordingly.
Village electric crews discovered the downed hydro in June and following inspection from Fairbanks Mill, a hydroelectric construction company, assessed the issue as a lower bearing unit that failed. The unit itself is about 45 years-old.
The village has already sunk about $18,000 into the work Fairbanks performed, Dasaro said at the August meeting.
A hydropower bearing is a component which supports rotating or pivoting in a hydro plant. It carries the load of the unit, holds alignment and keeps friction within a workable range so the machine runs smoothly.
The loss of a bearing makes the unit inoperable, Dasaro said, as turbine blades are unable to turn. Basically, the bearing is the piece which adjusts the angles of blades to slow or speed up and adjust water levels.
With the loss of the Kendall unit, Dasaro said the Village is losing about 250-300 KW per day in production. Though with water levels in the past couple of months, Dasaro said it’s closer to 200.
“It does translate to real money, especially during the summer when air conditioning is running,” he said.
Currently, the village is not looking at raising rates because of the Kendall unit issue, Dasaro said.
During the August meeting, chair of the trustees Eli Gabuzda asked how much income the village was losing per day, and director of finance Caroline Marcy, said the municipality has missed out on about about $15,000 per month in the last couple months and calculated the loss to about $125,000 a year on average.
“There are certain times of the year we make a lot more. Right now, it’s the low time of the year, but pretty soon it won’t be,” she said.
At the same meeting, Alan Plouff, the crew lead for the electric department, said he does not recommend the quick fix option, saying he’s not convinced it’s the way to go and that a new unit would be a better setup with a little more efficiency.
“I think it would be a better set up for the situation,” he said. “I mean, we’re constantly working on that thing.”
Regardless, village trustees decided not to make a decision at the meeting and instead have the topic back at the table in a few meetings with more solid numbers and a timeline on how long each fix would take.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here