Judge denies motion to dismiss Franklin County Sheriff Grismore’s case

Posted

NORTH HERO – The motion filed to dismiss Franklin County Sheriff John Grismore’s simple assault case was denied by Grand Isle Judge Samuel Hoar this past Wednesday, Sept. 27.

The motion filed by Attorney Robert Kaplan on Grismore’s behalf argued that Grismore’s actions – seen on a widely distributed video released last summer – didn’t meet the definition of “recklessly” required by the state’s law on simple assault.

Hoar’s ruling denied the motion, and he set a status conference for Oct. 12.

State law requires that a person guilty of simple assault to have caused or attempted to cause bodily injury purposely knowingly or recklessly.

Those convicted could be imprisoned for up to a year, and/or fined up to $1,000.

Grismore has argued publicly multiple times that his actions seen on video were a response to those of Jeremy Burrows, who had been arrested earlier that day following a dispute with deputies.

Grismore had been filing paperwork in the office when Burrows was brought in on a hot day in August. Grismore said he pushed Burrows with his foot to stop Burrows from spitting on a deputy helping him standup.

The video of the incident shows Grismore from behind as he delivered the kick. Moments earlier, Burrows had fallen forward and acted belligerently toward deputies.

If convicted of simple assault, Grismore could legally remain sheriff. Outside of court though, the Vermont Criminal Justice Council and Vermont State House could still technically remove him from office.

Grismore’s use of force case is scheduled to go in front of the Vermont Criminal Justice Council in October, and a ruling against him could de-certify him as a law enforcement officer. The Vermont House of Representatives is also investigating his office as they consider impeachment due to alleged financial improprieties.

Grismore, however, has signaled his intention to argue his cases, both in and out of court.

“Although we’re disappointed with Judge Hoar’s ruling, we expected this as a highly probable outcome. Getting charges dismissed under a Rule 12(d) Motion to Dismiss is an uphill battle for any defendant and even more so when a misdemeanor case, such as this, is made so widely public and has political foundation,” Grismore said in a statement released to media outlets following the ruling.

“We knew the motion to dismiss was a long shot based on how criminal procedures work in Vermont but it was a necessary step in the process. The Court evaluates evidence in the light most favorable to the state, excluding modifying evidence.

“We are ready for the next steps in this process, including a trial by jury, so that we will have an opportunity to share all the facts and circumstances. The public has only been provided with a small portion of the information in this matter and we look forward to providing all the evidence.

“We continue to receive an outpouring of support from the community and are eternally grateful for that confidence. We continue to remain optimistic that justice will prevail, and we will have a favorable outcome.

“We will continue to move this organization forward in a positive and meaningful way that provides the best possible police services to the people that live and work in Franklin County.”

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here