ST. ALBANS CITY — Vermont is a small state with limited resources. But that hasn’t stopped federal authorities from leaning on them.
A year after President Donald Trump was voted into office, Vermont’s state government has worked with the Department of Homeland Security through limited means via specific programs or agreements to limit federal influence.
But how much is too much?
After watching a Swanton resident be apprehended by ICE and Customs & Border Patrol officers, St. Albans City state representative and Franklin County Republican committee chair Joe Luneau is looking for some clarification.
“The request here is one for transparency,” Luneau said in correspondence sent this week to Gov. Phil Scott’s office.
Freshman legislators rarely get their pick of committee assignments, but Luneau has appreciated his time on the House’s Department of Corrections & Institutions Committee, where he’s dived into some of the state’s financing mechanisms around its buildings and prisons.
But he can’t tell you if due process is being followed when someone gets picked up by federal authorities and housed in a state prison. A recently renewed contract with federal authorities doesn’t make the stipulation.
“The Administration should be advised by ICE or any other Federal agency as to why an individual is being held if said individual is being lodged at a facility owned by the State of Vermont,” Luneau wrote.
As he explained in written correspondence sent to the governor’s office, Luneau is a regular shopper at the Swanton Grandview Quickstop, and he witnessed an incident when federal authorities arrested the store owner without giving a reason, asked all customers to leave and closed down the business when no one else was around to keep it open.
Later, he learned from another employee at the Quickstop that the employee had been picked up due to “misidentification,” but Luneau said he still hasn’t seen him back at work.
As a state representative on the corrections committee, he could guess where the man likely had been sent after getting picked up. The typical next steps for most people is to be sent to Northwest Correctional Facility — if a man — or down to Chittenden County — if a woman.
Deportation proceedings then often occur in New Hampshire, where ICE tends to be more welcome by the state government.
“There is reasonable probability that he is either detained or that he has uprooted his life in order to avoid detainment,” Luneau wrote.
Since increasing its deportation efforts over the last year, the Department of Homeland Security has not released any numbers showing how many people have been detained and deported from Vermont.
Will Lambek, however, has watched ICE and Border Patrol operate in Vermont closely over the last year as an advocate with Migrant Justice. The nonprofit has been actively watching and tracking new cases that come down the line, and he said the organization has documented and supported over 100 people in Vermont who have been affected by new deportation efforts.
Due to the nature of the federal approach, Lambek said there’s likely more happening that’s going unseen. The organization offers a 24/7 hotline to take in more information about ongoing proceedings, but if no one speaks up, then an enforcement action — illegal or otherwise — can often go unreported.
Federal agencies haven’t offered much information either.
Part of the lack of info, Lambek said, is due to how federal authorities treat immigration status. Since illegal entry into the U.S. is largely a matter of civic law instead of criminal rule-breaking, federal authorities can hold deportation hearings outside of the courtroom without legal representation.
Thanks to a recent agreement signed by Gov. Scott with U.S. Border Patrol, federal detainees can also be held in Vermont’s correction system without a trial. Scott renewed Vermont’s contract with U.S. Customs and Border Protection in mid-September after bragging up the quality of Vermont’s facilities.
Under the memorandum of understanding with Border Patrol, federal detainees can stay at Vermont’s facilities for $185 per night, with that number increasing every year to $208.22 per night by 2030.
Vermont can also cancel the contract at any time, if four months of lead time is given.
There’s no section in the MOU, however, that requires federal authorities to give any information on why they are holding detainees in Vermont’s facilities.
With that said, some immigrant advocacy groups have supported Vermont’s approach. Lambek, for example, with Migrant Justice, said the group doesn’t support the state detaining people without due process, but they also don’t want people to be shipped out of Vermont without having access to legal, language or healthcare services.
Federal enforcement is also expected to continue, Lambek said, if the past year is any indication. Migrant Justice has received increasing reports of immigration enforcement by Border Patrol officers, as there are limited ICE resources in Vermont.
“It is happening a lot more now than it used to,” Lambek said.
This includes a recent Border Patrol pre-planned raid in Jeffersonville, when a group of officers targeted a Maplefields convenience store at 5:30 in the morning to arrest roughly 20 people. No names or details were released by federal agencies after the fact.
Later that morning, though, NBC5 confirmed that Northwest Correctional Facility had been holding 17 people with questionable immigration status — netting the state $3,145 per night.
“It may or may not be that Due Process is being regularly honored,” Luneau wrote. “But Vermonters cannot have faith in this in the absence of this information.”
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here