How Franklin County's independent grocery stores build community despite challenges

Posted

FRANKLIN COUNTY — Seated at one of the booths by the window at the Franklin General Store, a UPS delivery driver unwraps a sandwich and sips a hot coffee. 

He is one of about 30 customers the deli counter served during the lunch rush on Monday – and owner Patti Corey said that’s typical every day of the week. 

“Our pizzas, our grinders, our lunch specials…there isn’t really anywhere else to go up here,” she said. 

In towns across Franklin County, small, independent grocery stores not only serve as affordable lunchtime destinations, but as stockers of essential ingredients, champions of local producers and hubs for community conversation.  

Almost every town has one – that place you stop for milk, eggs and fishing bait, gas on the way home from work or a bottle of wine before a dinner party. 

But being that convenience in rural Vermont also comes with challenges, and to stay afloat, small business owners have to balance increasing prices with paying fair wages and meeting ever-changing customer needs. 

“It’s like dog paddling,” said Jordan Mantle, operations manager at Steeple Market in Fairfax. “I’m trying to keep my head above water and do all our daily tasks.”

Local stores, local stories 

Many of Franklin County’s independent grocery stores have at least a half-century of history serving generations of residents. Sylvester’s Market in Montgomery has been open since the 1950s. Desorcie’s Market in Highgate opened in 1964. 

“The history of the market is, well, we’re talking decades,” Fairfield Market owner James Gregoire said. 

He remembers the store being there when he was growing up in Fairfield. Hector and Yvonne Brown were the owners for about 40 years before it went under the care of the Menards. Then, it closed. 

For residents of Fairfield, the next closest market would have been five miles away in East Fairfield or 11 miles away in Enosburg or St. Albans. But research shows the presence of a grocery store in a neighborhood typically correlates with higher rates of fruit and vegetable consumption and reduced obesity rates. 

“There was clamor in the community for the store to open back up,” Gregoire recalled, so he and a business partner stepped in to reopen Fairfield Market in 2014. 

“We didn’t get into this to make money,” he said. “We did it because we had the resources and the skill sets…and because the community is important to us.”

The Franklin General Store also has a history that stretches far back. Black and white photographs of the storefront hang above the wood stove inside, and it’s traded hands just a few times over the years.  

Current owners Patti and Kenneth Corey bought the store this past June from Patti’s sister and brother-in-law. The Coreys had been organic dairy farmers, but as farming grew more difficult, they sought a new path to earn an income.

“We both grew up in Franklin, so to have a store right in the village where you grew up is pretty perfect,” Patti said. 

While the Franklin General Store sells plenty of Lake Carmi souvenirs for tourists, it’s really a store for locals, who come in to grab a pizza for family dinner or a storemade pie for dessert. Above the register, flyers are taped up for rec department activities, church bingo and a found cat. 

That’s also the case at Steeple Market in Fairfax and at Georgia Market, where staff have noticed an uptick in local customers thanks to the fast-growing populations of those particular communities. 

People are stopping in on the way to and from school and having conversations at the register or in the aisles with neighbors. 

“Having a small community store like this, you get to know people,” Mantle said. “It’s a lot of the same people every week. They’re stopping in because it’s taco night at home, and they need cheese or sour cream.” 

For Ray Bouffard, owner of Georgia Market, that’s part of what’s special about grocery stores: they bring together many different types of people under one roof. 

“We have people who are very, very hard workers, but they struggle. And we have the other side,” he said. “We have a pretty big cross section.” 

At Fairfield Market, Gregoire feels the same. As Fairfield and Bakersfield’s representative in the Vermont statehouse, he enjoys the opportunity to touch base with hundreds of people every day. 

“It opens up a whole avenue for where people can see me, and where I get to hear people talk not just about policies, but their life. I have all those voices in my ear, and I take them with me,” he said. 

Meeting customer needs

In spite of their long and established histories, Franklin County’s grocery stores have had to adapt in order to stay relevant and profitable. 

When Bouffard bought Georgia Market in 2005, he said it was a “challenged business” that needed his help. A veteran of corporate supermarket chains who grew up in his father’s butcher shop, Bouffard knew what needed to be done in order to change the store’s trajectory. 

In 2011, Georgia Market got a brand-new building in a slightly different location. In 2022, Bouffard doubled the size of the frozen food section and built new offices and bathrooms for staff. This spring, he’s planning to install electric vehicle chargers in the parking lot. 

When Gregoire took over Fairfield Market, he did his research, and found that women do most of the grocery shopping for their households. To that end, he lowered the shelf height and added more lighting to make the store feel more welcoming and safe. 

What’s on the shelves has changed over the years too. Bouffard prides himself on listening to customers' requests – like more gluten and nut-free options – and getting those products on the shelves within days. 

“I want to save you a trip to Hannaford…so I do three things: I listen to my customers, I react and I follow up,” he said. 

Franklin County’s independent grocers are also some of the biggest champions of locally-grown and produced products. 

Steeple Market has one of the best local cheese selections around, as well as Vermont-made beer and wine. Mantle – the operations manager – said it's important to stock those items not only for residents, but for tourists. 

Steeple Market sees plenty of Canadians stop in on their way to Smugglers’ Notch, and so Mantle’s proud to showcase to them what Franklin County farmers and producers have to offer. 

At the Franklin General Store, maple jelly from Deuso Family Maple and barbeque sauce from Sartwell Family Maple down the road are prominently displayed at the end of an aisle. So is local honey, syrup, jam, meat and pickled vegetables. 

“It’s important to support the people who are supporting you,” owner Patti Corey said. 

Financial concerns

Downstairs in her office at Steeple Market, Mantle checks the price of every product that’s stocked on the shelves. 

While food prices generally increase about 2% year over year, they increased about 11% between 2021-2022 and 6% between 2022-2023, according to the U.S. Department of Agriculture. Inflation contributed to the increase, but so did other factors, like disruptions to the global food supply chain. 

“We really do try to be fair in our margins,” Mantle said. “People don’t always understand…they think we’re just picking a high price because we want to, that we’re pulling a fast one…but I’m using a straight equation [to ensure we make a fair profit].”

In the last few years, Mantle has noticed the most change in the cost of eggs and processed foods. To compensate for increases across the board, Steeple Market has started offering steep discounts on new products every week. On Tuesday, for example, a selection of granola bars was Buy 1, Get 1 Free. The market also does “Truck Load Sales” twice a year, which include super sales on things like wine and meat. 

The deli counter at the Franklin General Store serves lunch to around 30 people each day, and folks line up for Steeple Market’s $12.99 prime rib dinner on Thursdays. But Fairfield Market doesn’t see the same kind of traffic. Gregoire said he had to close the deli a few years ago because there weren’t the crowds to support it. 

“That’s probably my biggest sadness, that we couldn’t keep that going,” he said.  

Running a deli — especially one that serves build-your-own sandwiches, hot lunch and dinner specials — can be expensive, and a staff is needed to support it. At Georgia Market, the big sign out front says the store is seeking deli workers for $18 an hour. 

“Will we ever go back to hiring somebody at minimum wage again? Absolutely not,” Bouffard said. “The cost of doing business has gone up, and it’s going to stay up.” 

With the increased price of products, utility bills, employee wages and more, independent grocery stores can struggle to turn a profit and meet each day’s challenges. Sheldon Creek Market closed before the COVID-19 pandemic, and Bakersfield Village Deli closed in 2021. 

“I hate to say it, but I feel like our small businesses are going to start to fizzle out,” Mantle said. “I don't think they're going to be able to pay what's going to need to get paid.” 

Help wanted 

So what would help local grocers succeed? 

Bouffard works to lobby the state government for help as a board member of the Vermont Retail Grocers Association. He thinks legislators need to focus on making it easier, not harder, for small businesses to grow. 

Regulation and permit fees add up, he said. For example, in order to add electric vehicle chargers outside Georgia Market, he’s had to go through Vermont’s Act 250 review process, which costs money. 

“It shouldn't be a money thing,” he said. “It should be, what is good for the local economy? What is good to grow the business? Will it employ more people? Will it be able to help pay people more?” 

Not only would Bouffard like to see those kinds of revisions to Act 250, Vermont’s land use law, but he’d like the state to come up with an affordable, robust health care program he can offer to his employees. Mantle said subsidies for utility bills would be helpful. 

Even Gregoire – a Republican state representative – has had a hard time navigating various government regulations and checklists. 

“Everything isn’t necessarily in a one-stop place,” he said. “The number of times I've been told we were cool by one person and then gotten a letter in the mail saying ‘Hey, you still need to do this piece of paperwork.’”

Though he likes to keep political talk out of his store, Gregoire takes what he learns as a small business owner back to Montpelier. He said he works on behalf of all of his constituents, but  values having this particular perspective in his decision-making. 

Corey purchased the Franklin General Store knowing the challenges she’d face. As a dairy farmer for most of her life, hard work wasn’t anything new. But she has dreams of opening up a more robust bakery in the store and of offering creemees this summer. Making those a reality will depend on how this winter goes. 

“Small business is really what keeps Vermont moving forward,” Bouffard said. 

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here