Georgia teacher found not guilty for sexual abuse

Posted

FRANKLIN COUNTY – After three hours spent deliberating, a jury found former Georgia Elementary and Middle School teacher Matthew Toof not guilty on all charges. 

In 2021, Toof was charged with aggravated repeated sexual assault, as well as lewd and lascivious conduct while working as a math teacher at GEMS. The trial started Wednesday, Sept. 11 and continued to Friday when the case was handed to the jury for deliberation. 

Jurors cleared his name on both counts, returning a not-guilty plea. If charged, Toof could have faced a lifetime in prison.

“His name and the community has really suffered a terrible reputational hit,” Robert Kaplan, Toof’s defense attorney, told reporters after the verdict. “He will have to find a way forward and rebuild a good, effective and fulfilling life.” 

Toof gave his own testimony Friday to deny the charges. 

“That is my answer to all of them. If I were to expand I would say that it’s ludicrous,” he said.

Throughout the case, Kaplan argued there was not enough evidence in the investigation for the jury to accept that Toof committed the crimes, pointing out a lack of evidence showing Toof participated in five years of sexual abuse of the victim. 

State’s deputy attorney Diane Wheeler alleged the sexual abuse happened at school, at the victim’s home and on family vacations. 

Wheeler’s opening and closing statements based the case on Toof’s alleged betrayal of the Georgia community, as he had been placed in a position of trust as a schoolteacher at Georgia Elementary and Middle Schools.

“It was sexual acts with [the victim], that was his end desire. His scheme and his plan,” Wheeler categorized Toof during her statements.

The result was that Toof was prosecuted and charged unfairly, Kaplan said, because of a lack of investigation into what allegedly happened. 

Toof had been under house arrest following strict court orders, including 24/7 monitoring, since his arrest in 2021.

(Editor’s Note: The Messenger does not publish the names of sexual abuse victims, alleged or not.)

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here