GEORGIA — A few dozen constituents joined the Franklin County legislative delegation at the Georgia fire station Monday morning, bright and early for an 8 a.m. breakfast of bagels and coffee.
The event served as space for residents to ask questions of their representatives and make their voices heard by lawmakers. Sen. Bob Norris (R-Sheldon) ran the meeting, in lieu of a chair or vice chair, neither present.
Topics of interest this morning ranged from housing to education, from wastewater issues to a possible loss of federal support, from cybersecurity to veteran affairs and beyond.
Richard Noel of Highgate, a semi-retired farmer, showed up to share how some of these issues are playing out in Highgate. The town has purchased land and set up grants to try to build housing and a wastewater system in its town center, but the hurdles implemented by the same state government that says more housing is needed, might prevent the project from getting done at all, due to cost of state wastewater regulations.
“The requirements are strangling us,” Noel said. “We're going to have to end up with a piece of land we're going to turn into a park before we get done, because we won't be able to do anything to it.”
“We don't have a center of town in Highgate,” he added. “We were a rural town. We had a couple of stores and things of that nature, but we didn't really have a center of town, and that's what we're trying to establish: some real estate for businesses, the elderly housing, the library.”
But without wastewater, which they’ve already got a site for and already have grants for, Highgate is going to have to tap out as a result of the complex hoops the state would have them jump through — and the grant money will expire before they’d be able to get the project done.
“And anyway, it confuses me, saying ‘we want interlay housing,’ when they throw so many jumps up,” Noel said. “It's extremely, extremely hard to accomplish.”
From her position on the housing committee, Rep. Ashley Bartley (R-Fairfax) said she has heard numerous pieces of testimony from stakeholders about addressing appeals for permitting and infrastructure, which birthed wastewater Act 181 last year. She said this helped out more in larger towns and counties, but the legislation enacted thus far still left smaller towns to fend for themselves.
“That being said, there's been a real shift to appeals and infrastructure, which I think is what would be needed in Highgate to help you get there and to help you be able to start building,” Bartley said. “It's on the forefront of our minds, and we are working towards that right now.”
Sen. Randy Brock (R-Swanton) sits on the economic development, housing and general affairs committees, and said the Senate is working on a tax increment financing project to support developments.
TIFs borrow money to do particular things, like build infrastructure for housing, by borrowing or bonding for a sum of money that is slowly paid back in the future, on the basis of the increased property taxes that will come from the development once it is built. After the loan is paid back, those taxes fund education, serving as a long-term investment in the community.
“Sometimes to get things done in Vermont, anybody who does this work knows, you sometimes have to blast through the wall that often is in front of you,” Brock said. “And that's one of the things that we do in the legislature. In addition to passing laws that nobody understands, we occasionally help people blast through walls. And so let's talk at the end of the meeting.”
Rep. Lynn Dickinson (R-St. Albans Town), who sits on the House appropriations committee, mentioned a Vermont Bond Bank Infrastructure Sustainability Fund, which aims specifically to help build infrastructure and make funds for that available to towns so that they can build infrastructure needed, like in the case of the wastewater situation in Highgate.
In a similar vein, Denise Smith, executive director of the Vermont Council on Rural Development, chimed in with the next question. Hers is a small nonprofit organization that’s done community visits in over 90 communities, including six or eight already in Franklin County, during which they facilitate a process for communities to identify their needs for projects moving forward.
One of the things her organization sees is a lower capacity to be able to do anything as a result of having only a part-time administrator or clerk — it tends to fall on volunteers to write grants and process permitting and do other back-end development work. She mentioned Montgomery’s selectboard chair Charlie Hancock as another person who’s been fighting to put municipal wastewater and sidewalks up, via fully volunteer hours.
“So I'm here to really request the governor put in his budget $3 million for the Municipal Technical Assistance Program,” she said. “It's a really important program for the state. It basically provides grants or people [with expertise] to communities to be able to do some of this extra labor that they cannot pay for, and so I just want to advocate for that.”
“The other one that we work on, and we've been doing for about 12 years now, is the Working Lands Coalition, and the Working Lands Enterprise Grant,” she added. “And that is investment that goes to foresters and farmers to help support them to be able to pivot and change business models. And the coalition is asking for $3 million in that budget line item this year.”
The delegation also spoke to related issues with the American Rescue Plan Act funds, and a real need for shovel-ready legislative remedies to this issue of bandwidth amongst small rural communities for infrastructure grant acquisition and use capability.
Mother of three Tasha Dickinson brought her topic of interest to the conversation next, asking the delegation how they’d help support the banning of cell phones in schools. Dickinson runs a company that does cybersecurity for small businesses and has witnessed firsthand that there is little to no education on technology beyond basic use, yet high-tech modern-day phones and laptops are being used in schools by the youth with practically no oversight or cybersecurity education.
Her concerns range from cyberbullying to financial transactions and scams, to contact with strangers of any age from all over the world and more, sans education or protection. She was told this year they haven’t committed to any bills on the wall for this topic this session, but that the subject is prevalent.
Rep. Casey Toof (R-St. Albans Town), who sits on the House education committee, said he recognizes the anxiety about addictive behaviors, social anxiety, suicidal thoughts and beyond which result from unrestricted cell phone access in teens.
“I've spoken with the principal at Fairfield School, and they have a school-wide band there, and it's been pretty successful,” he said. “Behavior problems are down. Kids are spending more time outside or with their friends, and their social interactions are so much better… So I believe it's a really important topic to discuss, mental health issues, and this is one way of addressing it.”
He said the only reason they aren’t likely to push forward a bill on it this session is due to the ongoing work and focus on restructuring and reforming the statewide education funding system.
However, while schools may not feel it yet, a bill that may pass the legislature this year referred to as “Kids Code,” is focused on providers’ role in the addictive behavior among children with cell phones. If passed, it will place restrictions on providers’ ability to produce programs designed to addict kids into electronics-addicted behaviors, as well as address privacy issues.
Tiffany Sharp of Fairfax went next, inquiring about Act 173, on rescinding the ban on striking in higher educational institutions, to which she was told at least one committee is taking it up and is hearing testimony. It may go through independently or as part of an omnibus Senate labor bill.
Georgia resident Martha Lance, associate director of wellness and wellbeing at the Patrick Leahy Honors College at the University of Vermont, spoke out next — also to encourage her delegation to take up and vote in favor of the aforementioned bill.
“Seventy-seven percent of union staff members are low- or moderate-income, twenty percent are going to food shelves,” she said. “We are unable to hire staff because of low wages. We’ve been without a contract since July and the administration’s negotiating tactics have been rough.”
Lance said she and her colleagues are concerned about student health and that she’s seen two deaths by suicide amongst them in the last three years, despite their tireless work to protect and support students.
“I have worked two to three jobs ever since I got to UVM,” she said. “I've been here for 30 years. So we just want to protect our workforce. We want to retain good people, and we need to have tools in the toolkit to make sure we're heard by the administration.”
“And I'm a fairly conservative person,” she added. “But I've seen these people struggle. I've struggled myself.”
Kim Lakin of St. Albans Town then spoke up, pivoting to her concerns about President Donald Trump’s administration and its desire to eliminate the federal Department of Education under the claim that the money is going to come back to the state.
“Are you at all worried that the President might wish to punish our brave little state, for some of the values that we have?” she asked. “What are we going to do to ensure that whatever dollars we do get are available for those students who are most vulnerable?”
Three legislators responded at length, expressing immense concern about it, and the fact that a third of the state’s entire budget comes from federal money, but said they are doing everything they can as they restructure Vermont’s education system. Gov. Phil Scott has a team watching every single federal Executive Order to respond nimbly.
“We don't know what the ramifications are yet,” Rep. Dickinson said.”We’ve got to be careful, because we don't know… A lot of our Medicaid money comes in through block grants that do affect our most vulnerable, so that is something we have to watch and make sure that we can just keep an eye on that, because we do rely on the federal government more than most states.”
The legislature also has a mechanism called the emergency board, including the four chairs of the finance committees, who have the authority to redo the budget with the governor when not in session in the case of an emergency, so in the most dire case, reexamining it is an option.
Jan Johnson of St. Albans City spoke next, to ask her representative, Toof, as well as his colleagues, about why he would support H.249, an income tax deduction bill that takes money away from taxpayers for homeschooling, especially given their concern about the budgets.
Toof said he appreciates the bill, which was initiated per a request from a different constituent.
“Vermont has a really long tradition of supporting all children,” he said. “We are required by law to educate all of our students, and we're responsible for educating those students. We have a diverse school system.”
Toof said Vermont has seen almost triple the number of homeschooled children in the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic, and he feels the state has a duty to ensure opportunities are granted to every Vermonter’s education, regardless of how their family chooses to administer it, considering many rural communities like in the Northeast Kingdom don’t have high schools nearby.
“My point is, I'm opposed to my taxpayer money supporting private education,” Johnson said in response — a statement to which many constituents’ heads around the room began to nod.
But Toof reiterated Vermont basically can't discriminate against religious or private schools, although it can set parameters. The bill in question does limit actual money going to private education, and those public tax dollars for private education dollars typically only go to the four historic academies, which each educate over half of their area’s student population, he said.
“Those are necessary high schools,” Toof said. “They just don't have a high school in that area that could serve that many students… Very similar — we have Bellows Free Academy up until I believe 2006, we were a private-public school.”
“I hear the concerns that public dollars should go to public education,” he added. “In the state of Vermont, there are just certain places where that can't happen. People have the right to homeschool their kids. If you wanted to build a new school it’d probably cost us $150-$200 million.”
Topics to arise in the latter half of the meeting included childcare affordability or lack thereof, even for full-time working parents, and a request to appropriate tax dollars to the cause; concern about the phase-out of emergency housing starting in April, with no immediate replacement for the hotel and motel system; the impact of that last move on veterans, and what else can be done for vets including tax breaks on social security; the Clean Heat Standard; the growing concern around rapidly rising healthcare costs and its widespread impacts; and input from a recently-terminated federal employee who was the primary provider for her family with income and health insurance. The feds were historically one of Vermont’s largest employers.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here