Franklin residents reject proposal for school closure

Posted

FRANKLIN – In a special meeting Tuesday night, voters from the Town of Franklin overwhelmingly defeated a pair of articles that would have closed the Franklin Central School (FCS) and sold its assets to the town in a bid to preclude an Act 46 school merger.

Voters defeated the first article, which would have sold the school’s assets to the town for an undisclosed price, 160-29.

One vote was left blank.

The second article, which would have converted the Franklin Town School District into a “non-operating school district” and effectively closed Franklin’s elementary school, was defeated by an even wider 175-15 margin.

The articles had been billed by some residents as a form of “insurance” as the town contested the likely consolidation of Missisquoi Valley Union (MVU) High School’s member districts. Following an example set by North Bennington, those residents hoped to convince the school to close its doors and have an independent school opened in its place.

That independent school, they argued, would allow Franklin to avoid that consolidation and remain independent of school districts in Highgate and Swanton.

Franklin was recommended to merger with school districts in Swanton, Highgate and MVU as a part of a statewide merger plan drafted by then Secretary of Education Heather Bouchey. That plan was submitted to the State Board of Education, which is currently in the process of deciding whether or not to follow through with Bouchey’s recommended mergers.

During a meeting with members of the Franklin and Highgate selectboards and school boards, current Secretary of Education Dan French suggested that the state education board would likely approve Bouchey’s proposed consolidation of MVU’s member districts.

Ahead of Tuesday’s votes, both the Franklin school board and Peter Magnant, the chair of the Franklin selectboard, spoke against the articles, citing a general lack of information related to the impacts of both articles and the fact that there were no guarantees of an independent school opening in FCS’s place.

Neither the school board or the selectboard had had a chance to analyze the possible tax impact of maintaining the school’s assets ahead of Tuesday’s vote, something members of both boards were critical of.

The school board’s chair, Bob Berger, also argued that, since these articles likely wouldn’t prevent a merger of Franklin’s district with Highgate and Swanton, it meant Franklin would still have to pay a share of maintaining those schools while being solely responsible for its vacant school building.

The school board also feared that, if the town assumed the school’s assets, it would negatively impact a class action lawsuit against Act 46 that Franklin had signed on to, as that lawsuit argues reassigning local school assets to a unified school board shared among several towns was unconstitutional according to both the state and federal constitutions’ Takings Clauses.

“We as a board feel that there’s a lot of risk involved, and that’s why we’re unanimously opposed to Article 1,” Berger said.

The school board’s opposition drew some criticism from some members of the crowd who previously accused Berger of presenting a “worst case scenario” for a school closure.

Berger countered by noting that both he and the board have been longtime opponents of a possible forced consolidation under Act 46, having signed statements against a recommended merger and joining a lawsuit that could stall the Act 46 process.

Berger also disagreed with theories that a school board unified under Act 46 would unequally represent Franklin and would ultimately lead to the school’s closure.

Critics in Franklin opposed to Act 46 have hypothesized that a unified school board split between Franklin, Highgate and Swanton would see representation based solely on those town’s populations, as federal law requires some form of proportional representation.

That theoretical board would see one representative from Franklin, two from Highgate and four from Swanton, a ratio that they declared overwhelmingly favored Swanton in a unified district.

The unified school board doesn’t necessarily have to be divided according to those ratios, however, a fact that Berger noted during last night’s meeting.

School board representation may be divided evenly among the three towns, so long as the residents within all three towns were allowed to vote on every member of the hypothetical board. The school board currently governing MVU is composed according to those rules.

“I will point out that MVU has maintained equal representation on the MVU board and the voters of Swanton and Highgate have not challenged that,” Berger said last night.

School board member Jon Gates would also refer back to that fact ahead of voting.

Berger added that the State Board of Education’s articles of agreement, which would govern all mergers forced under Act 46, would use a model similar to MVU’s to govern its merged districts.

“Trust me, I’m here to fight to the end on Act 46, but if we fight that fight and lose and end up in a forced merger, I’m not a hundred percent convinced that we won’t have equal representation when the Agency of [Education] is pushing for it and we have precedent,” Berger said.

An attempt to amend the article so that, rather than approving the sale, the article would simply authorize the school board to sell FCS to the town was quickly shot down by voters who noted that the board already agreed it wouldn’t endorse the sale.

According to the Franklin school board, Article 2, if passed, would have faced an “uphill legal battle” against the state, leading to a second lawsuit the board wasn’t sure it could win, as the state would be unlikely to recognize a ‘yes’ vote.

“School attorneys advised us that this would be an uphill battle… to prove that [the state is] abusing that power by not recognizing the vote we took tonight,” Berger admitted.

Pointing to language in Act 46 itself, the Agency of Education has maintained that the state board must base any merger decisions on the school’s current structure, rather than a proposed future structure.

The Franklin school board, which unanimously opposed both articles, expressed reservations over the “high level of uncertainty for the teachers and staff” that would follow FCS’s closure.

Berger also said a closure would make it look as though “Franklin is turning our backs” on Swanton and Highgate, even though “they have stood by us throughout our fight against a forced merger.”

The ensuing conversation became heated, as Berger and former MVU school board chair Jay Denault sparred over whether or not the closure of Franklin’s school was necessary in light of a class action lawsuit challenging Act 46.

Franklin’s school board previously signed onto that lawsuit stating it was the “best course of action” to challenge Act 46’s processes. Their hope, expressed during that meeting, was that an injunction against Act 46 would stall forced mergers long enough for a coalition of state legislators to overturn or amend Act 46.

Candidates for both the State House of Representatives and the State Senate had previously expressed to Franklin – as well as Highgate and Swanton – that they’d support either overturning or amending Act 46 in a way that could allow schools like Franklin to avoid a merger.

Denault attended that Franklin school board meeting and agreed with the decision.

Tuesday night, however, he asked repeatedly whether or not the Franklin school board had met with lawyers representing it in that lawsuit. In a heated exchange heavily mediated by meeting moderator Tim Magnant, Berger confirmed that the board had not.

“There are still towns that are voting whether or not to sign on,” Berger answered, explaining that the lawyers were waiting until they knew exactly which towns would be signees on the class action lawsuit.

A meeting among the plaintiffs in that class action lawsuit was planned for later this month, Berger said.

The last comments delivered ahead of a vote came from Kindergarten teacher Ashely Bachelder, who asked that the town vote down the article closing FCS. She spoke as a teacher, a parent of FCS students and a longtime resident.

“It is a dream for me to teach here in this community,” Bachelder said. “I feel so blessed to work with the staff that works here – they want to make a difference and they want to be here at Franklin Central School.

“If we choose to close this school, we eliminate that opportunity for the teachers and the kids in this town,” she continued. “As a parent… I have never imagined sending my children to any school other than this one, and I don’t want to imagine that.

“We’re guaranteeing that every parent of a student in this school has to make that decision.”

With that, a call for paper ballots was approved and the town voted down Article 2, guaranteeing that Franklin would continue as an operating school district and FCS would remain open for the foreseeable future.

“The school will remain as it is,” Tim Magnant summarized with the crack of a gavel.

Another article, approving the sale of the school’s athletic fields to the town, was approved in a floor vote. Voters amended that article to include FCS’s community gardens and community walking path, which was an amendment requested by the school board.

The logic behind that third article was unrelated to Act 46.

Instead, Berger said, it was promoted simply to streamline use of the athletic field, which is now largely coordinated by the Franklin Recreation Department.

The school board and selectboard weren’t sure whether or not a consolidation under Act 46 would affect that vote, should the sale not occur until after a forced merger was approved by the State Board of Education.

Residents left as they entered that night, staying behind in the school’s gymnasium simply to talk and, in some cases, hug each other goodbye.

Stay informed on what’s happening in Franklin County, subscribe here.

Similar Stories: 

Franklin split on eve of school vote

Franklin joins Act 46 lawsuit

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here