FRANKLIN COUNTY TOWN MEETING DAY BLOG: Passing of the mayoral torch in St. Albans City

Posted

5 p.m St. Albans City — As the sun began to set on St. Albans City Hall Tuesday evening, incoming mayor Trudy Cioffi and outgoing mayor Tim Smith talked to city voters as they came and went. 

At around the same time, the number of voters had reached close to 500, or just over 10% of total registered voters in the city. For a regular Town Meeting Day, that’s pretty typical for St. Albans City during a noncontroversial election. 

Last year when people were worried about the school tax rates, the city received 680 votes. 

City Clerk Nicole Robtoy said this year’s lower turnout isn’t a big surprise. All three open seats up for election were filled by candidates with uncontested races, and outside of the budget, the big question for the city was a $1.6 million project supported by state loans.

As for the candidates, they had shown up in the morning. 

“They were out there this morning when the sun was shining, which was nice, and they came back this afternoon. But that wind is cold now,” Robtoy said. 

To stay warm as the sun went down outside, Cioffi had gotten a coffee, which she held while wearing mittens. Tim’s wife, Denise Smith, had offered to buy her one, she said. 

“I heard Denise say that there’s a lot of things that (Tim) needs to do around the house,” Robtoy said jokingly. “And she can finally start coming to council meetings.”

As for Tim, he said he expects he will have some more time now. Cioffi will still be getting a few pointers and tips from him regarding St. Albans City when applicable, but now that his duties as mayor are largely over, he can focus on new projects away from public view, he said.

He might even need to work with Cioffi – in her new role as city mayor – to push them forward.

“Trudy’s ready. I’m ready. I think it’ll be good. I know it will be good,” he said.

-Josh Ellerbrock

4:30 p.m. Fairfax - It’s another slow Town Meeting Day in Fairfax, town clerk Lynn Parah said. 

As of 4:30 p.m., the tabulator was counting 850 votes for the day out of the registered 3,924 voters in town – that’s without counting the 180 absentee ballots the town office has already received. 

Even the informational town meeting on Saturday was uneventful, Parah said. 

“Our town meeting was about an hour and fifteen minutes and the school was about 45 minutes,” she said. 

As for the voters who did show up Tuesday evening, they were coming in for a variety of different topics revolving around Fairfax, from stronger governmental leadership to school support. 

“I was a selectman for two years,” voter David Shea said. “Towns are complex. Today they require thoughtful leadership.” 

This past year for Fairfax has shown divisions between the townspeople and the selectboard, and Shea said cooler heads need to prevail to continue to make the town better for all who reside in it. 

“We need to come together over our own selfish ideas,” he said. 

As for voter Kathy Bessette, she said her number one reason to go vote is for the schools. 

The school board and administration work hard to reign in the budget, she said, and because of their efforts she said she wants to show them her support.

“I always go vote whenever I can,” she said. “Supporting the school is especially important.” 

Both voters, however, believe voices are being missed. 

For Bessette, she wishes more people would come out to vote on Town Meeting Day and express their opinion. There are many vocal opinions in town and she said without voting, they end up moot. 

“You’ve got no right to complain, unless you come out and vote,” she said. 

As for Shea, he said the switch many municipalities including Fairfax took to use the Australian ballot just isn’t the same as the traditional Vermont meeting format. 

“Town meeting isn’t what it once was,” he said.

 - Aidan Schonbrun

2:30 p.m. Swanton - For Beth Jette, voting on Town Meeting Day is part of her civic duty.

“I vote every Town Meeting Day,” she said at around noon on Tuesday, after exiting the polls. “I try to be supportive of the town and village.”

By around noon, Swanton Village Clerk Dianne Day had tracked about 170 voters, or just over 10% of the total village voter base had come out. She expects roughly 20% to show up by the time polls close, spurred to vote by questions about taxes.

As the biggest topics of the election, Day said folks have been chatting about Missisquoi Valley School District’s proposed budget, as well as the town’s local option tax. 

Jette said she voted “yes” for both requests. As a former teacher, she supports the schools, and after paying for St. Albans local options tax without too much concern for years, she said she doesn’t expect the additional sales tax to be overly detrimental for Swanton businesses.

Jette then motioned to the two Swanton Town Selectboard candidates sitting at the end of the sidewalk.

“And I support these young people, too,” she said. “Because I taught them.”

Out of the four Swanton Town selectboard candidates on the ballot, Ronald Underwood and Nicole Draper had staked out spots among the candidate signs by lunchtime. They said Josh Aldrich had come by earlier, but they hadn’t seen Steve Bourgeois.

“It’s a great pleasure to thank everybody for coming out and doing their civic duty,” Draper said, while interspersing “thank yous” to those who walked by. “Voting is a right that some people don’t have, and I’m glad to see people exercising their right to vote.”

“At least, it’s a semi-warm day,” Underwood said. “I’m meeting a lot of people, answering a lot of questions.”

As voters have moved through, he said they’ve been most interested in the local options tax, as well as the school budget. 

“We have opinions,” Underwood said about the school budget. But then again, as a selectboard candidate, “We don’t have much say over that.”

-Josh Ellerbrock

12:30 p.m. Georgia - The Town of Georgia had a longer floor vote than usual at town meeting this year after three articles faced significant dialogue and changed to a paper ballot instead of a vocal majority.

At peak, the room sat 124 registered voters engaging with the selectboard and each other. The town had eight questions to vote on from the floor this year all touching on topics of financials in town.

Article 2, asking voters to pay taxes on Oct. 15, as they usually do, raised dialogue with voters asking why the town doesn’t make residents pay their share quarterly as other towns do. The conversation also began to mix in with Article 5, which asked voters to change the finances of the town from a calendar to fiscal year system.

Article 5 was eventually repositioned for discussion immediately following Article 2’s approval.

“What we want to do is move us to a fiscal year [with] 2028 being the first fiscal year. Let's talk why,” selectboard chair Kristina Senna said to the crowd.

First off, it would align the town with the school and state for operations. Grant funding, which also operates on a fiscal year basis, would be together so contracts would finally be in line with the town, and finally, the calendar year schedule means the town operates for a two and a half month time-period using money not approved by voters.

Anticipating there would be some concern in the timing, Senna said the town would move slowly. After being approved this year there would be no change. At town meeting in 2027, voters would approve an 18-month transitional budget and by 2028 the budget would be set for the fiscal year.

After the selectboard said their piece, resident Ken Mink began to question the clarity in the wording of the article. While in the explanation the selectboard shared a timeline, nowhere in the ballot is that clear, Mink said.

“It’s totally lacking information other than what we were just told, which is just hearsay,” Mink said. “I think the article should be rejected because of that.”

Right after, the first paper ballot of the afternoon was called from the public.

Of the 100 people who voted on the article, 85 agreed to change to a fiscal year while 15 said no.

Next up, Article 3 asked voters about a capital expenditure reserve for the highway and fire departments. Again, the selectboard ran into issues with verbiage.

“Basically, it’s just the surplus from the fire department line and the highway line is going to go over to their respective reserve funds,” resident Fred Grimm said. “It’s kind of poorly written, doesn’t say that very well.”

The selectboard’s original intention was to put the money left over at the end of a fiscal year into reserves for those bigger expenses, however, wording on the ballot had the town creating a new reserve budget line item.

Again, town residents and the board went back and forth on amending the ballot before approving the article to say funding existing reserve accounts for the two departments.

Next up, Article 4 asked voters to approve putting $50,000 annually into a contingency reserve fund for unanticipated expenses. This time, voters had concerns around the guidelines the selectboard could or could not use the money with.

“It’s understandable people are concerned about what the selectboard would have available to them,” former selectboard member Kyle Grenier said. “It’s original intent was this, like when the town has to replace the roof, because the roof failed, we have to go to the bank and borrow money, so we have to pay interest on money that we weren’t expecting to spend.”

Georgia has a several million dollar budget, there’s no reason the town should have to borrow money for a $100,000 repair, Grenier said.

For the second time of the afternoon, a lone voice called for a paper vote and lines immediately formed.

This time with 91 people casting their vote, 66 said yes to the appropriations and 25 said no.

A more contentious ballot, Article 6 asked voters to authorize an additional $50,000 to be added to the law enforcement budget line item. The sum of money buys around eight additional hours of coverage.

“This article is asking for an additional $50,000 because we continually hear concerns from residents regarding public safety and need for additional law enforcement,” Senna said. “But, due to the overall budget increase, the selectboard chose to put this as an additional article for the residents to vote on.”

Questions pretty quickly came flying at the board asking about the steep price tag and whether the board looked for options outside the Franklin County Sheriff’s Office, which the town is currently contracted with.

“When I had to personally call the police, I never once had a sheriff come up,” one resident said. “I’ve always had to wait for the state police and then we’re talking sometimes over an hour before they get here, so to spend this kind of money, or extra money, on the sheriffs that don’t even show up [sic.]”

Another voter asked why the town should fund the sheriff’s office, and asked the board to again investigate other options.

“I know it’s limited … but I think it’s worth considering given the current situation with the Franklin County Sheriff’s Office,” one resident said. “And I say this as the wife of a police officer who served for 15 years. This is by no means being anti-law enforcement, I’m enthusiastically pro, I’m just curious about who we’re getting on patrol."

Senna said when the board reached out to St. Albans City P.D., they said they couldn’t negotiate as they are already overwhelmed, and that previous experience with VSP and Milton P.D. did not do enough for Georgia.

When moderator Rep. Carolyn Branagan (R- Georgia) called for a voice vote and heard an approval, it was questioned, and for the third and final time of the afternoon residents turned in a paper slip.

This time, out of the 86 people who voted, there were 39 yes votes and 47 no votes, so Article 6 was defeated.

On a lighter note, a new voter in Georgia at his first town meeting seconded a motion, receiving a round of applause welcoming him into the old Vermont tradition.

Following town meeting the school was up, but no questions were asked of the Georgia school board or administration.

– Aidan Schonbrun

9:08 a.m. St. Albans Town — Happy Town Meeting Day! Voters across the state are turning out today to weigh-in on local school and town budgets, candidate races and community projects. 

In St. Albans Town, it's a quiet morning at the poll. Outside Collins Perley Sports Complex, selectboard candidate Cathy Montagne greeted a trickle of voters. She's running uncontested for a three-year term. Jack Brigham is also on the ballot for re-election. 

A friend of Jennifer Williamson was also outside, holding a homemade sign calling for voters to write-in Williamson for the Maple Run Unified School District board. No one is on the ballot for the St. Albans Town seat being vacated by Amanda Giroux. Williamson, owner of Avalon Natural Medicine, previously ran for the board in 2021, but lost the race. 

Inside, Town Manager Casey Toof is helping to check in registered voters. The town's ballot is short and relatively non-controversial, he said, which probably explains the low turnout so far.

It's Toof's first Town Meeting Day at St. Albans Town Manager, and he laughed, thankful to be inside instead of out in the cold where he's been in the past as a candidate. 

Girl Scout Troop #30456 is at the complex selling cookies to raise money for their annual trip and community service projects. Aislynn Armstrong and Liliah Olsen, both senior scouts, said they've used cookie proceeds in the past to travel to the Boston Aquarium. This spring, they are looking forward to participating in Green Up Day and the local parades. 

—Bridget Higdon

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here