4 p.m. — Record turnout in Swanton? That was the word on the sidewalk as voters and candidates talked outside the Swanton Village Municipal Complex.
Lots of ballot questions plus the presidential primary had people passing through to vote all day.
One of the biggest questions on the Village ballot is whether voters will approve $14.8 million for a new public safety building for the Swanton police and fire departments. For several voters, that price tag is just too high.
“It’s too expensive and not the right time,” resident Melanie Ryan said.
“With the economy the way it is, it’s bad timing,” resident Tim Menard said.
Kristy Paradis turned out to vote because it was the presidential primary. As a Republican, she voted for former President Donald Trump, she said, so the party can put forward a strong candidate for the general election.
Locally, as a resident of Swanton Town, she supported funding for the recreation department. She knows lots of local kids utilize the programming and she herself enjoys the town trails.
For others, the topic of the day was the budget for the Missisquoi Valley School District. Angie Scott has a child in the district, but thinks the $50.7 million ask is too much.
Saundra DuBois, of Swanton Town, wanted to weigh in on the school and police budgets. She always comes out to vote, because that’s a value her generation was raised on, she said.
1 p.m. — After Vermont’s warmest winter, 2024’s Town Meeting Day was noticeably less frosty than years’ past.
The lone St. Albans City candidate Erik Johnson standing outside city hall Tuesday knew he had it easy.
“(State Rep.) Mike McCarthy came by earlier and he told me ‘you got so lucky’. It’s not freezing outside. It’s not raining. But, it might rain later,” he said.
Johnson said he ran into a few people curious about his candidacy. Some had seen his face in the newspaper, or online, and he said he appreciated being able to introduce himself to them on Town Meeting Day. He had already made his rounds with some city staff to get ready for the position.
“It’s more than a seat. It’s a responsibility,” he said.
The incumbent councilor, Bob Farrar, dropped out of the race in February, noting potential conflicts of interest with his position as Franklin County Probate Judge. That makes Johnson the likely winner, as the only other name on the ballot.
The other city races for mayor and Ward 6 councilor are uncontested.
City Clerk Nicole Robtoy said Mayor Tim Smith did drop in earlier in the day, voted, grabbed a donut and left.
As for Ward 6, Chad Boudreau had posted a campaign sign at the front of city hall to propose his name as a write-in candidate. With no one running for the seat, it’s a small hill to climb.
Voters, however, had different concerns. About 425 had voted at St. Albans City Hall prior to 1 p.m. with 140 absentee ballots waiting to be counted. For the city, the early turnout was on the higher end, especially compared to last year’s, Robtoy said.
With not many people interested in Tax Increment Financing, it’s expected that the proposed education budget and Vermont's lack of affordability was driving people to the polls.
“I voted ‘no way’,” Dawn Laroe said as she left city hall. “It’s too high. We can’t do it anymore, and we’re headed out of the state in a few years because of the taxes. They keep going up and up.”
Christina Fornaciari was more optimistic about Vermont’s future.
“I’m trying to remain active during a time of apathy,” she said. “I’m here less on the issues, but I want to stay engaged. It’s a challenging time.”
— Josh Ellerbrock
11 a.m. — The Town of Highgate had its last Town Meeting Day from the floor.
After close to two hours of back-and-forth discussion, the final tally was 79 “yeahs” against 69 “nays” to use the Australian ballot during Town Meeting Day.
Those against the change spoke about upsetting tradition and losing a unique Vermont political phenomenon, and those advocating for it argued to open up the vote to gain more representation and add flexibility to an important political process.
Much of the conversation, though, revolved around the topic of transparency. Without Town Meeting Day, how are people going to know what the town is doing before they vote?
“I struggle with it every day,” Highgate Town Administrator Sharon Bousquet said. “We try to get information out to people.”
For those working in town government, it’s not exactly a secret, but public engagement at the local level is slowly disappearing as older generations age out, and there’s no warm bodies to replace them.
At Highgate’s last informational meeting, attendance was low. Meanwhile, selectboard meetings rarely have people in the crowd. Across the state, more and more holes are opening up in public office on the local level, and more and more administrative needs are being farmed out to professional services.
But when it’s brought up as a problem – as it was done this morning in Highgate – the public encourages them to keep looking for a population that isn’t available.
Highgate also voted to replace its two lister positions with a professional service out of Waitsfield this morning after the two people filling the roles retired.
“What happens if this gets voted down?” a member of the crowd asked.
“That’s a good question,” Town Clerk Wendi Dusablon said. “Somebody here better be ready to take the job.”
“We’d be up…poop creek,” Town Treasurer Shelley Laroche added.
The results of the lister vote – and the rest of Highgate's final votes – are expected by the end of the day.
— Josh Ellerbrock
11:20 a.m. — More than 130 residents packed into the gymnasium of Georgia Elementary & Middle School for the town’s first floor vote since before the COVID-19 pandemic.
Before the meeting, residents voted on some articles by Australian ballot and viewed displays set up by the Georgia Historical Society, library, conservation commission and fire department. At 10 a.m. sharp, moderator Carolyn Branagan took to the podium and gaveled the meeting to order as she’s done for many years.
“This is your meeting,” she said, sharing that the town meeting tradition started long before Vermont was a state.
Six articles were voted on from the floor, but the meeting stretched to three hours due to folks making amendments from the floor. A motion from Gary Wright to move from annual to quarterly payments for property taxes failed, but a motion from Ken Mink to use about $120,000 in unassigned funds to offset taxes, passed.
“I’m here participating in local politics because I can’t change anything on the national level,” resident Ben Richards said. “I’m not sure how I’m going to vote on the budget. I’m looking forward to the discussion.”
Many voters had concerns about how the 2024 budget was laid out in the 2023 Annual Report, but treasurer April Edwards said the organizational changes were recommended by Georgia’s recent financial audit.
Seated on stage, the selectboard directed many questions to Edwards, who could barely sit down before being called again to the microphone. One voter criticized the board for doing so, saying the elected officials should know the answers to financial questions.
Voters also asked questions about the recreation department, ARPA and grant funding, and Georgia’s move from AmCare to Fairfax Rescue.
Though all school-related questions were voted on by Australian ballot, Franklin West Supervisory Union Superintendent John Tague was seated in the audience. He said the local school boards did good work creating budgets that are right for the schools and fiscally responsible for the community.
“Now it’s up to the taxpayers,” he said.
Reps. Ashley Bartley (R-Fairfax/Georgia), Chris Mattos (R-Milton/Georgia) and Chris Taylor (R-Milton Georgia) were also present for the start of the meeting. All three said they were open to questions from constituents.
“I love Town Meeting Day,” Bartley said. “This is democracy at its finest.”
—Bridget Higdon
11 a.m. — Two candidates vying for for the Fairfax Selectboard stood outside the polls at BFA-Fairfax as voters trickled in.
Dwayne Leach and Tim Burns stood next to each other and shared what they thought they could bring to the Selectboard if they were elected.
"I've been in town a long time and I want to make it grow in the right ways," Leach said.
Burns shared the issues he wanted to address.
"I feel passionately that the town needs a change. I have a few issues to address -- affordability, sustainability, recruitment and retention," Burns said.
Fairfax resident Patricia Ledoux was concerned about increased property taxes due to education spending as a homeowner living on a fixed income."Well, our taxes are out of reach and every vote counts so that's why I'm here," she said.
Paul Lavallee said he was also stressed about the increased taxes with the cost of living.
"I can see it every year, the same thing, just going up. No changes just increases, its the way we live," he said.
Fairfax resident Grace Cothalis had a different approach and said if the town needed something, they needed something.
"If you put it off it's just going to cost more. I think the interesting thing at town meeting was the reserve fund, because we are always running at a deficit so it seemed like a hypothetical thing," she said.
9:30 a.m. — People were rushing in and out to vote and perhaps buy some girl scout cookies on the way out of Collins Perley Sports Center, the polling place for St. Albans Town.
The Messenger caught up with Sean Adkins, the town manager, who shared his thoughts on the town budget.
"The biggest increase was the law enforcement budget but the rest of the budget only went up ten thousand dollars," he said, "We were pretty creative about what we could do without blowing through it."
He felt there was support for the budget, pointing to rising crime rates in Burlington, and how the town wanted to stay ahead of the curve.
Town resident Billie Jean felt similarly about the budget.
"I think its hard times but I believe in the schools and the local town and government to do their jobs to keep the city and town in good shape."
The budget increase was justified with the cost of living going up, she said.
"People try to do the best for our kids and our schools and it's expensive."
Another town resident, Bill Lotz, felt similarly to Jean.
"As a taxpayer I'm like 'Oh my god' but it's got to be done."
Lotz moved to St. Albans three years ago from Maine and was the chair of the finance committee in a tiny town there. He said he was aware that costs go up.
"I'm surviving on social security, but we got to educate our kids," he said, adding that he was happy to live in a community with nice people.
Robert Hathaway was motivated to come to the polls to try to keep Donald Trump from becoming president. He said he wanted to empower the Town's Selectboard and did not look too closely at the numbers.
"I assume they're doing the best they can and that they're sharp people. On the particular items I don't pick them apart too much. I'm sure there's been debates in the back room," he said.
—Jean MacBride
9:20 a.m. — As we await photos from today's polls, take a look back at Town Meeting Day 50 years ago in Franklin County. We love these photos from the Messenger archives of floor votes and ballot-casting from 1974.
7 a.m. — Good morning. Polls are open across the state for Town Meeting Day voting.
Need to catch up on what's on the ballot? Read the Messenger's coverage here.
While ballots will be dominated by local issues, including selectboard representatives and school budgets, today is also the Presidential Primary in Vermont and "Super Tuesday" across the nation. Vermont voters can request a ballot in any party's primary.
Return to this page all day for updates and photos from our reporters as we fan out across the county to bring you the news of the day. We'll also be LIVE tonight at 8 p.m. on Northwest Access TV with results.
—Bridget Higdon
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here