Franklin County Sheriff candidates weigh-in; Voters get say Aug. 11

Posted

FRANKLIN COUNTY — When yard signs start appearing, then you know an election is just around the corner.

And for this upcoming August 11 primary election, the biggest local race being decided is the choice of Franklin County’s next sheriff.

The current sheriff, John Grismore, announced his intention to step down from the position back in April, and there are three Republican candidates seeking the position on the August ballot. They are Capt. Chad Miles, Sgt. James Lynch and Andre LaBier.

To get more information out about their candidacies, the three men participated in two debates in the last few weeks, which were each captured on camera by Northwest Access TV.  For the first event, the community-oriented anchorman/interviewer Richard Cowperthwait talked to the three candidates on July 21 for his show, “For the Record.” The second event — a candidate forum — occurred roughly a week later this past Monday night at Richford Town Hall, where regular citizens got to submit the questions asked to the candidates.

For those voters still undecided, here’s a quick review on what happened.

(For a more complete picture on the sheriff’s race, links to both public debate videos and the Messenger’s coverage of the three candidates can be found in the online version of this story.)

Sheriffs and auditors

While many voters have likely heard about what initially happened with Sheriff John Grismore — thanks to a widely-publicized online video that depicts him striking a man with his foot — there’s been so many twists and turns in the story that it can be understand what’s happened in recent years.

The latest news too just came out in June, when Vermont State Auditor Doug Hoffer released his latest report of Vermont’s sheriffs that pointed to incongruencies in the Franklin County Sheriff’s Office accounts. Grismore, in response, released a long social media post on Facebook to provide his side of the story not long after. 

So who’s correct? How bad is it at the sheriff’s office under Grismore? Or are operations running better than the state would like to admit?

Each candidate has a slightly different take.  

Out of the three, LaBier had the strongest critique as a proponent of “proactive but not aggressive” policing. He contends that deputies need to be coached and trained to better utilize community policing techniques. Then by proving their worth, the office would have a better time finding contracts, he said, as it took a reputational hit under Grismore’s leadership.

Both Lynch and Miles, in comparison, were more hesitant to put black marks on the office. Both men defended the office’s bookkeepers when the question came up. 

Miles also currently functions as the lead law enforcement officer under Grismore, as the state of Vermont revoked Grismore’s law enforcement credentials in the aftermath of the state’s examination of his “use-of-force” case.

In other words, things like patrols and the day-to-day supervision of other deputies has been completed under Miles’ leadership, as Grismore has functioned largely as an administrator following the Vermont Criminal Justice Council's withdrawal of his credentials..

After getting a few questions on Monday related to the office’s financial accounting practices, Lynch addressed the controversy directly:“None of us are running against John Grismore. “We are three candidates who have great thoughts and ideas.”

Lynch too challenged some of the findings of the auditor’s report, giving an example of the state’s requirements on how the office should handle mail, further labeling the process as “obstructively bureaucratic.”

Both Lynch and Miles, however, did say that they expected they would work closely with the auditor’s office to ensure that any accounting discrepancies could be found and fixed.

LaBier’s response took it one step further. Out of three candidates, his past experience lies with signing off on budgets that were several orders of magnitude larger than the sheriff’s office due to his background as a chief inspector with the U.S. Marshals. To prepare for his federal job, he said he took financial classes to ensure he understood some of the finer accounting details related to dealing with taxpayer funds.

Rural contracts and public safety 

As inflation impacts law enforcement’s cost, many of the questions asked by residents on Monday concerned the sheriff’s office’s role in covering the rural parts of Franklin County. Because in Vermont, residents largely get what they pay for. If a town doesn’t contract with a law enforcement agency, the default coverage is provided by the Vermont State Police. 

Many town residents these days, however, are looking for a little more, especially in regards to quality of life issues, such as traffic safety and speeding. So would the new sheriff be able to get it done?

Both Miles and Lynch brought up the potential behind additional regionalization of policing services. If one town can’t carry the cost, then they might be able to access a few more patrol hours by pooling their funds, in theory. 

But then there are natural obstacles to the work. As Miles explained, when sheriff’s deputies are on patrol, they use their vehicles as their workhubs, which don’t have the same supplies and support systems in place as they do back at their home office. 

Then would they be willing to move their office away from St. Albans to provide better service to other rural places?

Miles said the option isn’t off the table, although they would have to find the right spot before making the decision. 

“We’d have different capabilities with a different office,” Miles said.

In comparison, Lynch was against the idea, as one of the main required duties of the sheriff’s office is to provide support to the Franklin County Superior Court. Both court security and prisoner transfers are direct responsibilities of the sheriff’s office, and moving the office would make them less efficient. 

Instead, to get more contracts, Lynch said, the sheriff has “to hustle” to form strong partnerships with towns, as they don’t have a municipal government that would cover major budget changes. Regional agreements, however, could be a way to do “more with less.”

“Everything that we do it has to pay for itself,” he said. “... Anything that the sheriff does outside of what’s constitutionally-mandated is hustle.”

Even so, all three candidates agreed that there was no way to completely answer everyone’s needs. Many of the underlying issues that residents see can’t be solved with just an arrest, as there needs to be a web of support systems that can actually limit or stop bad behaviors. 

Miles said things like property crimes, speeding and ATV misuse are problems “pretty much everywhere” across the county, and “you’re never going to stop all of it.” The sheriff’s office is working to address many of those issues in the towns where they patrol, even though people don’t always notice it, he said.

Similarly, Lynch labeled the long-term issues as ongoing societal problems, like generational poverty, economic distress and addiction, including both drug use and other problematic behaviors like gambling. And LaBier put his focus on repeat offenders, including people who steal to cover their drug costs, and ongoing quality of life problems. 

As for LaBier’s opinion on new contracts, he said the first focus would be ensuring department policies are strong and that deputies were performing up to people’s expectations. Then contracts would be easier to secure.

Final questions

The last few questions asked by Richford residents injected a little fun into the debate, while revealing more about each candidate.

What’s your favorite creemee flavor? 

Lynch answered immediately: “Maple.” For LaBier, it’s vanilla. And Miles prefers maple chocolate swirl with chocolate sprinkles.

What’s the last book you read?

LaBier couldn't remember the title, but he summarized it as a book about a marine battalion in the Korean War. Lynch said it was “Demon Copperhead,” a 2022 book by Barbara Kingsolver that gives insights about the opioid crisis. Miles, who has a young child, said he didn’t have much time to read.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here