Fingers-crossed; Will an alum treatment clear up Lake Carmi?

Posted

FRANKLIN — The road to a “lake-in-crisis” began long ago, when Geo Mann came to Franklin Pond.

Or at least, he likely helped.

“(Mann’s Mills) are situated on the outlet of Franklin Pond, about one mile from East Franklin, and consist of a saw and shingle mill and axe factory,” one Saint Albans Messenger correspondent wrote in 1870, after taking a tour of the facilities.

“Mr. Geo H. Mann, the proprietor, manufactures axes, butcher’s knives and other edge tools and hoes. These are all of excellent material, well-made and durable. … We would suggest that he exhibit specimens of his skill at the next county fair.”

Roughly 150 years of environmental impacts later, a small barge dropped hundreds of thousands of gallons of a chemical mixture into Lake Carmi to stop a goopy soup of cyanobacteria from making it stink.

Will it work?

Franklin residents are keeping fingers-crossed.

Summers of blue-green algae

Last October, a small aluminum barge equipped with six plastic chemical tanks was watched excitedly by a small crowd on Lake Carmi’s northern shore. For many of them, it was a source of hope.

“Pete and I were talking the other day, we love the beginning of the year — the May, June, July time frame,” Rob Evans explained.

Evans has been coming to Lake Carmi for the last 17 summers, and he and Pete Benevento volunteer with the Lake Carmi Camper’s Association. Evans is currently the organization’s vice president, and Benevento is the president.

“There’s this great energy when the campers start to open their camps. And the fishermen are out there. They’re fishing and tubing. And then the water starts to turn green,” he said.

“You can’t use the lake. You can’t wade into the water. … The smell, the thickness of blue green algae out there, it’s like scum across the entire lake. It smells so bad.”

The chemical-laden boat that made its rounds back in October is supposed to change all that. 

Back in 2024, the Town of Franklin hired Barr Engineering to find a solution to Lake Carmi’s annual algae problem, and in 2025, the State of Vermont gave the engineering firm’s plan its blessing by providing $2.7 million in order to effectively stop the cyanobacteria blooms.

Most Vermonters are familiar with the blue-green algae menace. Hot temperatures cause officials to shut down beaches across Northern Vermont to keep residents from wading in the stuff, and Lake Champlain’s interaction with the St. Albans Bay inlet often creates similar messes for residents up-and-down Maquam Shore Road.

But could alum treatments be a solution for the state’s cyanobacteria problems?

Residents are hoping to get two decades of stink-free summers from Vermont’s only “lake in crisis” thanks to the treatment, but nobody knows what the result will be.

Underwater coverage

While tucking into some goulash at the Franklin General Store, Franklin resident Jen Raynak is pretty confident the treatment isn’t going to hurt the lake. The science looks good.

“My parents were both chemists. I was a chemist for a little while. I understand the chemistry of it,” she said. “It makes inert things, not dangerous things.”

Engineers, too, have proof the new concept could be applied successfully to Lake Carmi. The 2024 feasibility study laid out how an effective treatment across roughly half the lake could hold the problem back for decades.

And there have been stories of past successes. Grand Lake in Ohio, Lake Morley in Fairlee, Vt., and Lake Kanaksatka in New Hampshire have all applied the treatment with strong results.

“Everything we have here says it’s going to work fine,” Raynak said. “I don’t remember anybody thinking it was a terrible idea. There are the people who felt burned by the aerators, who were less hopeful, but they didn’t think it shouldn’t be done.”

She gave credit to the engineers and technicians who had to explain and sell the process, as many in Franklin have a solid understanding of the treatment, despite the reasons behind blue-green algae proliferation being quite complicated.

Essentially, cyanobacteria will erupt in large “blooms” when underwater nutrient-rich environments settle and are spurred by hot temperatures, kicking off mass expansions of plant life that die weeks later only to come back again when the sun returns. The consequence of these cycles of life and death is usually the stink.

In comparison, alum is a chemical compound that’s specially created to clump together with phosphorus and other materials in the lake to settle at its bottom. Over time, that material should form something like a “blanket” that covers the nutrient-rich anaerobic environment on the lakefloor, essentially cutting off the blue-green algae’s food supply over a period of decades.

As for Raynak’s relationship with the lake, she’s lived in Franklin since 2021. She also grew up there and was a regular visitor to Lake Carmi prior to moving back, as her family owns a camp along the shoreline.

She said she’s gotten used to the blooms. They’ve been coming every year since she was a child. And even in August at their worst, residents can wait them out. By the time cold weather arrives in September and October, the lake is much clearer.

Raynak though is curious about what the alum treatment can do for the community. If the lake is naturally more attractive, then, in theory, more people will seek it out as a recreational asset. And more people means more energy, and potentially, more money.

“I don’t necessarily imagine it will lift my boat here at the (Dick Wright) pub, but it’s important to the town, which lifts everybody,” she said.

Raynak opened the pub last year, taking up the old car dealership on Franklin’s Main Street drag to create a community space. She’s plenty busy at the Dick Wright Pub, instituting different classes and programs for local residents, but the business often functions like a nonprofit.

As for more general community impacts, Raynak said she could see property values rising in Franklin as a result of the alum treatment. And that could lead to better tax revenue lines for the town over time, and maybe more tourists seeking out the northern town in the summer months.

Just down the road, Franklin already lost its creemee stand on the northern shore, likely due to the stink. Now they have the momentum to do differently.

“That requires the population being around,” Raynak said. “And it not being absolutely disgusting.”

Local control

Haston Library director Josh Worman said he’s heard his patrons talk about the alum treatment, as they’ve come into the library chatting about it. Most people have been pretty positive.

“I think it is seen as a type of opportunity, if it works out,” he said. “I mean, everybody’s hoping that it will kind of revive things a little around here.”

Historically, Franklin’s economy has leaned on its agricultural output, but that’s not the case anymore. Worman said there are a few businesses, like the Franklin General Store and some agribusiness operators still thriving, but most people are retired, or they work for themselves. The town also took a big hit when Dick Wright Ford, the local car dealership, ended up closing back in 2018.

These days, it’s likely Lake Carmi that has become the town’s biggest attraction, with Lake Carmi State Park standing out as a major draw, thanks to 482-acres being set aside along two miles of coastline on the lake’s southeast shores.

Worman said he’s a regular park visitor, as are a lot of local Franklin residents. For those without a lakefront property, it’s one of the easiest ways to access Lake Carmi’s waters.

But then, the cyanobacteria can still chase away visitors.

Worman said he does have some environmental concerns about the alum treatment. Boating and fishing is probably the biggest recreational activity people pursue on the lake these days, he said, as swimming is more likely avoided, so there are some questions of how wildlife might react to what’s happening underwater. And there could be worst-case scenarios that they didn’t even know about.

In 1870, for example, the community was praising Geo Mann for his handiwork with an axe. By 1874, Franklin Center consisted of three churches, an academy, three stores and one hotel connected to civilization via a railroad line. Salmon and pike fry were being dumped by the hundreds of thousands into Franklin Pond.

Decades later, Vermont finished clearcutting its mountains and wheat farmers were setting up on the banks of its rivers and lakes. One Messenger correspondent in the late 19th century even bragged about the production levels available if people would farm the shorelines of Franklin Pond, or the islands of Lake Champlain.

Now, Lake Carmi — given its new moniker in 1910 by state representatives — is deemed a “lake-in-crisis” thanks to decades of unregulated fertilizer getting washed into the lake, to collect at its bottom. 

Much has changed in the meantime. Thanks to required agricultural practices, farmers are no longer allowed to farm on a slope with higher than a 10% grade, and wetland delineations keep most development as far away from waterways as possible.

“One of the ironies of ironies — maybe the central irony — is that we don’t own (the lake). It’s state property,” Worman said. “So it’s kind of like, we, as a community, have so much invested in it. We have some say over what happens to it, I guess, but not the ultimate decision.”

Moving forward

Town of Franklin selectboard member Brooks Sturtevant said he likes to bike around Lake Carmi, and like most people living in Franklin, he’s experienced the smell while enjoying the summer.

He’s also spent many hours trying to tamp it back. He was on the board when the Town of Franklin decided to move forward with a plan to use $1 million to install aerators to help with the legacy phosphorus, all that fertilizer still there, at the bottom of Lake Carmi.

And like many Franklin residents, he too has his fingers crossed the alum treatment will work.

“The perspective of the town is a prevailing sense of guarded optimism,” he said. “… Personally, I was relieved. I know that a lot of work has gone into it, and the board is happy for the possibilities."

In fact, it’s likely due to all that prior work that this new effort happened in the first place. Sturtevant said the alum treatment got broad support from across many organizations that came together without pointing fingers to find a solution to the lake.

“The main thing is we really appreciate everything everyone has done. It’s been a collaborative effort,” he said.

And now, the only thing left to do is wait.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here