FAIRFAX – According to a petition received by the Town Clerk’s office, 220 Fairfax residents are looking to remove the town manager position from the Town of Fairfax.
The petition calls for Town Manager Sarah Hadd to step down and for her position to be removed, after signatories say she mishandled recent town-owned vehicle thefts.
The petition has enough signatures to call for a special vote, so the selectboard met Aug. 5 to discuss next steps. The two members of the five-person selectboard, Randy DeVine and Tim Germaine, signed the petition, along with the newly-appointed town constable Josh Langelier.
Back in January, a town truck was discovered missing from the town garage during an equipment inventory check. As required by the town’s Fraud Prevention Policy, Hadd requested the Franklin County Sheriff's Office investigate and a report was made to auditors.
During a July 15 selectboard meeting, Germaine said he only chose to sign the petition because he was deeply insulted and hurt after being called by an officer over the missing vehicle.
“I did not sign that petition until the second cop called me and left me a message,” Germaine said. “When I played that message, I called him and let him [selectboard chair Bryce McNall] have it and went looking for that petition because I am no thief.”
Germaine was supervisor of the public works department for five years before retiring in January 2023. He was elected to the selectboard in March of this year and signed the petition before gaining his elected seat.
Germaine said he contemplated removing his signature, but ultimately decided to let voters choose what happens next and keep his name on.
Tempers flared up again when two trucks from the town garage went missing again during the night of June 25, this time because of a robbery. Authorities said two trucks were stolen shortly before another theft occurred.
During the robbery, a pickup and a loader truck were stolen from the town garage and used to travel to Union Bank on Ramsey Road. The robbers attempted to steal an ATM from the bank.
Hadd said she took next steps in accordance with the selectboard’s policies and ordinances.
Vermont State Police said they showed up around 3 a.m. after an alarm was triggered. They found the outdoor ATM removed and heavily damaged down the street on Route 128, while the vehicles were recovered undamaged.
At this past Monday’s meeting, the selectboard discussed possible dates for the special vote to occur. There were concerns about the logistics of the vote especially in relation to the general election in November and March elections.
Chair Bryce McNall asked Town Clerk Lynn Parah the costs for having a special ballot made for either date. Parah said for the general election, the town would need to pay between $10,000 and $15,000 dollars in mailing, programming and the ballots themselves.
Because the State of Vermont mails general election ballots to all registered voters, Parah said the selectboard might want to pay to mail the special ballot too, so as not to cause confusion. That would cost $4,000.
“The communication and misconception could be out there that, ‘Geez, they mailed the general election ballot, but they didn't mail this special vote ballot,’ and so therefore they get the perception, ‘I didn't know I had to request for that ballot or do that,’” Parah said.
If the selectboard continues down that path, a special town meeting would need to be called between Sept. 26 and Oct. 6 per state law.
Whereas, if the selectboard choses to hold the vote during Town Meeting Day in March, costs would be significantly lower. There is also the option of holding the vote on its own, however, Parah said it would come at significant cost to the town.
Resident Jim Webb spoke up to say he’s heard from residents on his side of the town who feel like the selectboard gave up all its power when it created the town manager position in 2017.
The town manager position was added to the town's government body after previous selectboards said they could not keep up with all the work while the town continued to grow. There have been only two managers; Brad Docheff in 2018, and Hadd beginning 2021.
No-one he knows, Webb said, remembers voting for the manager position. He said he talked to 60 people since the last selectboard meeting and no one remembered voting on the position.
Only 732 of 3,650 registered Fairfax voters took to the ballot back then.
This prompted the selectboard, town manager, clerk and moderator to say they were being transparent through the whole process.
To anyone who signed the petition, Parah said it shouldn’t come as a surprise when the special election is held. The town posts meeting dates through multiple different sources.
Town Moderator Roberta (Robby) Rodimer said if there were any concerns, through this process or in general, then the public needs to be engaged and show up to town meetings.
“Instead of listening to what goes on here and what they talked about, they're listening to the town grapevine, and the town grapevine is almost always wrong,” Rodimer said.
The selectboard made no decision Monday night on when to hold a special town meeting or vote on this matter.
Hadd said another possible solution is for the town to create a modernized charter.
It is impressive, she said, that the town continues to use the charter from 1763, but a new charter could provide more clear rules and guidelines for each position in the town’s governing body.
As Fairfax grew, listers, then assessors, a clerk, treasurer and eventually an appointed town manager took positions in the town office without a charter to default to. Instead of getting rid of the manager position, Hadd said duties could be defined.
“That might be something to look at in terms of a charter committee, something to look into as an avenue to help clarify and provide information and also have citizen participation about how people want to be governed,” Hadd said.
Town managers provide a lot of the day-to-day work that an elected selectboard does not have time to do. They are the chief administrative officer in the town and a lot of information from government operations goes through them to the selectboard.
Managers also communicate with the town, coordinate multiple departments and spearhead the town’s budget with adjustments to the selectboard's approval.
Jeff Bartley, town resident and Fairfax Planning Commissioner said he is opposed to the petition and the removal of Hadd’s position.
Since Hadd's appointment as manager, Bartley said the town hasn’t had many problems. Her leadership has led to a strong parks and recreation department and an adequately staffed town office, he said. Her experience as a planner has also been valuable.
“I don’t think the town is divided,” Bartley said. “We’re talking about 200 disgruntled people. It’s a couple of families, so I don’t think the town is divided, things are going well.”
When it comes to the selectboard members on the petition, Bartley guessed their reasoning is either a power grab or not wanting to have a boss. If that’s how they feel, they should resign, Bartley said.
Randy DeVine, superintendent for the wastewater treatment center, is contradicting himself, Bartley added. DeVine voted to renew Hadd’s contract three days before he signed the petition.
“Truthfully, I think one member of the selectboard shouldn’t be on it because during the day he reports to the town manager and at night he's her boss,” Bartley said. “At the end of day, I firmly believe Randy DeVine needs to resign from Selectboard.”
Asked to comment, DeVine said: “I don’t have an answer for you [for signing the petition], I am a resident of Fairfax.”
Three people on the petition have asked for their signatures to be removed. One said the oversight from the elected selectboard keeps the town manager position in check.
Fairfax residents are still able to remove their signature from the petition. If it drops below the required threshold of 196 signatures, the petition is returned to the challengers.
Petitioners can get more signatures and return the matter to the selectboard when they hit the required 196 signatures again.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here