FAIRFAX — After weeks of debate and a tense November meeting, the Fairfax selectboard decided by the narrowest of votes to opt into the county’s new land use map.
The 3-2 vote Nov. 17, represents the split board opinion on the Northwest Regional Planning Commission’s land map and Tier 1B designations.
Tier 1B designations create exemptions to Vermont’s pivotal land use law, Act 250, in certain areas, allowing a developer to build up to 50 units on 10 acres. In Fairfax, those areas are centered in the downtown core, around the town office/Main Street strip and by the post office just down the road.
The board had initially handed off the land use map to the planning commission to get its seal of approval, but Selectboard Chair Tim Burns said the commission did not want to come to a decision and threw the decision back to the board.
As the board vetted the plan through three prior meetings, Rep. Ashley Bartley (R-Fairfax) expressed her support for the initiative, which aims to quicken new housing development. Bartley is vice chair of the House Committee on General and Housing.
“I want to speak to the importance of this decision in front of the selectboard,” Bartley said Nov. 3. “I see it as we are up against towns right over the border. I think this gives us an ability to stay very rural, but in a way that we are promoting growth in the places and areas we’ve already designated and the planning commission worked really hard that we know are sustainable.”
The planned growth’s boundaries, and concern over the town’s thin-stretched utilities created a fracture between some on the board and public in attendance Nov. 17.
“Opting into Tier 1B accelerates the development. If you accelerate the development, you accelerate costs,” resident Ron Smelstor said. “Don’t opt into it. We’re going to develop anyway … let it go naturally. We’re going to shoot ourselves in the foot.”
Smelstor went on to say if the board opts in, they are going against the voters from a 2017 community survey who said to maintain moderate housing growth. Selectboard member Lori Fisher, however, said while there is a vocal group at board meetings, members have heard from others online who want to opt in.
Some from the public found the boundaries of the map to be unfair, giving a boost to those in the "preferred" areas instead of the rest of the town.
“If we don’t opt into Tier 1B, Act 250, as bad as it is, is color blind. It’s not discriminatory. It doesn’t pit neighbor against neighbor,” Smelstor said.
Soon after, members of the public and selectboard member Josh Blake said they believed some recusals were needed on the vote.
Blake and member Kurt Magnan said they did have acreage in the boundary, but the public and Blake alleged Fisher was in the boundaries as well.
Fisher said her property was included in the interim Act 250 exceptions but not the map being voted on.
“I’m insulted to have to sit there and defend a conflict of interest suggestion when I clearly vetted that at the very beginning of this whole process,” Fisher said. “You don't think I looked at the map? ... And the first time anyone comes to me is my own board member at a public hearing, when I’m not even here … It becomes accusatory.”
What followed was a quick tit-for-tat between the two members with Fisher asking if Blake signs off on warrants that pay his family members, and Blake saying the two things are completely different.
“I don’t sign that check, I don’t create that pay scale, I don’t do any of that,” he said. “This isn’t like we’re picking over $20, we’re talking about moving real estate that can have a substantial gain. Like you said, the water and sewer comes right to the end of that property right there … You can’t even challenge my integrity as to how smart I am about acreage, I do acreage all my life … I know when I see 10 or 15 or 20 acres of real estate."
Should the town just throw away its conflict of interest policy? Blake asked.
Eventually, Burns put the argument to bed and called for a vote.
In the end, Fisher, Magnan and Burns voted in favor. Blake and Germaine – who went back and forth on it at several meetings before saying the town wasn’t ready – voted against.
At the same meeting, Burns said the town’s Department of Public Works lead, Brent Sheets, turned in his resignation.
Town Manager Mike Bishop said Sheets had a tough go moving from Texas to Vermont and figuring out the Fairfax systems by himself. That said, Bishop said the town will look at the job description and find a replacement.
“I do plan on reviewing the public works structure and putting in a temporary leadership plan, possibly permanent leadership plan, over the next week,” he said. “We will be back to talk over the future director and how it all comes together.”
Sheets had been working on upgrading Fairfax’s wastewater and water utilities.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here