FRANKLIN COUNTY — Chad Miles and Andre LaBier, the two candidates running for Franklin County Sheriff, have some similar ideas to help the office.
Both want to see the sheriff’s office grow. Both emphasized the importance of communication with local towns, and both want to move past previous stumbles in order to reinstate the office’s reputation.
The two candidates, however, have very different backgrounds. And it’s up to voters in November to decide who will be the best fit.
Andre LaBier started introducing himself to town selectboards this summer as “the most experienced candidate” for Franklin County Sheriff, due his extensive law enforcement background spanning 35 years.
Meanwhile, Capt. Chad Miles has been working for the Franklin County Sheriff’s office for close to two decades, coming up the ranks over time to become the office’s principal patrol officer and chief deputy.
Both men see avenues where the Franklin County Sheriff’s Office can be improved after a few years of reputational impacts to the office.
“I think really once we get out from under the Sheriff Grismore cloud, the dark cloud that's there, … I think we can move forward in the right direction,” Miles said.
“If John didn't have that one issue, he'd still be running for sheriff, and I wouldn't consider running for sheriff,” LaBier said.
It’s hard to talk about the sheriff race without bringing up the changes that occurred under Sheriff John Grismore.
Grismore has served for one term, but the impacts to the office’s reputation began before voters elected him.
In the week prior to the primary election in 2022, body-camera footage showing Grismore using force against a man in custody went public. Despite wide-ranging backlash against him, Grismore still won at the ballot that November, gaining more votes over candidate Mark Lauer to secure the sheriff’s role.
Vermont’s state agencies, however, still moved forward with consequences for the Franklin County Sheriff. After the House started a special committee to look into potential financial malpractices of the sheriff’s office, Grismore was stripped of his law enforcement certification by the Vermont Criminal Justice Council, and his salary was effectively reduced with a state law change. Vermont’s central office in charge of sheriffs, too, moved the county’s regular prisoner transport duties down to the Chittenden County Sheriff’s Office, effectively shrinking state revenues the local Franklin County office relied on.
Meanwhile, Grismore fought the criminal charge brought against him by arguing against it in court, pushing two hung juries to declare mistrials in Grand Isle County by the end of the legal process.
Through the twists and turns of his case, Grismore has struggled to push back against public perception since “the kick.” And while both candidates also spoke positively of how he administers the office, LaBier made it a point to highlight his difference in opinion about Grismore’s use-of-force case.
After the video was released, Grismore held a meeting between the deputies to try to clear the air, and LaBier said he was the only person to speak up to tell Grismore that “he was wrong” to do what he did, later pointing to Grismore’s lack of training as the big reason to why he stumbled.
Miles also recalled the same meeting, as the deputies had a few conversations about what they would do at that time.
“We all sat down in the office prior to that meeting, and we kind of talked about what we were going to do, and we came to the conclusion that we wanted to stick it out for the betterment of the office,” Miles said. “We’ve all poured so much effort into getting this office where it was, and we didn’t want to just give it up.”
Grismore, too, tried to make it work, Miles said, but “he’s been limited in his capabilities now for the last three years.”
“It’s really affected that office and our ability to function the way we should,” he added. “I’m being told that once a certified person is in that office that (the state office) will allow those positions to come back.”
In a recent letter-to-the-editor written by Grismore, the sheriff gave his public support to Miles by highlighting his ongoing work with today’s office, contrasting it with LaBier’s extensive experience outside the state in decades prior.
“My experience across the board — it’s really hard to beat,” LaBier said. “Getting that out there, not everybody looks at that. There’s been a lot of critique. People saying ‘I’m arrogant’ because I keep throwing around my background and experience. I’m not going to apologize. It speaks for itself.”
Both Miles’ and LaBier’s approaches to help heal the office largely revolve around the same idea. Both men are looking to raise the reputation of the FCSO by doing the work of law enforcement and opening up communications with towns. Then, they can try to customize each service contract and cobble together enough revenue streams to create a foundation for growth.
Miles said he knows it’s possible because he’s seen it happen before under Sheriff Robert Norris. During his tenure, Miles said deputies were able to slowly expand the office’s reach to create regional coverage as the office proved itself.
To do it again, Miles said deputies will have to start showing up in towns across Franklin County in higher numbers with greater prominence and excelling in current coverage areas in order to show selectboards the investment is worth it. And if selectboards are looking for community-centric policing, Miles said it’s something that can be done.
“I think it’s just getting out there, educating the public. And if we move into these other towns, that’ll be a big thing for me — to be aggressive,” Miles said.
If completed as expected, the office will be able to bring on more staff as more contracts are secured.
“They go hand-in-hand, right? You can’t hire more people without more towns. You can’t do more towns until you hire more people. So it’s kind of a balancing act,” he said.
Miles is also considering moving back to an older standard under Norris’ tenure where all patrol officers needed Level III law enforcement certifications. When Sheriff Roger Langevin came into office, he relaxed those expectations to bring on more staff. From an operational standpoint, Miles said Level II’s can sometimes require additional oversight from a Level III, depending on the case.
Level III’s would also make it easier for patrol officers to operate more independently of the main office. Miles said he’s open to the idea of creating regional outposts for deputies, especially if it’d create some operational efficiencies.
LaBier also agreed with the idea, emphasizing any satellite offices would have to make sense financially before they could move forward.
As for their current headquarters, Miles said he was open to moving the sheriff’s office from its current spot on Lake Street in St. Albans. Staff could use more space and functional cells, although any new office would have to be in a location that’d be close enough for regular interaction with Franklin County Superior Court.
“I think the office is fine because you’re running it as a business. But once you start expanding in the patrol realm of things, I think you need to look at: Do you have the space you need? Right now, we don’t,” Miles said.
In contrast to Miles, LaBier argues for a more process-oriented way of helping the office’s reputation. On multiple occasions, LaBier stressed the importance of training and education for sheriff’s office deputies and encouraged “community policing” that stresses forming local networks with people in each coverage area.
He used a few examples to explain the approach — including a “Safe Surrender” program that he helped launch in Camden, New Jersey. After a few days of arresting people, he said local groups saw their efforts in a positive light as they tamped down on some of the most disruptive criminals in the neighborhood. To make it happen, they spent a lot of time laying the groundwork of support by meeting with community leaders.
LaBier said he approached his work as a patrol officer in Richford in much the same way — by building bridges with people first — to create an informational network he could use when problems came down the line.
“What I did in Richford, I not only went out and greeted and met with people who were cutting their lawns and tending to their gardens and fixing up their houses, but the people who were at the heart of the problem — the addicts, the alcoholics, the homeless, and the mentally ill — they all knew me by name,” LaBier said.
To ensure sheriff deputies are taking the same approach, LaBier stressed hands-on training and regular communication with officers.
“I can build bridges. I’m good at it. And I’m confident about that. And the key components here come to education,” he said.
After LaBier publicly made comments during a Richford Town Hall meeting that second-guessed how some people came to be employed at the sheriff’s office, both Miles and Grismore have contested LaBier on this point. As a result of the comments, Miles said some people at the sheriff’s office are already eyeing the door, out of concern if LaBier wins.
“I'm not criticizing any of (Grismore’s) hiring practices, but there's been people who had to be let go,” LaBier said after broaching the topic. “Somebody who had worked, and subsequently got arrested. You have to do thoroughness on your hiring, and I'm big on that.”
At the same time, LaBier said he recognizes the challenges of staffing sheriff’s offices, as they’re regularly used as stepping stones for people early in their careers, or as places where retirees are looking for a post-retirement career.
“But that's a good thing because you have experienced people and new people who you can mentor,” he said. “I think mentoring is a big thing. Statewide, we could do a whole lot better.”
A recent change for the Franklin County Sheriff’s Office was the change-up in coverage for Fairfax after the selectboard decided to move forward this past July with a contract with the Milton Police Department.
To try to get the contract back, both men recognized that re-forging those partnerships with Franklin County’s towns will be a big part of the job, especially as selectboards look for additional law enforcement to tamp down on trouble areas.
“It’s going to take a lot of negotiating, a lot of work. … But I think it really just boils down to communication. Where can we come to a common ground? How do we get there? Is there a good answer to get there?” Miles said.
As an example, Miles highlighted both Enosburgh and Richford as examples of “lawless” towns where regular policing has fallen by the wayside, and he said there are multiple municipalities that could use additional coverage to tamp down on issues. Figuring out solutions will require some creative approaches.
Speeding and misuse of ATVs, for example, are the problems that candidates said they’ve heard about the most from voters. The trouble is administering fixes, as both men agree that there’s little that can be done to eliminate the issue outside of quelling it with police presence, especially in regards to speeding.
As for ATVs, Miles said they can be more strategic as people aren’t likely driving too far from home, and they might be able to be traced back to a residence where they can deliver a ticket later.
“That’s a monumental headache,” LaBier said. “ATVS are not built for road use. Simple as that. The safety things aren’t there. I constantly see it up where I live. … I constantly see it. I see 10- 11-year-olds, no helmets going down 105.”
While there’s no fast solution to the issue, both candidates introduced the idea of organizing some sort of larger group that could help across the board when it came to ongoing problems.
For Miles, he recommended a county-wide committee with municipal representatives. The additional communication could then help the sheriff’s office quickly adapt to needs or identify potential resources. If the group succeeds, Miles said there could be the potential of negotiating a coverage contract on a county-wide basis — in the same way Grand Isle does.
“That is something that I'd like to look at. It makes it a little bit harder when there isn't a county government,” Miles said.
Instead of municipal leadership, LaBier said he’d like to see local police come together once a month to share info. Additionally, LaBier stressed using some of the national intelligence networks to help guide operations, especially around drug enforcement, as he’s had experience with them in the past.
“Sitting down and talking about what’s going on in your department and in your community is important. And it’s to the benefit of the community,” LaBier said.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here