Candidates asked about violence

Posted

ST. ALBANS CITY- Seventeen candidates from across Franklin and Grand Isle counties gathered in the Saint Albans City Hall Thursday morning to discuss the issues of domestic and sexual violence facing the region.

The candidates, invited by the Franklin Grand Isle Domestic and Sexual Violence Task Force, were given a few minutes to introduce themselves before asked to answer one single question: What do you believe are the root causes of domestic and sexual violence and, if elected, how would you use your position to uproot those causes?

The moderator, Kris Lukens, executive director of Voices Against Violence, gave each candidate three minutes to deliver their answer.

Franklin-1

Republican incumbent Carl Rosenquist was the sole candidate present in the race to represent Georgia. His response focused on the idea that violence stems from a lack of self worth. Instilling this value into the younger generation is one way to tackle the issue, he said.

He also emphasized that those being abused need to make sure they remove themselves from those situations. “If they are in an abusive situation they have to get out as quickly as possible. The only way to stop that cycle is to get out, and not be available to be abused,” Rosenquist said.

Franklin-2

Rep. Barbara Murphy, an idependent representing Fairfax, speaking close to the end of the forum, mentioned that there wasn’t a whole lot more to say. But the overall arching cause she says violence stems from is respect.

“If people are able to gather a greater respect for oneself, they do have that ability to see that others have that same right to have respect held to them,” Murphy said.

Murphy also cited some of the work she’s done in her past year in the legislature, including two gun bills (H422 and S221) she helped pass, which allow law enforcement to remove firm arms and dangerous weapons in cases of domestic assault.

Republican challenger Mary Beerworth responded with a more personal impact of violence, discussing her sister, who grew up a victim of sexual assault that Beerworth says resulted in pregnancy. Because of this, she says, the best way to tackle the issue is to start in the high schools.

“I’m most concerned about helping our teenagers become less involved in inappropriate and too early sexual relationships, which I believe sets a pattern for abuse,” Beerworth said. “I watched that happen with my sister.”

Franklin-3-1

Republican Jim Fitzgerald, who is seeking to represent St. Albans City and a portion of St. Albans Town, pointed the finger towards media and, more specifically, pornography.

“We tolerate porn on our Internet, we tolerate horrible movies on our T.V. and the news is depression; no wonder we have these types of problems in our society,” Fitzgerald said. “I think we should ban porn. Who needs it? Why should we tolerate this? We also must help the victims learn the signs of oncoming abuse, and we need to have people work with these folks daily.”

Democratic candidate Mike McCarthy made it clear that one of the main issues behind violence is a lack of stability in many of the victims’ lives. He advocated for affordable housing as one of the essential ways to solve this issue.

“I believe it’s our job as leaders in our community to make sure there are safe places for survivors to go and bring their young children in difficult situations.” McCarthy said. “The victims or survivors that we are talking about today have a right to be safe in their homes, in our society, and we need to create a culture of safety.”

KateLarose, also running as a Democrat, cited society blaming victims as one of the core causes of abuse. She says the community should be offering support to these people instead of pointing the finger.

“We are not here to blame them; we are to provide the services and resources when they want to access them,” Larose said.

She also mentioned educating kids about consent at a younger age. She says she started this process with her son as early as a toddler, and that it’s important for kids to know they don’t need to hug or kiss people just because they are family. Finally, she mentioned that addressing the issues going on in leadership should be another priority in stopping this crisis.

“How about we don’t tolerate sexual assaulters in our leadership. How about we don’t tolerate sexual assault in our Supreme Court, Statehouse or presidency,” Larose said. “We need to be better than that.”

Franklin-3-2

Rep. Eileen Dickinson, R-St. Albans Town, cited power as one of the root causes of violence, and recommended improving economic stability to combat it.

“One of the things that makes it hard for the victim, in most times, they need economic independence. They also need emotional independence, and I think it’s easier to find that if you can get economic independence,” Dickinson said.

Franklin-4

Tammie Consejo, who is running as an independent write-in candidate to represent Sheldon and Swanton, listed off several root causes including anger mismanagement and a belief that partners and children are property. Her main message was that the issue needed to be solved on the community level and not by the government.

“I believe the government can’t fix everything. It’s easy to say they have to fix it, but we have to fix it. They are us,” Consejo said.

Democrat Nicholas Brosseau also cited power as a main cause. He mentioned the idea of bringing social services into schools, to help give students a better chance to report domestic violence as a way to fight the crisis.

Republican incumbent Brian Savage listed a number of determinants, with financial stress being a key issue. Savage also agreed with Fitzgerald that the media was a leading cause.

“I don’t think there’s one evening a week that’s free of any sort of sexual violence or violence in general in some of the programing and movies we see,” Savage said.

Though he sees violence as an issue needing to be addressed, he seemed to think the solution also didn’t come from the government.

“We cannot be all things to all people, that’s very important. We’ve got a lot of things going on, and sometimes people have to take their own personal responsibility as well, as far as looking for solutions to this problem,” Savage said.

Franklin -5

Democrat Charen Fegard was the only candidate in the race to represent Berkshire, Franklin, Highgate and Richford who was present.

“I know stress plays a big role on whether or not somebody explodes on their families. I believe a lot of people stay because of a lack of a perception that they have other options. The idea of making sure that there are supplemental housing options for people to flee violent situations is very important,” Fegard said.

She also suggested eliminating the stigma and shame attached to domestic and sexual violence as a top priority.

Franklin-6

Bakersfield, Fletcher and Fairfield candidate Kelly Cummings, a Democrat, cited sexism, poverty, racism, and a lack of self worth as the main motivators behind domestic and sexual abuse. She said that if elected she would work to address these issues from a base level.

“If we build a platform of the basics, we will create much needed stability, an it is stability that creates opportunity, and perhaps with opportunity it will help reduce the rates of violence,” Cummings said.

Franklin-7

Rep. Cindy Weed, D/P -Enosburgh, said a big concern for her was bullying in schools.

“I think we need to look very seriously at social workers in schools to catch some of these bad actions. It’s so hurtful and it affects people’s self esteems,” Weed said.

Weed emphasized the need for early education programs funded by the government, as well as hard accountability for the perpetrators behind violence.

“I’m certainly willing to make it a priority and that usually does mean more money. The first things should be our people, ourselves, our family and our community members, that has to be ahead of anything else,” Weed said.

Speaker of the House Mitzi Johnson represents Grand Isle County. She didn’t say what the root cause was, rather identified a larger question behind the issue as a whole.

“While it doesn’t only happen to women, it mostly happens to women. So what is the root cause where by and large, men think it’s okay to physically abuse women. That’s the really core astounding question that I want to stay focused on,” Johnson said.

Franklin Senate District

Democratic Senate candidate Dustin Tanner gave a personal answer spoke of his own experiences with domestic violence.

“I am a survivor of domestic abuse, my biological father beat my mother in front of me when I was five, so that was how my father left my life,” Tanner said.

He said he couldn’t really identify what the root causes of violence were, but was sure that it stemmed from a culture where men are taught to be powerful and mean to women.

“My answer would be to ask you what we can do in the Statehouse to make your jobs easier,” Tanner said. “I would do everything I could do give these organizations [referring to the task force] have what they need, you can’t really give a monetary value,” Tanner said.

Democratic candidate Pam McCarthy said the focus of the system needs to shift to the victims and the survivors, and what can be done to help them. She also mentioned that society needed to take a hard look at what was being valued as a social norm.

“We need to be educating and informing our young people on what’s appropriate. The socialization of boys as powerful and women as nurturing is something we need to reevaluate,” McCarthy said.

Republican Senator Randy Brock answered differently from the other candidates. Instead of providing an answer and solution, he turned it around, wanting to know what the task force thought was the root cause of violence.

“One of the biggest dangers with questions such as this is you’re asking politicians to pontificate, and talk about things that most of us have no expertise on whatsoever. In a way the shoe ought to be on the other foot,” Brock said. “As politicians our job is to listen, not talk.”

 

 

Candidates talk agriculture, mental health, guns

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here