Building a ‘haunted house’; The Victorians get a new life in St. Albans

Posted

ST. ALBANS CITY — The lady of the house waits for an unsuspecting victim to fall into her web. In the room over, an Italian patriarch attends to his studies in his quest to conquer death, and upstairs, one of the servants is practicing voodoo.

Or rather, they would be, if Alex Nalbach had anything to do with it. 

Since 2022, Nalbach and his partner, Marc Vincent, have been transforming the old Victorian house at 73 Bank Street into a simulacrum of a Victorian haunted house, complete with dozens of creepy portraits, themed rooms and staging that could compete with many Hollywood productions.

For Nalbach, it’s been a lifelong dream.

Memento Mori

With a birthday close to Halloween, Nalbach said he’s always had an interest in the macabre. If he was a Victorian, he would be among contemporaries.

And soon, he’ll have a house to match.

Over the last year, Nalbach and Vincent have poured days of work into completely restoring the house on Bank Street’s interior with new lighting, plumbing and wiring to be able to reproduce Nalbach’s vision for the space.

As he described it, it’s been a long time coming. He’s wanted to own an old Victorian house since he was a boy, but the realities of such a build have made it difficult to make it come to fruition. This past year, however, he said he took his dad’s advice. 

“His mantra became 'Don’t wait,’” Nalbach said. “I think it’s in his spirit.” 

Nalbach must have taken it to heart. Walking into the place, the effect of his efforts are immediate. Artifacts from the time period, as well as curated reproductions extend throughout the building. 

Not everything is directly from the time period, but Nalbach has taken special care to stay true to the Victorians' themes and decorating styles. 

An easy way to describe the look is “busy.” Upper middle class Victorians, especially, would often open up their homes for large events, where they could show off their wealth and status, and they often designed their homes in a “maximalist” style that would feel cluttered in today’s households.

Nalbach, however, wants his arrangements to feel a little unsettling. 

Among the carefully-arranged clutter are subtle nods to the dark and sinister. In the lady’s parlor, for example, stare long enough and guests will start to notice hints of webs, flies and spiders scattered throughout the memorabilia. Nalbach labeled the theme as “welcome to my parlor, said the spider to the fly.”

Even the rug, which seems innocuous on first glance, resembles the interlacing patterns of a spider-web.

He brings similar approaches to the rest of the house’s rooms, adding little callbacks and even mythological references – a very 19th century thing to do – to match each room’s theme. 

He’s also kept the walls dark, and he plans on adding portraits from the period throughout the front hall and foyer. Each one has been handpicked to stare back and follow people as they move through the house.

Other rooms close to completion include a men’s parlor, a study, a family chapel and multiple themed bedrooms, such as a wedding chamber, the Egyptologist’s room, the Naval officer’s room and a nursery.

“Naturally, you have to have a nursery in your creepy Victorian house,” he said.

The house, however, still has plenty of room left for more themed areas. Nalbach already has plans for a room with Lord Byron-esque overtones, a greenhouse, an upstairs laboratory and Lovecraftian observatory tucked away in the cupola.

“I think there’s been a long gradual accumulation of ideas,” he said.

Railroad men

When Nalbach first began looking for a Victorian home, he had a few options in St. Albans. When the Central Vermont Railroad moved its headquarters to St. Albans in the latter half of the 19th century, the railroad brought with it a wave of upper middle class families composed of mostly railroad managers in St. Albans. 

Those most successful built large homes on the slopes of the city, and residents can still find the grandiose structures lingering throughout St. Albans neighborhoods, usually changed or rehabilitated for modern needs.

Nalbach and Vincent ended up buying John Hobart’s.

Originally from Randolph, Hobart got a job at age 18 in the railroad’s construction department after spending a few years learning the “mercantile arts” in Boston. From there, Hobart slowly climbed the company ladder, first becoming a freight clerk, then Montpelier’s station agent until he became the general freight agent for the railroad in 1859.

He moved to St. Albans in 1861 and stayed there until his death from kidney failure in 1897. He was 69. 

As his obituary explains, Hobart was active in the local community, serving as director of the Welden National Bank, vice president and director of the Fletcher Granite Company, founder and director of the National Car Company, a trustee of the St. Albans Cemetery Association and a trustee of the Episocopal diocese of Vermont. 

As for the house’s unique look, Hobart and his wife, Mary Jane Hobart, would have been the ones involved in making the call on the final design of the building, which utilizes a few popular architectural features of the period, such as a mansard roof, a unique slate pattern and a large accessible cupola, known as a belvedere. 

The building also saw Hobart’s death. He died at his Bank street residence just after midnight on Oct. 17, and Mary Jane hosted his funeral service there two days later “in keeping with what it is believed would have been his own wishes.”

Another railroad man, Michael Magiff, purchased the building after Hobart passed away, and like Hobart, he ended up raising his family in the house, as well as dying there.

Magiff also would have been one of the Central Vermont Railroad’s bigger names by the end of his career. A news article published in the 1920s describes a scene where Magiff – the “dean of the railroad officials” – played a prominent role in the surprise birthday party of his boss, E.C. Smith, who was turning 70 that year.

“(Smith) was hardly seated in his chair when officials of the road began to file in from the adjoining office of the general manager,” an article from the period reads. “(Magiff) stepped forward and with a brief presentation speech put into the hands of former Gov. Smith a beautiful silver loving cup.”

According to the article, Magiff was something of a bridge between the Smiths in charge of the railroads. J. Gregory Smith – responsible for administering the major buildout of St. Albans railroad facilities in the late 19th century – worked with Magiff when J. Gregory’s son, Edward Curtis, was still in college at Yale.

Michael Magiff eventually died in 1935 at the age of 83. He had worked with the railroad for more than 60 years, and played an instrumental role in the construction of Bellows Free Academy, as he was the chairman of the board at the time. 

During the 40 or so years that Magiff owned the Bank Street house, he and his family made ample use of it. The society pages from the 1900s, 1910s and 1920s are filled with mentions of various social functions – such as readings sponsored by the Daughters of the American Revolution, meetings of the Married Ladies Whist Club, and a Seven Hand Euchre tournament – held at the residence.

In 1904, Magiff’s wife and daughter, Frances and Frances Eliza, even hosted the opening of the St. Albans social season at the residence, bringing in 200 people to enjoy Ryan’s Orchestra and food from Coons, out of Burlington. 

Three years later, Miss Magiff found a suitable match. She was married at the house in 1907 during a grand ceremony to William McLeod.

“After the assembling of the company at 8 o’clock, an orchestra which was stationed in the upper hall played the “Bridal Chorus” from Lohengrin (known in the 2020s as ‘Here Comes the Bride’) as the bride and groom came down the stairs and proceed to the parlor where the ceremony took place as they stood under a bower of Southern smilax banked with palms,” the Messenger’s society pages read. 

Melinda McLeod, Frances Eliza’s granddaughter, still has photos from the event.

Connecting to the past

After Frances Eliza married her husband, William McLeod, they had a son, Robert McLeod, who lived in the house with Shirley, his wife, and they raised a family there over the last few decades.

When Nalbach purchased the building, he made sure to contact the family, starting a conversation with Melinda McLeod, who was one of children who grew up at 73 Bank Street. During a tour of the place, he said they began to see some interesting commonalities between what had come before and Nalbach’s vision for the place.

“What we began to notice was that, without having seen any of these historical photos in advance, we had been inadvertently replacing a great many of the things that had originally been in the house, often in exactly the same spot!” he said via email.

It seems that in his hunt for historical accurate pieces, Nalbach ended up restoring actual history. After the tour, Melinda sent photos she had from her time growing up in the house, showing historical evidence of an old grandfather clock, bed frame and lion-footed oval mirror that had modern doppelgangers in Nalbach’s version of the house. 

The picture of Frances Eliza taken on her wedding day even matched an old cake topper purchased by Nalbach.

Of course, Nalbach still has work to do to finish his project, and he expects the final version will likely be an embellished version of the Victorian era, but by keeping to certain styles, he’s replicated some of the same look and feel. 

“It’s finding ways to make people uncomfortable and also very in line with the Victorians' obsession with death,” he said.

As for his future plans, Nalbach is playing around with different ideas to use what he calls “The Highbank Hall.” Due to the unique staging he’s implemented, he’s considering making the house available for private social functions, although exact plans are still up in the air.

Until then, he’ll keep finding different ways to add his own touch to the house’s long history as one of St. Albans’ Victorian homes.

“My whole life I've wanted a house like this,” he said.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here