Another go at recreation; New building back on Swanton Town agenda

Posted

SWANTON – The Swanton Town Selectboard is once again moving forward with a new recreation building.

The idea to build out an expanded space for Swanton Recreation has been a consistent topic for the municipal board for the better part of a decade, but now, the federal funds set aside for the build – roughly $600,000 committed in 2022 – have an expiration date set next year.

By the end of their latest discussion, selectboard members voted unanimously to support the construction of a 125 by 80 foot building at the lower end of the Swanton recreation ball fields and tasked the recreation commission with getting a cost estimate as a starting point for further development discussions.

“If Swanton is going to be the type of community that I envision it to be, we needsomething like this. It demands it,” selectboard member Earl Fournier said, during the board’s Nov. 18 meeting.

Arrested development

While many local municipalities used American Rescue Plan Act dollars to fill in various capital needs brought forward by the COVID-19 pandemic, the Town of Swanton committed $600,000 to help build out a new recreation facility.

The federal funds, however, came with a deadline. ARPA dollars need to be spent by 2026, and while the board already committed the funds, the town still needs a development plan.

With that said, discussions around a new expanded recreation department building have been ongoing for years. Throughout both 2022 and 2023, the selectboard sought out additional properties, and eventually paid for a feasability study to get the ball rolling on a new recreation building.

Meanwhile, the Swanton recreation commission – a separate body tasked with overseeing the department – had already started working with Cross Consulting to come up with some early engineering sketches and designs with the the latest rendering, revealed in Dec. 2023, showing a facility built within the recess of the hill.

Two years later, it seems that vision has been largely scrapped.

The selectboard started their latest discussion this past month trying to find the most cost effective entry point. Nicole Draper, who is a selectboard member as well as the recreation department’s director, offered the approach – a $200,000 metal shell of a building that would effectively serve as a 125 by 80 space for a gymnasium.

“The gymnasium is such an important piece to holding recreational programming and we can continue to add on to our existing budiling,” she said.

Draper recalled being contacted by people with Sen. Bernie Sander’s office, as they were inquiring to see if Swanton had any available space for one of the senator’s “Basketball with Bernie” events.

Lacking a facility, Swanton had to pass. They didn’t have any space available, Draper said, but a limited gymnasium could at least fit that need if it happened again.

The resulting selectboard discussion revolved identifying the top needs of the recreation department. The rec commission, chaired by Betsy Fournier, had brought six top capital needs of the larger department to the board to consider. A new building sat at the top spot of her list.

Selectboard members subsequently batted around the best approaches to get the plan moving after everyone on the board agreed that the recreation department needed more space than what they currently have. The department, as it is now, operates out of a small space on Jewett Street reconfigured for its needs.

“We have to do something. There’s no question,” selectboard member Steve Bourgeois said.

But what will be the price tag?

Next steps

While the selectboard agreed action was needed, a major hang-up continues to be the cost. Two years ago, the selectboard largely ceased talking about the project publicly when voters made it clear that they wouldn’t support property tax increases to pay for a new building.

That spring, public outcries around affordability and inflation hit their zenith in the national media, and Swanton Village voters rejected financing the construction of a new public safety building. Draper said the selectboard “read the room” at the time, opting to push back the discussion.

During the board’s Nov. 18 meeting, those cost concerns still remained, although selectboard members largely agreed that it was time to start paying for capital needs.

Both a department vehicle as well as an additional storage shed, for example, were discussed as costs that the board could quickly cover while they discussed the larger building project, although there’s still some question on what to do with the recreation department’s existing building.

Selectboard chair Joel Clark led the discussion on that front, advocating for a more substantial upgrade to the current facility while the board develops plans for a gymnasium building. He said the final construction for a new builing is likely four years down the line, and the recreation department needs something now that would be more substantial than what’s available.

The new building could also lack office space for a substantial period. To keep costs down, selectboard members voted for cost estimates of a slimmed down building that could be upgraded over various phases. “Phase 1” would consist largely of a gymnasium, foyer and bathrooms, and office space would be built out down the line as needed.

The final say on what the selectboard will do, however, will be left up to voters when the board is ready to present its findings.

During their latest discussion, for example, selectboard members had no major cost estimates for a building, although the lowest projection – around $200 per square foot – would mean that the most basic structure would be priced at $2 million.

Looking at past development and planning efforts in 2023, engineers put the building cost at $3.6 million for a streamlined facility, while an estimate for a more substantial two-story building set its construction cost at $4.5 million.

Selectboard members agreed that the local options tax could cover the annual fee, although Swanton voters would still need to approve the move. Or the selectboard could propose another way to pay for the building, such as a bond vote.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here