After tight races, what’s next? Recount for Headley/Cross, Swanton goes back to drawing board

Posted

FRANKLIN COUNTY — While Town Meeting Day came and went this past Tuesday, a few razor-thin margins in voting results are leaving some outcomes unresolved.

In the Town of St. Albans, candidate Bob Cross formally filed for a recount this Monday after the race for St. Albans Selectboard ended up returning 447 votes cast for him, and 448 votes for Amanda Headley.

And in the Village of Swanton, village trustees are returning once more to the drawing board after watching their proposed electric department building project get rejected thanks to a 6-vote margin.

“It’s deeply disappointing,” Swanton Village Manager Bill Sheets said. “The root cause of the project — the space issues — have not gone away or been alleviated at all.”

A call for recount

After watching the St. Albans Town selectboard candidate vote come in Tuesday night, Town Manager Sean Adkins said he and Town Clerk Anna Bourdon have been working to establish the recount process, expected to be completed next week by the town’s Board of Civil Authority.

Adkins said the recount will be completed with an equal number of Republicans and Democrats, as represented by the 15 justices of the peace that make up the board. The final official count is currently scheduled for next Monday.

Under state law, any candidate who sees results within a 5% margin of total votes cast has the right to have the votes recounted, as long as the request is filed within 10 days. Cross filed the next day, with the recount outcome expected to make the final determination on who sits on the board.

Headley and Cross have been competing for a spot on the board since a spot opened up this past November. At the time, the St. Albans Selectboard opted to appoint Headley to the position following short interviews with both candidates, and the election results — for now — seem to back up that decision. Due to the slim margins, however, Cross effectively needs one ballot to be miscounted to reverse the decision.

Another go at the drawing board

The Village of Swanton has spent part of the last two years working to convince residents that the local municipality needed a new building, but after voters said “no” twice, it’s now up to the five-member Swanton Village Board of Trustees to determine what’s next.

Sheets said the trustees will have their first meeting following Town Meeting Day on March 10 to start their conversation around what to do to meet the village’s future space needs.

If voters had said “yes,” the electric department project would have made additional room available in the village’s 50-year-old municipal building, but now the police and highway departments are stuck with what they have until trustees can come up with an alternative approach.

Sheets said trustees and the project’s design team — made up of experts from architectural firm Wayman Lamphere and construction company Connor Contracting — have already worked for two years to find something that would make sense for the voters.

Other projects were considered during this time, Sheets said. The first iteration of the electric department building project — originally developed as a public safety building — was itself a re-working to help replace the impact on property tax rates with a smaller impact on electric rates, bringing the cost to 30 to 60 cents a day for Swanton electric ratepayers.

A lease-to-own option also made it onto the consideration list — St. Albans City took the approach to create its own new police department building back in 2021 — but Sheets said the overall price-tag ends up being higher for taxpayers in the long run, as such deals often require a third-party that adds to the cost overall.

Instead, the village had banked on voters to help give them the necessary bonding authority to borrow $8.3 million towards the electric department build.

Sheets said the village, however, didn’t see much engagement from voters on the issue. Prior to seeing the final results on Town Meeting Day, both Sheets and Village President David Winchester explained they were having difficulties showing people how the proposed public safety building and the latest electric building proposal were different.

They also held multiple public informational meetings in the run-up to Town Meeting Day to try to help people prepare for the vote.

“We thought we did that, and in the first three meetings nine people showed up,” Sheets said.

What now?

Overall, turnout was low for this past Town Meeting Day, with many municipalities in Franklin County reporting that less than one-fifth of registered voters actually participated this year. Civic engagement has also been on a down-swing for decades.

What many municipal officials have noticed recently, however, is that there just aren’t many bodies willing to volunteer, or even engage with the information being released by towns, cities and villages.

A recent Vermont report on civic engagement, released by Secretary of State Sarah Copeland Hanzas, estimated that just under 60% of municipal officials report they’re having difficulties getting people involved and informed on the local governance level, with some making extra efforts to reform websites, or even hire communication coordinators as advertised by the Town of Colchester, to help.

For the Village of Swanton, that low engagement rate led to just over 300 people being responsible for voting for a $8.3 million project, with six people casting the deciding ballots.

“We all recognize that it’s an issue. If someone knew how to solve it, we’d have solved it already,” Sheets said. “Our concern is, if you walk in and have a ballot in front of you — and it’s the first time you’ve seen that — that’s a problem for us.”

Meanwhile, Swanton’s municipal building will just keep getting older. Sheets said almost everyone he’s talked to about the building’s needs agrees that police officers need more room, with Chief Matt Sullivan still using closets for evidence lockers.

“I can’t imagine the scenario if we could alleviate those space needs for cheaper than what we’re proposing right now,” he said. “It’s time to have the candid conversation. If we don’t do something fairly soon to alleviate space conditions in the police department, we are three to five years away from not having a police department.”

#sanltop

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here