This story has been updated May 21 at 9:20 a.m. after hearing back from selectboard member Josh Blake.
FAIRFAX – A pattern of in-fighting is developing at Fairfax selectboard meetings. Tensions boiled over Monday night when some members attempted to address the issue.
The conference room was filled to the brim with residents and interested parties May 19 as members of the board decided it was time to clamp down on aggression coming from the audience and the board itself.
“Public comment is going to be your only time to talk,” Chair Bryce McNall said to residents. “I didn’t want it to come to this, but the last few meetings have been pretty impossible. I tried to be lenient… but I feel like I’ve gotten taken advantage of.”
The board has faced a growing number of hot topic issues over the past year which members of the public have wanted to weigh-in on. Last year, residents signed a petition to rescind the town manager position, but that move ultimately failed at the ballot box. Then, tensions rose earlier this month about how to handle parking on Hunt Street during school construction.
Vice Chair Tim Burns said conversations in town about these issues and more have been unproductive, leading to a less collaborative community.
With permission from McNall, Burns read a letter he wrote to residents addressing the tensions.
To begin, he said Fairfax deserves to know the truth. The aggression in board meetings is “wasting time” and an "embarrassment of the board,” he said.
At the last board meeting, residents of the town accused selectboard members of signing bills, ordinances and policies without understanding what was written down. This complaint had been levied to the board before during the town manager discussions.
“Just because a board member you personally know does not have the competence to understand items he voted for… don’t assume the rest of us don’t understand it,” Burns read from his letter.
Burns pushed back and inferred member Josh Blake has been feeding information to residents to control the conversation.
“To the gentleman who lectured the board on financial oversight and policy. Since when did you become a financial expert?” he said. “It is clear you are being spoon-fed your information from a specific board member.”
Burns said that resident had held up the 19-page internal control policy document, while simultaneously “bashing” it for not being on the website.
Lastly, directed specifically to Blake, Burns said his antics in the last few board meetings have been disrespectful, “thinking you’re a dictator and a self-proclaimed expert.” His aggression is “harassment” and has created a hostile work environment for town staff, Burns said.
All of this stems, according to Burns, from Blake not being hired as a member of DPW last fall.
“And now you have a personal vendetta against the director and the department,” Burns said. “It’s clear and it’s been evident in your short time on this board, that you don’t have the ability for forward thinking to better this town, instead wanting to dwell on the most ridiculous, petty things.
Speaking to the Messenger, Blake said he was never in serious talks with the town to be a DPW worker. Instead, he said the public works department was understaffed at the time and previous town manager Sarah Hadd asked for him to lend a hand.
While Blake did meet with DPW director Brent Sheets, he never completed any work for the department, he said. Somehow, the story was miscommunicated.
“It was just to help the town. I was not looking for employment to make extra money,” he said. “For anybody who’s saying that I’m disgruntled or upset because I didn’t get hired by the town of Fairfax to run the pickup is totally inaccurate, 100% inaccurate.”
In his letter, Burns said it was unfortunate Blake ran unopposed back in March.
“As vice chair of this board, I will not tolerate your antics," Burns said.
Blake ran unopposed on Town Meeting Day for a two-year term on the board. He filled the seat vacated by Stephen Bessette. The Messenger reached out to Blake and he could not be reached by publish time.
When Burns finished reading, Blake asked for a chance to respond, causing a minor kerfuffle between the vice chair and himself. “Harassment” is a strong word, and Blake refuted it.
Blake told the Messenger later he was caught off guard by Burns’ comments.
Yes, Blake said, he had asked questions about policies and sent emails with his points of concern, but it came from the fact he’s new at being on the board.
“I’ll be honest, I don’t know what I was doing in the first couple meetings,” he said. “And those questions I still haven’t been able to ask anybody yet, so it’s just been kind of tough.”
In the end, Blake said what happened at the meeting was unfortunate and unnecessary.
“It just makes everything look bad and we all need to work together as a team and I don’t have any hate and discontent towards anybody in town at all, I think there’s just a huge misunderstanding,” he said.
The member-to-member arguments May 19 were put to a stop by a lone member of the public standing up asking them to “stop this pissing match” and figure it out after the meeting.
The board remained fractured 4-1 during a vote to approve last meeting’s minutes – usually a nonpartisan, uncontested part of selectboard proceedings. Blake was the lone opposing vote.
The selectboard’s decision earlier this month to tow high-schoolers parked illegally on Hunt Street didn’t go down too well with some members of the public, who showed up Monday night to voice their opposition.
Franklin West Supervisory Union’s superintendent and school board chair also made an appearance.
One parent had a car towed and said there is no sign indicating the vehicle will be towed at the owner’s expense and yet he paid to get it back.
“For those students to have those vehicles towed, they missed their class at the tech center, they missed their education," he said. “I think that’s something that should be looked at and a reimbursement for those fees.”
Blake jumped on the comments and said after the board made its decision May 5, there was no determination on when DPW was going to put in the concrete blocks.
“It would have been all avoided if it went a different way,” he said. “I did not call the school and I did not ask them to tow your son's vehicle … If I sat in that person’s seat I would have simply called Liz Noonan, the high school principal, at 7 o’clock in the morning.”
Blake said he would have told the school the crew was coming to put in the blocks and had students and construction workers move their cars.
“That’s how I would have handled the situation,” he said. “So how the situation was actually handled we need to ask other members in this town.”
School board chair Emily Aiken piped up to say the town and school have to work together more collaboratively for the betterment of the community and for the students.
“This goal can only be fully realized when we work together,” she said. “After watching the recording [of last meeting] I felt it was important to me to address some of the comments, and the tone at times stood out as concerning.”
Treating the two entities as town vs. school pits the community against each other, Aiken said, while also disrespecting the students who call both places home. To start collaborating, she suggested another joint meeting in the coming months between the two boards, to explore a shared approach to challenges.
Superintendent John Tague, given permission to speak as a non-resident, came in to also address the tone of the discussion. The phrase “these kids” has a negative connotation, he added, which compelled him to speak up.
“Having worked with ‘these kids’ for the past 32 years I’ve seen them becoming our students, their neighbors' kids, the future of our community, state and country,” Tague said. “When people ask me what’s the best thing about BFA, my response is consistent with our students.”
Two former Fairfax students, including the interim town manager, sit at the board table, he added.
Students may not be perfect all the time, but Tague said the animosity at the meeting for 16 to 17-year-olds was unacceptable. BFA-Fairfax wants to see its students succeed and wants to see the community support their kids, he added.
“Jump on our website, or Facebook page, attend a sporting event or play or concert and you’ll see what I've known all these years. These kids are pretty darn great,” Tague said. “I’m comfortable leaving our future in their hands. I hope the school and town work together to change the tone of the conversation.”
In other news from the May 19 meeting, the town received one bid to replace its outgoing auditing firm. The bid for Sullivan, Powers and Co. is $6,000 dollars higher than the previous auditing firm. By Vermont statute, the town is required to have an auditing firm look over each fiscal year.
“They are arguably the best in the state,” Interim Town Manager Nick Nadeau said.
The auditing firm will be locked in for the town from the last fiscal year to FY27, or three years.
Hiring for a new town manager will be underway shortly and will also be difficult.
“It’s going to be a tough pool,” Nadeau said. “I just wanted to get that going.”
Nadeau said it’s best to form a committee made up of selectboard members, town staff and members of the public as the manager serves in all three groups. The committee will be making recommendations to the selectboard before the board makes the final decision on the matter later.
The town will post to social media to gather those interested in joining the committee as part of the hiring process.
The DPW crew in town has unionized. Nadeau said the town is reviewing the petition with its legal counsel now. When a petition is delivered, it becomes effective immediately, Nadeau told the Messenger, though the town has seven days to contest if it would like.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here