SWANTON – The last two weeks for both Swanton Village and Swanton Town have been busy ones for the two municipalities as they move forward with an initiative to expand and professionalize the Swanton Police Department.
Swanton residents, however, have been dealing with a case of sticker shock.
The early numbers announced by the Village of Swanton back on Dec. 4 prompted further questions about the costs expected to be borne by town residents if they’re looking for 24/7 coverage from the Swanton Village police. Currently, town residents pay for eight hours a day from Swanton police.
“If the town wants the protection, this is what it’s going to cost,” Town Selectboard Chair Earl Fournier said Dec. 4. “I don’t think we’re ever going to get around that. We might be able to bring that bond cost down by working with the trustees, but what I’ve been hearing from most people, unfortunately, is that this is not affordable.”
Swanton Village initially purchased the property abutting its municipal center back in April for $400,000 with the goal of constructing a new public safety building in order to create additional room for village operations, and the village administration has been pushing forward with the public education aspect of the build in the lead-up to Town Meeting Day.
A joint meeting held Dec. 4, however, saw town residents concerned about the future costs related to the project, especially as much of the village’s goals require additional buy-in from town residents to help carry the $19 million cost of building a new public safety facility, as well as the operational costs of a department doubled in size.
For taxpayers across Swanton, the estimated cost just to carry the tax burden of the new police department would be 51 cents per $100 valuation. The average home sale price in November 2023 in Swanton was $330,000.
For village residents, the tax burden is already close to what residents are paying now for 24/7 police coverage provided by Swanton police. For town residents, however, it's more than 10 times the increase in what the town currently pays for 56 hours a week.
“We’re always going to see increases,” selectboard member Cody Hemenway said. “Unfortunately, that’s the world we live in, but a 1,100% increase, that’s brutal.”
Hemenway said he simply couldn’t afford the increase as proposed on top of other tax increases that the state education fund and local governments are considering for Town Meeting Day. Growing up in a low-income household, he said he already had experience being pushed out of Swanton due to increasing livability costs, and he couldn’t commit to supporting the initiative as proposed at this time. The rest of the town selectboard agreed.
Town residents, too, pushed back against the increase, asking if there were any other alternatives on the table to see if that price could be lowered.
The village administration, however, is poised to move forward with the plan as presented, due to the larger needs of the village. As Village Manager Bill Sheets has often repeated, the five village departments currently located in the Village Municipal Center are running out of room, and they need additional space to operate effectively.
Constructing a public safety building would help fulfill those operational needs, while delivering an increased service that town selectboard members have said they’ve often heard requested by the public.
“If we lose sight of it, and it goes sideways, we’re going to have no police in 5 to 10 years,” Sheets said.
The Swanton Police Department currently operates out of limited office space, with no salley ports or holding cells typical of a modern police department. Speaking about that need on Dec. 4, town residents said they largely support local police and they’d like to see something done to help police in their efforts. The cost, however, is the rub.
Fournier said he’s heard complaints from multiple town residents calling police to request service, but the limited time window that village police are contracted to cover Swanton can confuse residents when they’re looking for service. Typically, Vermont State Police can fill in the gaps during those non-village hours.
Swanton Village has also defined a need for a more proactive police service in order to combat an increase in drug crimes. Swanton Police Chief Matt Sullivan said his department has been busy putting together cases to drive drug dealers and their networks out of Swanton, but a modern department with more people would help expedite the process and keep crime rates low.
Additionally, taking the first step towards expansion would also allow the Swanton police to pursue additional regionalization efforts to spread out any potential costs to taxpayers. The idea, Sheets said, is to partner with additional towns as the new expanded Swanton Police Department gets off the ground.
This “regionalization” idea is not a new one in Vermont, Sheets said. As a former Vermont State trooper, he’s heard the discussions about the idea for decades as there are places without any legal coverage.
Vermont has county sheriffs to fulfill that role, but without much of a system for county government, sheriff’s offices are often reliant on forming contracts with towns and organizations to pull in needed revenue.
Sheets said that model has become untenable in today’s world due to workforce issues. As police departments wrestle with the best ways to increase retention and recruiting, contracting can be a dangerous foundation for a police force to rely on.
“Building a police department on the back of contracts is broken,” he said.
If regionalization can help lower costs, Fournier said he’d be willing to introduce the topic to neighboring towns looking for more police. While both the Swanton and St. Albans communities are discussing police expansion, many Franklin County towns – like Highgate – have been actively seeking out additional police coverage to deal with many similar crime issues as seen in the county’s more urban center.
Fournier visited Highgate’s selectboard just a few days later on Dec. 7 to see if they’d jump onto the idea.
“I think we can do something that is not as costly as what it’s being proposed right now, but I believe that we’re going to need a partnership with Highgate in order to accomplish that,” Fournier said.
After hearing the idea, Highgate Selectboard members showed some cautious optimism, although – like town residents – they had some consternation about the $19 million price tag needed to get started. Building a new building outside of Highgate using a portion of taxpayer dollars also caused a rub.
But if Swanton Village could find a way forward, they’d be willing to be a part of the conversation. A lower price tag would also help, Town Administrator Sharon Bousquet said.
“They’ve already picked out their contractor for a building that they didn’t even know if Swanton was going to go in with them,” Bousquet said. “It’s a little cart before the horse there.”
Either way, Fournier said they’re going to have to do something to ensure Swanton Police will be around for the foreseeable future.
“It’s not going to go away. No matter what happens in March, this is not going to go away. We’re going to have to deal with it,” Fournier said.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here