300 St. Albans residents and officials gather for forum on crime and public safety

Posted

ST. ALBANS CITY — Fear. Hope. Frustration. Compassion. All of those emotions and more were on display Tuesday night when more than 300 people showed up at city hall to discuss rising crime rates and public safety concerns in St. Albans. 

The topic has emerged as a community discussion point in recent months after residents and business owners took notice of recent increases in property crime and retail theft in the area.

“I am totally shocked at what has happened to St. Albans City,” resident Robin Bluen said. “Brings me to tears what’s happened.” 

People’s perception is reflected in reality. St. Albans Police Chief Maurice Lamothe said Tuesday night the department is responding to an increase in misdemeanor crimes, like shoplifting, thefts from motor vehicles, trespassing and loitering. 

Between January and June 2023, he said, SAPD responded to 37 calls about retail thefts from stores. During that same time frame this year, police responded to 161. 

But felonies on the other hand – like robberies and burglaries – are down year-over-year. 

Lamothe and the forum’s other panelists – experts brought in to answer the public’s questions – attributed the rise in misdemeanor theft to drug addiction, an expensive habit that can lead to difficulties keeping stable employment and housing. 

The drug crisis, Franklin County state’s attorney Bram Kranichfeld said, is nationwide. Dealers from out-of-state are supplying drugs to Vermont and crimes are rising subsequently as people get desperate for cash to fuel their addictions. 

“To pay for it, they have to get the money from somewhere,” Lamothe said. “It’s an everyday hustle and they’re willing to work for it.” 

On Tuesday night, city councilors and town selectboard members, school representatives, legislators, social service workers and residents turned out to hear from the panelists about the complicated web of challenges and potential solutions. 

But tamping down crime has to be a two-pronged effort, panelists said, of immediate action to hold people accountable combined with long-term prevention work. 

“Often this conversation gets framed…either we can hold people accountable for breaking the law, or we can provide them with treatment,” Kranichfeld said.

“And I want to ask the question tonight: Why can't we do both?” 

Holding people accountable

While the panelists acknowledged more work needs to be done, each also shared what fixes are already underway. 

By this fall, SAPD will relaunch a two-person Street Crimes Unit, whose mission will be to identify illegal drug use. Chief Lamothe said raids can’t be conducted without a warrant, which takes time to justify. By utilizing two detectives dedicated solely to this work, the department should help produce results faster, he said. 

Rep. Mike McCarthy (D-St. Albans City) said the legislature listened to Vermonters’ concerns this session and passed a number of bills that aim to aid St. Albans and other communities facing similar struggles. 

The state budget, for example, which goes into effect on July 1, includes more funding for Vermont’s bogged-down court system. Greg Rainville, a retired judge from Franklin County, said the COVID-19 pandemic stalled many cases and the recent implementation of a new computer software was full of hiccups. 

“It was a perfect storm,” he said. “People were under such stress they were quitting…The system has been working with both hands tied behind its back.” 

The state budget, McCarthy said, attempts to rectify some of that burn-out with funding for more court staff, judges and prosecutors. 

Another piece of legislation passed this session was S.195, which rolls back some of the reform to state bail laws that was enacted in 2018. Previously, bail was capped at $200, which limited state’s attorneys and judges' ability to keep people lodged pending the outcome of their cases. 

S. 195 now changes how a defendant’s criminal record is considered in imposing those conditions of release. 

McCarthy also drew attention to H. 534, which increases the penalties for retail theft. Currently, retail theft and thefts from vehicles are misdemeanor crimes, which often means no jail time for offenders. H. 534 provides more pathways for tougher prosecution depending on the severity of the theft. 

“That’s another tool that our state's attorneys and our court system will have in order to advance these cases and take them more seriously,” McCarthy said. 

But for some members of the audience Tuesday night, these state-level changes are not enough. City resident Gene Kegler stepped up to the microphone to say he’s displeased with how Montpelier is spending his tax dollars. 

“[Police] can’t do their jobs. They are strapped with laws that let people (offenders) go,” he said, raising his voice. “It’s the legislature’s fault. Change the laws, and if they don’t, change the legislators.” 

Panelists also said the city’s public safety challenges are tied to Vermont’s housing crisis. Low housing stock and expensive rent have left some people with nowhere to go, and for Chief Lamothe, that explains the uptick in loitering complaints in the city.

For McCarthy, the stricter qualifications put in place on the state’s motel voucher program haven’t helped the situation. 

“There are a number of people who were housed in hotels and motels that now have nowhere to go,” he said. “There are consequences and costs to not funding those beds for people, and I think we're seeing some of the results of that.” 

Providing treatment 

Samantha Weber, the crisis clinician from Northwestern Counseling and Support Services embedded within the St. Albans Police Department, works every day to convince people to seek treatment for substance use. 

“I hear a lot of ‘No, I don't want help,’” Weber said. “But I want to be there the first time they're willing to say ‘yes,’ and for them to know they aren't going to do it alone.” 

In order to get sober, a person with addiction has to want treatment. There are very few circumstances in Vermont in which people receive involuntary treatment, which Weber said research shows is often ineffective anyway. 

But for those who do want to do the work to get clean, Vermont is seriously lacking in both treatment beds and mental health workers. During the public comment portion of the forum, Melinda White, who overcame her own drug addiction years ago, said the state’s residential treatment providers are easy to remember because there are just two.

“If somebody decides they want to get off drugs, where are they going to go?” she asked. 

She also encouraged lawmakers to rethink how treatment is paid for. Medicaid covers 14 days of medicated treatment in Vermont, but for many people, that’s not enough time. Further treatment is then on the provider’s dime, which can cause centers to struggle financially. 

“We aren’t funding what already works…we’re providing plenty of support for people to get on medications, but we’re not providing enough for them to get off and heal,” she said. 

These challenges are what prompted White and co-organizer Brad Ferland to start the Substance Use Addiction Summit, which will be held for its third year July 19 at the Champlain Valley Expo. The summit’s goals are to brainstorm solutions and advocate for change. 

Jody White, Melinda’s husband, also stepped up to the microphone to “give hope.” He said he needed to go to jail to get sober and has now been clean for nine years. 

“It took me to have to go to jail, to be put in time out for a period of time,” he said. 

What residents can do

While local and state officials have a laundry list of work to do to lessen crime and get people the help they need, there are ways residents can help in the meantime to make St. Albans a safer place. 

“So what can you do?” Weber said. “I can tell you to keep your hearts open and your doors locked and productive conversation flowing.”

Chief Lamothe shared tips – also available on SAPD’s Facebook page – so people can prevent crimes close to home. Keep your vehicle, residence and windows locked. Remove valuables from your car and property when not in use. Don't advertise on social media if you're going on vacation and will be away from your home.

He also encouraged people to use their common sense and to look hard at a situation before calling the police. While SAPD will answer any call, he does want to dispatch his resources to where they are needed most. 

“Some people are a little hyper-vigilant right now,” he said. “I want you to keep your property safe and your family safe, and I want you to pay attention, but we need to take a breath.”

Members of the public who spoke on Tuesday night were a true mix of long-time residents and folks who moved to St. Albans more recently. Many, before making any other statement, expressed their love for the city. 

“I love St. Albans,” said John McCarty, who moved here two years ago. “I want it to stay safe. Before it gets worse, we need to buckle down and get things done.”

“Don’t give up on us,” Rainville said. “Things are going in the right direction.” 

Watch the entire forum: 

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here