2 decisions impacting local policing agencies are happening Dec. 6

Posted

ST. ALBANS — This Wednesday, governmental officials will be making a few major decisions affecting the future of policing in St. Albans. Here’s a quick rundown on the potential impacts coming this week.

Joint Police Board budget meeting, between St. Albans Town and City officials

When? 7 p.m. Dec. 6

Where? St. Albans Police Department

Why? St. Albans Town and City officials are setting a foundational budget for the department's future. Basically, every subsequent St. Albans police budget will likely cost more than $4.8 million once city and town officials put their stamp of approval on their first this week. 

ST. ALBANS — The St. Albans Joint Police Board will be meeting for the third time this Wednesday evening, and it’s expected that there will be a vote on the proposed budget for the new and improved St. Albans Police Department. 

As proposed, next year’s budget would add $1 million to the town’s $1.4 million law enforcement budget passed last year. City residents will be paying roughly the same as last year, and the benefits would include coverage by a 16-strong force, a two-person street crimes unit, two mental health specialists backup and dispatching services for town residents. 

City officials, however, have argued the budget increase is necessary to provide mirrored police coverage to both city and town residents while tackling a growing drug problem in the county, and town officials have largely signaled their support to move forward with the new move.

“I think there’s a lot of value here – speaking for myself, not the entire selectboard,” Selectboard Chair Bryan DesLauriers said. “The street crimes unit, I think that’s like a big selling point for folks. The (crime) news hasn’t gotten better out there.”

Town and city officials attended their last Joint Police Board meeting back on Nov. 15. During the discussion, Town Manager Dominic Cloud and Finance Director Sarah Macy dived into budgetary details, and after roughly 30 minutes discussing how dispatching costs influence the final tally, town representatives were more apt to move forward.

“The way to drive down costs is what we’re doing tonight, is to achieve regional economies of scale so that we can stabilize costs,” Cloud said.

The two selectboard members representing the town – DesLauriers and town selectboard vice-chair Jack Brigham – said they’d talk to the rest of the board before casting a vote.

“I think with one more meeting, we can have full confidence and be back and clear in what we’re doing,” DesLauriers. 

They got that chance the following Monday during the board’s November meeting. St. Albans Police Chief Maurice Lamothe was also in attendance to answer questions about the department’s needs and resources as St. Albans police officers deal with an apparent flux in drug criminality.

“The whole state is seeing it,” Lamothe said. “When covid came, proactive police work went down, and we’re paying that price. Quite honestly, that’s a big part of it.”

During the meeting, selectboard member Brendan Deso questioned how expansion of the law enforcement budget would play out paired with a court system already dealing with an overload of cases.The topic of conversation, however, was quickly downplayed by audience members who supported more police spending, especially when “you can’t even walk down Church Street” in Burlington.

To pass the total $4.8 million police budget out of the joint police advisory board, a majority vote is needed by the six-person board. Town representatives are DesLauriers, Brigham and interim operations director Al Voegele. City representatives are alderpeople Tim Hawkins, Bob Farrar and Trudy Cioffi.

“What do you need to move forward out of this group? And my reading of the agreement is, I think you need four votes to move it forward, and it’s kind of structured that way,” Cloud said. “And once it passes out of here, then ... I think that it becomes each community’s responsibility to sell it, to raise their $2.4 million.” 

Once approved by the JPD, town and city voters will get a chance to approve the police budget as included in the larger general fund budgets voted on during Town Meeting Day.

2nd use-of-force hearing on Sheriff John Grismore

When? 9 a.m. Dec. 6

Where? The Vermont Fire Academy

Why? A negative ruling could result in the end of a policing career for the Franklin County Sheriff, a ruling in his favor could pose legal challenges for the state

MONTPELIER — A decision by a state committee could change the future of the Franklin County Sheriff’s Office this week, depending on what they rule in a use-of-force case pending against Sheriff John Grismore. 

The Vermont Council on Criminal Justice rules on and regulates the state’s policies on policing, and the committee of 23 people heard seven hours of testimony on Nov. 14 to consider the context of an incident involving Grismore allegedly striking a man in custody in August of 2022, in order to decide if Grismore’s use-of-force was reasonable.

During the meeting, the committee heard testimony about the incident from three deputies who had been in the room, including Grismore, as well as additional info from use-of-force expert Eric Daigle.

Much of the day’s legal wrangling, however, concentrated on how dangerous the man-in-custody, Jeremy Burrows, had posed to the team of deputies. Questions from Grismore’s legal counsel, Robert Kaplan, focused on Burrow’s violent actions – he tried to kick a deputy – prior to his arrest, and how the resulting situation at the station evolved to make it more difficult for inexperienced deputies to keep control of him.

In contrast, the state’s representating attorney, Kim McManus, argued that the shackles and handcuffs restricting Burrows from using his hands or legs eliminated any real danger from the clearly intoxicated man, and consequently, Grismore’s actions – when he used his foot twice to push back on Burrows – only escalated a situation already in control. 

Testimony has also focused on the danger posed by Burrows’ spit. Grismore’s father died as result of complications surrounding COVID-19, and Burrows had spit in a responding officer’s face before he arrived at the station. Grismore said he took his actions that day to prevent Burrows from spitting at a deputy again and potentially spreading the disease.

After the state’s use-of-force expert, Eric Daigle, downplayed the danger, Kaplan challenged the attorney’s testimony.

“Your attitude in testimony here is that police officers just have to accept getting spit on, and they don’t have the right to defend themselves from that conduct?” Kaplan said.

“That’s not what I said at all,” Daigle replied. “Just because he spits on you doesn’t mean you can take active resistance measures and kick him or punch him because of that. There is a retribution for that, and that is the criminal charge.”

As McManus pointed out, none of the deputies had taken precautions with a spit hood despite recognition of the danger. 

After hearing seven hours of testimony, the committee briefly met and agreed to make its deliberation during a subsequent meeting on Dec. 6. 

Grismore is also facing a simple assault charge for the same incident at Grand Isle Criminal Court. The House Special Committee on Impeachment Inquiry – which is investigating the Franklin County Sheriff’s Office for financial improprieties – is also expected to meet to discuss the latest developments on Dec. 11.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here