GEORGIA – Is the cost of technology in schools worth the price? The Georgia Elementary and Middle School board is weighing its options.
What started first as an attempt to save money for future fiscal year budget cycles, turned into a more widespread conversation between the board and school administrators over the use of technology and digital learning platforms.
At the school board’s April meeting, board clerk JC Thouin said Franklin West Supervisory Union’s lease for Apple’s education technology comes to an end in 2027, so it’s time to discuss the pros and cons.
“One thing I’d like to talk about, is right now there’s discussion about renewing the lease for the iPads in classes,” he said. “I think that’s something we should consider if it's worth spending for that [and] if it’s helpful for our kids or not.”
The approved cost of the Apple technology contract for fiscal year 2027 is $157,323 for GEMS. Technology for the school in total, however, only represents 2.9% of the entire $18 million budget.
Removing the technology contract could save the school money and lessen the need for IT support and resources. Thouin said he’s also concerned about the impact one-to-one technology is having on younger students.
“I’ve seen it in my first-grader,” he said. “The first thing he does when he’s in front of an iPad to type he’s using predictive text. He doesn’t try to figure out how things need to be spelled; he just types one letter and then, is it this word? Yes. He’s not learned how to spell words.”
Thouin is not alone in that thought, either.
Legislators in Montpelier already made moves to limit technology use in school after passing a bill last year which prohibited the use of cell phones at school. This year, they’re going further and considering creating guidelines around personal technology in classrooms altogether.
While the lease is approved at the supervisory union level, Georgia’s board can choose whether or not to use the technology in their school.
Still, Superintendent John Tague said it’s important to keep in mind the board’s job is not only to keep the school in good financial standing but also to create good opportunities for learning and prepare students for the future.
“I want to make sure we’re making the best decision based on finances and want to make a case, because I think to say we’re not going to have technology is clearly ignoring the future of our kids…” Tague said.
Still, Thouin said if the decision was up to him there would be no one-to-one iPads for students. Instead they would be given laptops to be used as a tool for learning with fewer personalized functions.
Karen Lehning, director of teaching and learning at GEMS, said any apps with some sort of gamification are strictly prohibited in classrooms. Instead, the school is using Freckle, an app used to practice math and English Language Art skills for short periods of time.
“Some of the ones that you’re talking about are the ones where it allows for students to have an opportunity for that instant gratification, like a game or something they get to do. It’s like Candy Crush, it keeps you going,” she said. “We intentionally selected educational apps here that go through a process to ensure they’re not something that has kids playing games embedded in.”
Freckle does have one incentive, however, in offering coins students can use to purchase hats for their avatars.
Technology in school is a tool for both students and teachers, Lehning continued. It can help keep students busy practicing on their own, while a teacher catches other students up with materials they might be struggling with.
Technology can make lessons or activities customizable, a practice called Universal Design for Learning. UDL is an educational framework for flexible learning environments to benefit all learners.
Schools across Franklin County have implemented technology in a variety of ways including one-to-one tech. In the Franklin Northeast Supervisory Union, students use virtual reality headsets to “see” cells up close. Students at Missisquoi Valley School District use apps to explore tropical rainforests or volcanoes without leaving Vermont. Maple Run Unified School District uses digital programs in its literacy curriculum and assessments. And in neighboring Fairfax, laser cutters and printers bring new tools to student’s fingertips.
In Georgia’s one-to-one use, Lehning said students are given ramps to assistive technology like having a PDF file be read aloud or to play a video if that’s how the student learns best.
“Our job is to use it as a tool to make learning accessible for all students and that really starts at Kindergarten for students to use it,” she said. “When you’re thinking about equity, tech is that equalizer for a lot of students, so to limit that is really challenging.”
And, as the gap between highest and lowest achieving students continues to widen in post-COVID classrooms, principal Steve Emery said one-to-one technology helps challenge the high performers and give learning opportunities for students struggling to grasp a concept or need more time with a teacher.
Still, conversations are ongoing with a technology committee made up of FWSU board members and educators looking at data and devices before making a recommendation for a new contract.
In the meantime, Emery said Georgia’s school board members should come in and see the technology in action.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here