Father-son duo puts Phoenix House 1835 on Vermont dining map

Posted

WEST BERKSHIRE — Is there such a thing as “Vermont cuisine?” 

At Phoenix House 1835 in West Berkshire, chef Tyler Sheridan is working to define the genre. He’s cooking up maple-glazed steak tips, brussel sprout tacos and grilled tomato and burrata, among other dishes that represent the Green Mountain State. 

“This is work, but it's also my passion,” he said. 

Tyler owns Phoenix House with his father Dennis Sheridan. The father-son duo opened the restaurant in 2018, giving new life to the historic 19th-century building at the base of Potato Hill Road, about a mile south of the Canadian border. 

Coincidentally, the restaurant will celebrate its sixth anniversary on Father’s Day, June 16. 

“We thought we’d sell burgers and beers and see what happened,” Dennis said. “It far exceeded our expectations.” 

New life in an old building 

Built in 1835 by Perly Hall, the Federal-style inn at 7 Potato Hill Road has a long history. Located along what was once a main thoroughfare between Boston and Montreal, the building started as a hostel, offering a hot meal and a comfortable bed to travelers. 

When the Civil War started, a garrison of Union troops was stationed there. Today, a photograph of soldiers standing on the house’s front porch hangs in the dining room. 

Over the next century, it served other purposes, including as a tavern, the post office, the hall for the Pike River Grange and as apartments. 

In the early 2000s, longtime Berkshire resident George Ewins restored the building, moving it back off the road, pouring a new foundation and renovating the interior. The project was part of Ewins' vision for a revived and bustling Berkshire. 

“I remember all the things that were right about it (Berkshire), and I see what it can be,” Ewins told the Messenger in 2004. 

In 2012, Amy Harrison opened up Phoenix House Restaurant and Bakery in the space. When the Sheridans took over, they added a professional kitchen. 

Dennis said the restaurant survived the COVID-19 pandemic due to the staff’s quick transition to take-out orders. As one of the few restaurants open for business in northern Franklin County, they gained a loyal following of regular customers. 

“We’re not on the beaten path, so we set out to make good food and make this a destination,” Tyler said. 

In addition to locals, Phoenix House also serves guests from nearby Lake Carmi, which can draw over 2,500 people to seasonal homes and campsites in the summertime. 

All year long, Phoenix House sustains itself by catering weddings, birthday parties and other special events. In April, the Sheridans opened The Phoenix Manor, 1845, a banquet hall in the old Methodist Church just up the road. 

With a brick exterior, steeple and vaulted wood ceiling, the church’s historic character is still intact. New lighting and a reclaimed bar bring it into the 21st century. 

Prior to its renovation, the church had been vacant for 20 years. This spring, it was bustling with life again, hosting 450 people for Mother’s Day brunch and Richford High School’s prom. For 2025, about 20 private events are already booked. 

Inspired cooking 

Back at Phoenix House, the standard menu is full of fresh green salads, grilled sandwiches and build-your-own burgers. The specials though, make the drive to West Berkshire worth the extra effort. 

Tyler changes the robust specials menu every week. This weekend, he is serving up maple-glazed chicken tender mac and cheese, lobster and shrimp risotto, garlic and herb crusted prime rib, as well as special appetizers, soup and pizzas. 

“I'll work a 12-hour day, then go upstairs and watch cooking shows,” Tyler said. “I have books and books and books. I’m constantly flipping through trying to get another idea or look at something a different way.” 

A graduate of Enosburg Falls High School, Tyler got his start in kitchens as a teenager washing dishes. He studied culinary arts at Paul Smith’s College in New York and has since worked in a variety of Franklin County restaurants, like The Abbey, The Tyler Place Resort and Mill River Brewing. 

Everything is made from scratch, from the maple bacon jam to the pizza dough, and Tyler has fun cooking with seasonal and locally-grown ingredients, like rhubarb and fiddleheads. 

Phoenix House recently created special dishes featuring maple for the Vermont Maple Festival’s Maple Cooking Contest, but Tyler said it's an ingredient he uses year-round. The restaurant won the 2024 contest with its maple bourbon burger and maple steak tips, among other entries. 

“Chefs sometimes don’t get the praise they deserve,” Dennis said. “But this award is all about his (Tyler’s) quality, his variety.” 

Family business 

While Tyler is in the kitchen, Dennis is out in the dining room, managing the seasoned waitstaff and working the bar. 

“This job can’t be done without the staff,” Dennis said. “I think if you add up the years of experience all of us have it’d be 150.” 

Regular customers are known by name (and often their drink order), and Dennis said it's that familial atmosphere at Phoenix House that sets the restaurant apart. 

There are more Sheridans involved, too. Dennis’ sister is the bookkeeper and sometimes his mother comes in to help out in the kitchen. 

“She’s the real boss,” Tyler said, laughing. 

“When Grandma Sheridan shows up, everyone needs to look busy,” Dennis joked. 

But for the father and son, it’s their team effort they are most proud of. 

“It’s one of the most enjoyable things you can do as a parent, work with your child,” Dennis said. “We do rub horns once in a while, but 95% of the time we’re on the same sheet of music.” 

The two are excited about what they’ve built in the last six years and are looking forward to continuing to bring good food to local people at the restaurant and the catering hall. 

“It’s amazing,” Dennis said. “We need to stop more and look around at what we’ve done.” 

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here