Will Medicaid cuts hurt Vermont?; ‘It’s going to be a rough couple of years.’

Posted

VERMONT — Sen. Peter Welch called it an “infliction of pain.” Rep. Becca Balint labeled it as a “moral failure.” And Sen. Bernie Sanders classified it as a “death sentence for working-class … Americans.” The federal government, however, went with “big” and “beautiful.” 

After watching Congressional politicians harangue each other for weeks, Republicans got their political agenda passed through both the House and Senate earlier this month.

Now, health care officials are trying to gauge and prepare for the impact.

“You just try to reassure people, and say, you know, we’ve got really good services. We’ve always been a good provider in the area and you have to just continue on. You can’t slam your brakes,” Northern Tier Center for Health’s director, Kathy Benoit said.

NOTCH operates eight medical/dental offices in Franklin County, as well as two pharmacies, a grocery store and a thrift shop.

One notch at a time

While it's hard to say how all the changes made by Republican legislators will play out over the next few years, there’s one avenue that health care officials are pretty sure about.

The $900 million federal cut to Medicaid will likely reduce revenues to Vermont’s health system, and it’s no secret the state is already facing big challenges covering its costs. 

“It is the worst scenario,” Benoit said. “Like someone didn’t think through the whole evolution of how this was really going to happen. You have people that are writing this down, they’re crunching the numbers, but they’re not looking at the downstream impact.”

At the same time, it’s difficult to know exactly what will change under the new bill. The combined work requirement and additional administrative burden imposed by the new bill is expected to kick an estimated 45,000 Vermonters off of Medicaid, equating to hundreds of millions in cuts for the state’s health care system after the new requirements go into effect at the beginning of 2027, according to state officials.

For local providers, that means they’ll likely need to do more education in the meantime to abate the worst impacts, Benoit said. To prepare, those who would lose coverage under the new ruleset can start making changes now to find new insurance, or they may be able to utilize a different program or categorization to ensure they can continue to access medical care.

Increased collaboration between health care providers can also help ensure that patients can maintain their access to a wide range of services without the need to duplicate the most expensive costs, like specialists or complicated equipment.

“If we can all kind of stay in our lanes and do what we do best, it’s going to be in everyone’s best interest,” she said.

A consultant report about the effects estimated that NOTCH would lose more than half of its Medicaid income – or about 65% – from the bill’s changes. About one third of NOTCH’s patients rely on Medicaid, Benoit said, but she expects that will change in the next two years.

But for NOTCH’s future budgets, Benoit is confident the federal change won’t disrupt their plans. Two capital projects, for example, are still moving forward without any changes expected.

They include NOTCH acquiring the Valley Crossroads building in St. Albans. Benoit said they’ll be merging with the practice after purchasing it from Northwestern Medical Center, and later, NOTCH’s Fairfax office will also get an upgrade.

Instead, she expects federal cuts will likely be reflected throughout the system as more specialized support services are cut throughout Vermont. This has already been happening to some degree as various hospitals and providers respond to lagging revenues.

In Berlin, for example, the Central Vermont Medical Center closed its inpatient psychiatry center at the start of this year citing a $3 million annual loss, and Copley Hospital in Morrisville announced  last month the expected closure of its birthing center.

The inherent danger over time, Benoit explained, is that each cut puts additional pressure on other medical providers’ throughout Vermont’s system, and if they become too common, then a mismatch between patient needs and provided services could put even more stress on the system.

The average amount of care needed for the average patient has already gone up in the last decade, she said. And when there’s more uninsured people relying on expensive emergency room services, health care providers have a harder time keeping costs and wait times down.

Additional providers

The Messenger also reached out to Northwestern Medical Center and Northwestern Counseling and Support services – the county’s two other largest health care providers – for more information about the expected impacts.

Danielle Roberts, director of community relations for NCSS, said the full impact of these changes on the agency and those it serves remains unclear.

"However, we remain committed to closely monitoring the situation and identifying ways to support the mental and physical well-being of our communities," she said. "We recognize that home- and community-based support programs play a critical role in preventive care. These services are not only cost-effective but are also essential components of the broader health care infrastructure that sustains and supports our communities."

NMC expressed some interest on the topic, but eventually declined to comment on the federal changes.

According to hospital spokesperson Kate Laddison, the bill’s changes are a major topic of interest for health care officials, but “we don't yet have a clear enough picture of the implications of the federal changes coming. We are very much in the process of digesting what news we're getting.”

Benoit said it’s not too surprising. Finding correct and accurate information has become more difficult since President Trump took office. For many looking for guidance on how to act, the sheen of politics has eclipsed much of the nitty gritty of policy discussions, and it can be hard to know who to talk to. Some federal bureaucrats that NOTCH had relied on for a quick answer for years have also disappeared completely, and the Supreme Court’s decision to allow mass firings has now been applied to the U.S. Department of Health.

Some things have just changed too fast for them to wrap their heads around before the next change erases all the work. Benoit said when new decisions come down the line, they often have to take a step back and refocus on their mission to get a better understanding of how to act in the moment. 

“I don’t see where any of the major services are going to be cut. I do think it’s going to be a rough couple of years, and I think it’s more than just the money. It’s getting people to understand the changes and making sure that they’re smart about these things,” Benoit said.

Editor's Note: This story was updated at 12:45 p.m. July 18 to include further comment from NCSS. 

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here