Will Highgate get a new library? New building option could change plans

Posted

HIGHGATE — The dream of a brand new Highgate library building is starting to see some cracks.

After a busy Town Meeting Day, the Highgate Selectboard got approval from residents via a non-binding vote to purchase 5 Gore Road and explore the option of transforming the building into a new library space.  

The Highgate Library board of trustees, however, isn’t too thrilled with the idea.

“(The Highgate Selectboard) are the ones that brought this to the voters,” library chair Rebecca Manning said. “(The library board) has been working on this issue for the last eight to 10 years.”

There are still a lot of unknowns at this point. Many cost estimates still need to be considered and discussions are ongoing. But when the selectboard and library trustees met this past Tuesday night, the disagreements remained after the discussion ended.

“To retrofit and remodel a building that's 150 or 160 years-old. Sure, it’s doable. Is it less expensive? Maybe, we don’t know that, but I think that it’s short -sighted,” Manning said Tuesday night.

Update on Village Core

Highgate has been considering creating a new Highgate library and community space for a few decades now, as its current building doesn’t have much room. Most library programs are stuffed into an area that’s less than 1,000 square feet. 

Getting a new build off the ground, however, has been challenging. Unlike bigger Franklin County towns, Highgate has no municipal wastewater system to rely on for larger developments, and so, the library has largely been waiting for the town’s larger village core project to start in earnest before any sort of fundraising for a new library could gain much momentum.

Two vacancies in the last year didn’t help. Both the former Highgate librarian, Adah DeRosier, and the former Highgate Town Administrator, Sharon Bousquet, ended up leaving their positions. 

Interim Town Administrator Carrie Johnson said the town also ran into some additional complications when the town’s initial fallback for the project’s water supply ran into issues these past few months.

Basically, the town had expected to extend new water lines out from Highgate Arena, Johnson said, to supply Cathedral Square’s senior housing project, but the state rules for public water supplies mean the town has to take additional steps to ensure the water line can even be used that way. Johnson said expanding a water line out from Highgate Airport or drilling a new well are also under consideration, but the overall impact on the project remains the same. 

Due to the complication, the town will need to spend another few years identifying the best approach to bring water to the village core. 

“We have other options, but the assumed working option doesn’t seem like the best path forward,” Johnson said. “It’s just such a huge project for such a small municipality, and the focus intentionally was on wastewater with water being important, but seemingly more straightforward. We just realized in the last few months that we needed to explore other options.” 

The wastewater system, however, is still on track for a future build, Johnson said. Letters went out this past month asking people if they’d like to be added to the wastewater system as the town finishes final permitting on the $6.8 million project.

Bringing a water supply to the village core though — and any related builds that rely on it — will have to wait.

Changes to the footprint

As the selectboard wades through its water problems, the Highgate Library board of trustees, meanwhile, has been eyeing the former Machia property as a potential build site for a new library.

The lot, which sits in the middle of town, currently houses an old hotel originally constructed in the early-19th century called the Stinehour, and the town purchased the site to make room for  Highgate’s new downtown area. Years later, an update to the old building seems less and less likely as the historic structure falls apart.

A few residents asked about the plans for the site in the run-up to Town Meeting Day, and selectboard chair Vern Brosky III said he toured the building and told the crowd during Highgate’s informational session that the floors had rotten to the point where people would be unsafe walking on them. An official feasibility study examining the property, however, has not been completed. 

Instead, the selectboard has turned its attention to 5 Gore Road, also known as the former Paws for Thought building. Located just a few doors down from the Machia Property, the lot under consideration is newer and in working condition due to more recent use.

Brosky said the building came up for sale this past November, and since then, the selectboard has recognized the spot as a potentially cheaper option than constructing an entirely new building.

Back in 2017, the architectural/engineering firm gbA estimated a 5,500 square foot building for a new library would cost around $2 million. Back-of-envelope calculations using inflation would put the price tag at $2.7 million in 2025 dollars.

The cost of renovating the Paws for Thought building, however, is still unknown.

On Tuesday, library trustees pushed the selectboard to know more about the building before moving forward with a purchase, as there’s currently $325,000 in taxpayer funds set aside by an earlier selectboard to help cover costs related to a new library.

During the informational meeting, the building’s owner, Sheryl Wilkins, said the market rate for the building is about $350,000, and she said some updates would likely be needed to turn it into a library, as the downstairs would likely need to be re-gutted and brought up to ADA-compliance.

Outside of that, the building has new wiring, plumbing, installation, sheetrock, doors and a new roof added, Wilkins said.

“I thought it would make a great space for the library,” she said during Highgate’s info session.

Library trustees, however, aren’t so sure. Back in 2017, library trustees worked with gbA to determine the feasibility of having a new library, and the firm’s final report examined whether a 5,600 square foot library would fit in the existing village core. It could, according to engineers.

The architectural firm was also instrumental in putting together documents used during the village core master plan community input sessions, when residents had a chance to weigh in with what they wanted to see happen in Highgate. Both housing — specifically for seniors — and a library got some of the most positive attention.

Manning and the library board contend the selectboard is largely throwing away that work in order to move fast on acquiring a property that doesn’t align with the library’s goals. 

“It seemed like the whole thing was incredibly short-sighted — to not know if they could fund a feasibility study,” Manning said. “All the costs are unknown.”

Tuesday night, the back-and-forth between the two groups largely centered around those costs for the new building, with little real clarification on what it would take to upgrade and upkeep an old building. Not much agreement was found.

“Paws for Thought has given us about a year — since the vote was positive — to pursue that property. The question is, as trustees, are you interested in that property? Because time is of the essence with (Wilkins),” Brosky asked the library board.

“It’s not what we’re interested in,” Manning replied. “We’ve been working for almost 10 years now on this plan, and we still think that it’s the right fit.”

The path forward, however, is the selectboard’s decision.

Back in 2014, the Highgate Library celebrated more than 8,000 visits with 10,000 items checked out, or circulated. Ten years later in 2024, those numbers have dropped to about 3,000 annual visits, and roughly 4,000 items checked out, according to Highgate town reports.

The proposed layout for the board’s vision includes expanded adult and children’s reading areas with books, as well as an attached community room, meeting space and a tech hub. 

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here