Who is at the helm?
Dear Parents and Taxpayers within the FNESU,
I am writing this anonymous letter in order to “blow the whistle” on the gross negligence and incompetence which has been plaguing our school district for far too long. Unfortunately, the public is very shielded from the decisions that our Superintendent, Lynn Cota, makes; this is confounded by the fact that her only boss, the FNESU Board, is only ever provided with information from Lynn herself. In this closed-loop feedback system, she feeds the Board the information that she wants them to know and that is how they make their decisions. While they do receive “reports” from the various school Principals on a regular basis, a reliable source informed me that Lynn has expressly instructed the principals to only include “the good stuff” in their reports so that it appears that all is well. This is how she is able to keep her job. As a teacher within this district, I am here to tell you that all is not well with our teachers, staff, principals, students and families, and also to express my serious concerns about some of the goings-on within our schools.
Thus, I humbly implore you to take the time to consider the following concrete examples of the abuse of power, lack of understanding of the actual needs of our students and families, and unconscionable fiscal recklessness demonstrated by Lynn Cota and her Central Office Staff:
1) Portrait of a Learner and our 9th grade guinea pigs: This program has supposedly been extensively researched by Lynn Cota’s Central Office staff for almost a decade and is being sold to teachers as “the solution” for everything. This initiative has included trips to faraway schools to witness the program in action and it involves 32 separate “indicators” which are best visually represented by a tree with multiple branches and leaves. This is now what this year’s 9th graders are enrolled in and represents all they need in order to graduate. All teachers are supposed to implement this multi-layered, complex behemoth into their curriculums yet no teacher has been trained on this and no teacher has been given any concrete answers about this. Furthermore, no teacher appreciated this being foisted on them after the school year had already started- that is like being in a moving vehicle filled with passengers and being told to rebuild the engine while in transit.
At a recent staff meeting between teachers and Central Office Staff, it was made abundantly clear that, in spite of our taxpayers paying the full-time salary and benefits of a lot of “experts” whose job it has been to research and create this, no one in Central Office actually has any answers about how this should work or be effectively implemented. Believe me when I say that Central Office does not have a plan, a manual, a blueprint or even basic definitions of this project: this year’s ninth graders are the real-time guinea pigs of this reckless and unfortunate experiment. Anecdotally, I have spoken to more than a few teachers who have hinted at this year as being their last year because they are so disgusted by both POL itself and its ungraceful handling. Parents of ninth graders should be asking a lot of questions about this.
2) Wayfinder “Social-Emotional Learning” (SEL) Software Package: Was the board aware of this expensive purchase? In an effort to apparently further reduce academic content and standards, Lynn Cota has now foisted yet another of her pet projects onto unsuspecting teachers and students. However, rather than asking any of the Central Office employees (like, for example, the Director of Social Emotional Learning?) to actually create anything, she purchased a “plug and play” type software package that all teachers have to show to their students for twenty minutes a week. The irony of showing a cheesy, public-service-announcement-style video as a means of teaching “social-emotional learning” is not lost on either teachers or students. It is horrendous. More importantly, what is the SEL Director doing now? She is not the one teaching this to students so how does she spend her time? Furthermore, this same SEL Director warned us during a staff meeting that this is a “very expensive program” therefore we need to make the most of it. Was the Board aware of this expensive program that, once again, has nothing to do with anything and that no teacher wants?
3) Hiring an outside consultant to create a new “Teacher Evaluation” form: Was the Board aware of this frivolous purchase? Lynn Cota hired an outside consult simply to create a fancy (and completely unnecessary) new form that Teachers use to do self-evaluations and that the principal uses to evaluate teachers. This could have been created on a Word document by just about anyone. The new form is so dense and absurd that neither the teachers nor the principals can actually do much evaluating as we have to spend so much time navigating and cross-referencing things. Is this really a priority? This type of meaningless busy work is a prime example of how disconnected Lynn Cota is with the actual needs of the schools, and also a compelling example of how little respect she has for district teachers and their time.
4) The results of last spring’s FNESU employee surveys were hidden: The Board members were never provided with the results of this survey. It would have been completed around June and it was an opportunity for all FNESU employees to evaluate Central Office Staff- including Lynn Cota. Lynn has refused to release the results because of how negative they were. I believe we all would be very enlightened if we were able to access these, and it would validate my concern that the Board is not being given the true story about anything. Prior year’s results were around 30-40% “satisfied” customers- have they sunk even lower?
5) Replacing zeroes with 50’s: Are parents, taxpayers and/or the Board aware that this was implemented in our High Schools? This means that students who do nothing and turn in nothing are automatically given a 50- that is the lowest grade possible now. This is unfair to everyone as it falsely bolsters students who are not trying while denigrating the work of students who are. It is also ironic that this would be implemented simultaneously with the POL model which, supposedly, is trying to create “transferrable skills” such as taking personal & academic responsibility, managing one’s time, and handing in work on time, to name a few. So, which is it? Are we teaching students accountability or are we teaching students that they can do nothing and get away with it? Or perhaps this was not thought out at all and this is simply Lynn’s way of artificially trying to boost grades/graduation levels so that it looks like her “methods” are working?
6) An authoritarian culture created by and enforced by Lynn Cota: She threatens those who disagree with her, evades transparency, talks down to teachers/staff, and utterly rejects democratic discourse/input. Although I am sure she presents a different side to the Board, this is the reality of existence for those who work under/with Lynn. Without breaking anonymity, suffice it to say that approximately half of the people who work in Central Office with Lynn report being unhappy because of how they are treated, multiple administrators report being lectured/threatened when they have wanted to have deeper conversations or express concerns about all of her projects, and teacher input is neither solicited nor welcomed. This absolute power has led to her being completely disconnected from what actual teachers/students/families need; she refuses to hear anyone else’s input. It is her way or the highway.
Based on what I have seen firsthand as a teacher, I believe that parents, teachers and principals all essentially want the same things for their kids/students: a rigorous, quality education in a safe, and supportive environment. I am sure the Board members probably share all these same goals, however, because of Lynn Cota’s selective truth telling, they have been led to believe that all of Lynn’s pet projects are creating those things and that is simply not the case. Put plainly, teachers, parents and principals want back-to-basics academic content, grades, rigor, behavioral consequences, and a reduction in non-essential, economically-untenable administrative positions; Lynn wants a “tree” with 32 intangible indicators to be the graduation requirement, falsely elevated grades, no oversight, absolute power to implement whatever new educational fad comes along, and a blank check to just keep on spending.
In conclusion, I think parents, taxpayers and the FNESU Board need to take a hard look at Lynn Cota’s regime and ask a lot more questions about all of it- including how people are spending their time and what they are actually spending money on. Again, the vast majority of people recognize that schools can be simplified and agree with money being spent on teachers, substitutes, and programs that actually benefit students (i.e. school lunch, afterschool programs, sports, transportation). No one, except Lynn and her colleagues, thinks we need more layers of non-essential administrators or busy work/pet projects. The fact that we barely have enough substitutes and it is hard to retain teachers here because of Lynn’s culture are real problems-not whether the form we use for Teacher Evaluations is glamorous. My concluding suggestions are:
1) I would urge you to contact FNESU Central Office and ask them:
a. To publicly release the results of last spring’s FNESU employee survey about Central Office (and Lynn Cota). They are all public servants and I believe we have the right to know how their employees think they are doing. They also need a dose of transparency and oversight.
b. To explain why they do not have a clear, step-by-step blueprint for POL design, definition and implementation after years of “research” on their part.
c. To explain why the actual needs of students, families, teachers and principals are not being correctly relayed to the FNESU Board.
2) I would urge you to contact your ninth grader’s school and ask questions about how and why POL is being implemented.
I thank you for taking the time to read my letter. I believe now is the time to speak out on these issues as they are negatively affecting the lives and futures of our communities and our young people. Teachers, support staff and principals are all held to certain standards of comportment: our Superintendent should be as well.
Thank you,
Anonymous
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here